KMC Comic Book Tiers

I actually banned fangirl from voting a while ago. But yeah, I think I set the precedent at some point that banned members' votes are discounted, unless it's a temp ban. His is not, btw.

Originally posted by Digi
I actually banned fangirl from voting a while ago. But yeah, I think I set the precedent at some point that banned members' votes are discounted, unless it's a temp ban. His is not, btw.

The Lightray business aside, I put my vote on Gorgon to mid.

Which should make it 3 or 4 for.

K, thx Kris.

Changes:
- Removed Darkseid and Dr. Manhattan entirely. The former because of power ambiguity and inability to come to a consensus. The latter for lack of feats to definitively place him.
- Added Gorgon to mid meta
- Added Immortal Hercules to low herald

Any problems with these, voice them now.

Originally posted by Digi
K, thx Kris.

Changes:
- Removed Darkseid and Dr. Manhattan entirely. The former because of power ambiguity and inability to come to a consensus. The latter for lack of feats to definitively place him.
- Added Gorgon to mid meta
- Added Immortal Hercules to low herald

Any problems with these, voice them now.

Originally posted by iceman24567
That sounds just about perfect 👆.

Just like Digi's round, fit buttocks.

Originally posted by Digi
K, thx Kris.

Changes:
- Removed Darkseid and Dr. Manhattan entirely. The former because of power ambiguity and inability to come to a consensus. The latter for lack of feats to definitively place him.
- Added Gorgon to mid meta
- Added Immortal Hercules to low herald

Any problems with these, voice them now.

Agree,

Lightray to mid vote.

we're voting on the inhuman gorgon right? not tom shoshido?

edit.

Originally posted by Starscream M
we're voting on the inhuman gorgon right? not tom shoshido?

No, Tom.

One question, why is Terrax in the same level as Sentry when Sentry completely destroyed him?

Originally posted by D_Dude1210
One question, why is Terrax in the same level as Sentry when Sentry completely destroyed him?

just like how Cyborg superman is in trans when superman has defeated him in the past.

Also, the lists aren't based on head-to-head matchups. That's only one aspect of their placement. Besides, there's only 10 categories, yet we have hundreds of characters. There will of course be some differentiation even within the various tiers. But yes, Terrax has justified his placement, despite that laughably bad showing vs. Sentry.

Skaar for mid meta

Seconded.

It's to early to put him on any "ranking" atm -IMO

Thurd

We'll hold off on Skaar for a while.

yea will know for sure when he moves to earth this summer

Anyone think Havok should be low herald.

no 🙂