KMC Comic Book Tiers

Originally posted by Digi
DS was removed entirely from the list for reasons that have been repeated ad nauseum on this thread. He's also discussed this with me in private and was told the same. .

Having imaginary PM discussions with Darkseid.

Originally posted by Original Smurph
Signs that you've been a comic mod for too long:

Having imaginary PM discussions with Darkseid.

The ALE it multiversal. Before being cheesed by a boyscout singing Aretha Franklin, 'seid popped in to complain about not being included in the list. I told him if he conquered the universe, I'd consider it. Sucks for him.

haermm2

Meh, I can't find the discussion on Cyborg, so I'll just ask - is his placement on the tier list with the SC rings, or not?

Because if not, I don't really feel he's got the combat feats to warrant his placement at high herald, let alone trans. He should be put down to mid-herald with other Superman-level beings who aren't Superman, such as Orion, Lobo, Captain Marvel, Supreme, etc.

I mean, if I made a vs. thread of Henshaw without the rings against Onimar Synn or the Destroyer or a PC Kryptonian or Onslaught or a Sun Eater (seriously?) it'd be closed for spite...

hmm

^ I mentioned the same thing couple of months ago. I don't agree with the Mid-Herald. But definitely not Trans.

Superman has more wins against Hensaw aswell.

High-Herald sounds about right.

Feel free to discuss. I'd comment, but Superman canon isn't my forte.

did gorgon get moved up?

Originally posted by Battlehammer
did gorgon get moved up?

I don't remember that we had enough votes, though I remember the discussion. You're welcome to tabulate votes and post them if I am mistaken. The thread hasn't been super-active recently, so it can't be too far back.

Herald

Middle
Rachel Summers (Phoenix II)

Is that with the Phoenix Force? As Seen in Excalibur, or with out it?

I said earlier that Gorgon should be mid meta, I changed my mind. He should be high meta.

Anybody know where we could/should place any Fables members?

At the very least Bigby could be up there. Maybe Boy Blue (w/ sword and cloak) and others too, though I dunno who exactly at the moment.

Gorgon for high meta

Originally posted by Original Smurph
I said earlier that Gorgon should be mid meta, I changed my mind. He should be high meta.

Anybody know where we could/should place any Fables members?

At the very least Bigby could be up there. Maybe Boy Blue (w/ sword and cloak) and others too, though I dunno who exactly at the moment.

Blue Boy's the most well known of that crew. He could pretty easily be placed.

Who else voted for Gorgon (or against) back when he was discussed? Because I believe you guys, but also can't change things based off of only a couple votes.

Originally posted by kgkg
^ I mentioned the same thing couple of months ago. I don't agree with the Mid-Herald. But definitely not Trans.

Superman has more wins against Hensaw aswell.

High-Herald sounds about right.

You're right. At least from '93-'96 he's got the uber feats. After that he gets beat by Supes straight up, Supes Blue (and Supes Red I think.) But still has enough feats to warrant a HH ranking. So I second that.

Seeing as how Blade, Wolverine, Midnighter, etc, are low meta...Gorgon being at mid-meta seems about right until he has more feats. No doubt they'll be coming in Secret Warriors soon. So, I'd like to keep him at mid-meta for now.

Originally posted by Enyalus
You're right. At least from '93-'96 he's got the uber feats. After that he gets beat by Supes straight up, Supes Blue (and Supes Red I think.) But still has enough feats to warrant a HH ranking. So I second that.

Seeing as how Blade, Wolverine, Midnighter, etc, are low meta...Gorgon being at mid-meta seems about right until he has more feats. No doubt they'll be coming in Secret Warriors soon. So, I'd like to keep him at mid-meta for now.

He has more powers then most of the high meta and would be the majority of them. He beat every one in the mid meta solidly ecpt maybe omega red who also should be a high meta.

Roughly how long has Gorgon been around, btw? And how many appearances does he have? He seems to have jumped onto the KMC scene fairly recently.

Originally posted by Digi
Roughly how long has Gorgon been around, btw? And how many appearances does he have? He seems to have jumped onto the KMC scene fairly recently.

He also only seems to have gotten better. While blind folded he wreck the secret warriors

Originally posted by kgkg
^ I mentioned the same thing couple of months ago. I don't agree with the Mid-Herald. But definitely not Trans.

Superman has more wins against Hensaw aswell.

High-Herald sounds about right.

superman has wins against everyone. it's not a gauge i'd use, tbh.

as far as henshaw's placement, i'd be willing to back a move, but not to mid herald. not a chance.

Henshaw being Trans is a joke, tbh. He got voted there right after he appeared to own Superman during the SC War but that didn't work out too well for him in the end.

The rings shouldn't factor into any discuss because for one, he has limited showings with them and two, they aren't standard equipment.

Seems like a fairly ardent consensus. Anyone else can put a voice in, but barring objections I'll move Henshaw down to HH sometime in the near future.