Originally posted by darthgoober
I doubt many people are familiar enough to vote that didn't already vote him where he is.
dam. He kinda were he is because I said low meta tier should be good for the thunder cats and all agreed at the time, but I dident realize weapons were taken into consideration, becuases the sword of O-mens is crazy powerful.
also cheetara is a speedster she should be moved up, I dident even realize classic quick silver was mid meta, cheetara faster then him and would kick his ass lol.
Originally posted by Alpha Centauri
I'd say votes for Tyrant for above Trans/Sub-Skyfather could be presented convincingly in either way, but I'm not really fussed with where he is now.I think he's in good company.
-AC
Tyrant off the list.
Against: llagrok, Harbinger, TricksterPriest, Nihilist, SuperiorTech, Alpha C.
For: Kurupt, Leonidas
I dare say the "for" group will require a ridiculous influx of votes for in order to make this happen. Usually we need like 5 or 6 more votes for then against. A move for Tyrant is highly unlikely.
A vs. thread reminded me of a suggestion I wanted to make a while ago:
Speedball for at least mid meta. When I researched him for an old tourney, I was shocked with what I found.
His best offensive feat is destroying an enraged Terrax. He was injured already, granted, but still not on his last legs. And Speedball's durability is what separates him from others in the same category. Punches, energy attacks, etc. all bounce off him effortlessly. He's been overloaded by energy, but it was with far more energy than anyone in low meta can muster. Surviving Stamford was no small feat either.
So Speedball for mid.
Originally posted by Kris Blaze
Tyrant off the list.Against: llagrok, Harbinger, TricksterPriest, Nihilist, SuperiorTech, Alpha C.
For: Kurupt, Leonidas
I dare say the "for" group will require a ridiculous influx of votes for in order to make this happen. Usually we need like 5 or 6 more votes for then against. A move for Tyrant is highly unlikely.
Still dodging the points I made Kris it's cool. We all know you don't have much of an argument against it but just want to vote know.. "cause it's already been voted on" If you really had valid points you would've made them. Shoot if you could contradict my points you would have. but you can't. I'll accept the concession.
Originally posted by Kris Blaze
Tyrant off the list.I dare say the "for" group will require a ridiculous influx of votes for in order to make this happen. Usually we need like 5 or 6 more votes for then against. A move for Tyrant is highly unlikely.
Actually, and Darth can correct me if I'm wrong but he said Tyrant should be removed from the list. Even barring the Galactus fight which I don't know why one would not consider it since it's very convincing. However, he said even excluding that Tyrant should be off because he just doesn't have enough to say one way or another. He has no low showings really and the showings he does have are pretty high. So, to him and what he said was that he should be off. So, really it's
Against: llagrok, Harbinger, TricksterPriest, Nihilist, SuperiorTech, Alpha C.
For: Kurupt, Leonidas, Darth
He can correct me if I'm wrong but his post did say that. Thanks
Originally posted by KuRuPT Thanosi
Still dodging the points I made Kris it's cool. We all know you don't have much of an argument against it but just want to vote know.. "cause it's already been voted on" If you really had valid points you would've made them. Shoot if you could contradict my points you would have. but you can't. I'll accept the concession.
Putting words in his mouth isn't a valid debating tactic, nor is "accepting a concession" that isn't there. He's got his opinion, you've got yours. It's a comic book tiers list...try not to act like you've been personally affronted.
Originally posted by iceman24567
Against Tyrant to off the list.
Adding.
Originally posted by Kris Blaze
Tyrant off the list.Against: llagrok, Harbinger, TricksterPriest, Nihilist, SuperiorTech, Alpha C, Iceman
For: Kurupt, Leonidas
Originally posted by Digi
Putting words in his mouth isn't a valid debating tactic, nor is "accepting a concession" that isn't there. He's got his opinion, you've got yours. It's a comic book tiers list...try not to act like you've been personally affronted.
What is he saying about me?
Originally posted by Digi
So Speedball for mid.
I can support Speedball being moved up.
His feats as Penance doesn't really suggest any higher or lower placement, so maybe you should add Speedball/Penance or add (Penance) like we do with alternate versions?
Originally posted by Kris BlazeI am for Tyrant being off the list. The guy took on a well fed, mentally prepared Galactus and was beating him. To have Tyrant on that list is insulting.
Amazo, Validus, Asgardian destroyer, King Thor, The Doctor, Resurrection man 1 million, all stronger in my opinion.
Feats don't prove Odin is on Galactus' level despite how awesome they are. Tyrant was on Galactus' level.
Originally posted by Kris Blaze
Amazo, Validus, Asgardian destroyer, King Thor, The Doctor, Resurrection man 1 million, all stronger in my opinion.
IMO Eclipso, Mongul I, Nightmare, Queen of Fables, Sun Eater, Supes 1M, and Tyrant all need to be off the list.
So the fact that all of them are on it, makes me fine with his placement. But were it up to me, those would all come off.
Originally posted by Enyalus
I think Tyrant should be above the transcendent category, but considering the people actually there, I have no problems with it.IMO Eclipso, Mongul I, Nightmare, Queen of Fables, Sun Eater, Supes 1M, and Tyrant all need to be off the list.
So the fact that all of them are on it, makes me fine with his placement. But were it up to me, those would all come off.
Are you sure about Nightmare?
I mean, Thor DID KO him.
Originally posted by Enyalus
But the cat does have his own dimension and Classic Dr. Strange admitted Nightmare was beyond his power, back when Dr. Strange was standing up to the LT and helping stop Zom, etc.Having your own dimension should auto-qualify ya for skyfather status, right?
Oh, THAT Nightmare.
I was thinking about someone else.