KMC Comic Book Tiers

Started by Original Smurph485 pages

Against Despero to HH.

Originally posted by Original Smurph
Gamora should be demoted from low herald...

Probably Forerunner too

Why do we have Gamora in LH, above people like Ironman, Sand, Invisible Woman, Northstar, etc...?

I agree with Smurph-o here.

Against Despero for HH and for Gamora down to HM

Originally posted by Endless Mike
In Trinity Despero went HtH against Konvikt and did fairly well (Konvikt was wrecking the JLA by himself)

that is impressive.

Originally posted by Enyalus
I haven't read all of Trinity, either. I stopped after like issue 18, and even that was too far.

S/B wasn't due to mind rape, though, so really has no bearing on his power level. And he was still tooled by Superman. Like he usually is.

I'd move Despero to High Herald. His appearances with the Flame of Pytar powerup were PC, weren't they? And V&V is probably his best showing, Post-Crisis. Even that reeked of PIS. I don't have the comic in front of me, but I think it was Power Girl and Hourman who were thrown to the ground by Despero and simply never got back up. And it was either Captain Marvel or Superman who was tugging on Despero's cape in one scan, and in the next, he simply wasn't there at all. It was just...a strange battle. And his durability definitely didn't seem trans-like or higher, which is consistent with all of his other appearances.

For Despero to HH.

And I don't know enough about ST to render a vote on him.

i never said it was mindrape. 😛

eh, against despero. if he did match konvikt one on one, that's pretty impressive, and keeps up his usual team wrecker status...

Despero has been wrecked by Young Justice (sans Cassie, Secret, Empress, and Slobo). Move him down.

istilldon'tseezatannaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa

Originally posted by tjcoady
Despero has been wrecked by Young Justice (sans Cassie, Secret, Empress, and Slobo). Move him down.

different despero 😛

Originally posted by -Pr-
different despero 😛

Oh I know.

I just like to rep Young Justice.

And in their defense he was possessing the Martian Manhunter at the time.

Did Agents of Atlas 9 and The first five issues in Hardback come out this week?

Originally posted by Original Smurph
Why do we have Gamora in LH, above people like Ironman, Sand, Invisible Woman, Northstar, etc...?

i agree--drop gamora to HM.

still not entirely sure of despero, but i'll officially rescind my vote.

can anyone tell me who they think he would cleanly defeat in the trans tier though? it seems he is pretty much the low-man on that particular totem pole.

Originally posted by leonidas
i agree--drop gamora to HM.

still not entirely sure of despero, but i'll officially rescind my vote.

can anyone tell me who they think he would cleanly defeat in the trans tier though? it seems he is pretty much the low-man on that particular totem pole.

Blackheart and Mongul, in my opinion.

blackheart? hmm, maybe. pre-c mongul? less sure of that one . . .

Originally posted by -Pr-
eh, against despero. if he did match konvikt one on one, that's pretty impressive, and keeps up his usual team wrecker status...

The same Konvikt who was stalemating a wounded Wonder Woman? 😛

Originally posted by leonidas
blackheart? hmm, maybe. pre-c mongul? less sure of that one . . .

Yeah, I don't agree. The Mongul up there on the list is the original, Mongul Sr. Despero might beat Pre-Crisis Mongul Jr. (he's the one in the For the Man Who Has Everything issue, for example). But, Despero not taking out the one who is listed on the trans tier currently.

Don't know enough about Blackheart to comment on him.

Oh, I'm for moving Gamora to high meta status. And reiterating my position for Despero to high herald. 😛

Gamora has been unanimous. I'll make the move at some point, and we can stop voting on her. Anyone want to do a tally for/against Despero?

I've counted 248 people for moving Despero to HH, 4 against.

I don't really see the logic in moving somebody just because they're the lowest powered in their tier.

Then we'd end up with only one person in each tier.

I'd say Despero is usually depicted doing better than a herald-level would in most of his battles, and is a usual team wrecker.

Originally posted by Original Smurph
, and is a usual team wrecker.

So are most villains. Lex Luthor included.

Oh, and Hulk.

Originally posted by Enyalus
So are most villains. Lex Luthor included.

Oh, and Hulk.

Hulk would certainly be higher on the tiers if he didn't completely lack versatility.

Despero happens to be a far more formidable telepath than Martian Manhunter, so versatility isn't as much of an issue.

Lex Luthor wrecks teams when he has prep, which is another matter entirely.

Originally posted by Enyalus
So are most villains. Lex Luthor included.

Oh, and Hulk.

Not true at all, in either case. What's the most powerful incarnation of recent Hulk? WWH probably. Was he taking down Sentry easily while fending off multiple other heralds? No, he was stalemating someone in the mid herald category, which is where he is and where he belongs.

And we don't include prep. This has always been the case. Mentioning Luthor is plainly ridiculous. You're reaching to try and garner support, but just looking silly.

Originally posted by Digi
You're reaching to try and garner support, but just looking silly.

Not really, to the first. Take a look at the high herald category. Most everyone on that list beats him for a majority, IMO.

That's what I, personally, use to gauge the power of someone. When half or more of the given tier in question are capable of beating the character in question.