KMC Comic Book Tiers

Started by batdude123485 pages

Originally posted by Digi
Be serious bats. If this is really your vote, then it means you didn't even read enough of the discussion to know what tiers she's being debated between.
Shut it.

Originally posted by batdude123
Shut it.

Darling, please behave <3

Originally posted by Digi
😕

I've had to clarify a few things. Happens every time there's discussion on a character.

I'm wondering exactly what we use to determine placements here? Individual matchups is naturally a bad idea, since some characters go better against others. But I can't think of any other cases where there is 1 character who cannot grab a single win from anyone else in his or her bracket. Versatility seems to be a factor. That's why Kurse, Grundy and Juggernaut are mid herald I assumed. Overall power matters I suppose. What else? Experience? How complex their powers are?

Jubilee to Low Meta.

Originally posted by Kris Blaze
I can't think of any other cases where there is 1 character who cannot grab a single win from anyone else in his or her bracket.
You have got to be kidding me. You are seriously underrating her if you don't think she can pull a single win from anybody in mid meta.

Originally posted by Creshosk
You have got to be kidding me. You are seriously underrating her if you don't think she can pull a single win from anybody in mid meta.

I mean she can't get the majority out of 10 from anyone. She can get 1/10 against many.

Originally posted by Kris Blaze
I mean she can't get the majority out of 10 from anyone. She can get 1/10 against many.
That's different from "cannot grab a single win from anyone "

I've already said she'd be at the low end of mid meta. She can do okay against some of the mid metas though.

Originally posted by Creshosk
That's different from "cannot grab a single win from anyone".

Hence why I changed it.

Originally posted by Creshosk
I've already said she'd be at the low end of mid meta. She can do okay against some of the mid metas though.

She'd be at the absolute bottom.

Originally posted by Kris Blaze

She'd be at the absolute bottom.
Yes, I realize that.

Originally posted by Creshosk
If there were sub categories I'd put her in the low end of the mid meta tier.

But since they're aren't I'd say she's a bit closer to mid meta than low meta.

I believe the votes are 5 - 4 now?

Originally posted by The Nuul
I believe the votes are 5 - 4 now?

Yeah.

1 for high
batdude123

5 for mid,
Creshosk
Blari Wind
Digi
leonidas
Wagstaff

4 for low.
Kris Blaze
The Nuul
Blanket
Enyalus

I don't see how people don't believe she could beat many low metas if they started at distance. The girl can explode mansions, and has deflected energy and bullets.

Jubilee for mid

Originally posted by Kris Blaze
I'm wondering exactly what we use to determine placements here? Individual matchups is naturally a bad idea, since some characters go better against others. But I can't think of any other cases where there is 1 character who cannot grab a single win from anyone else in his or her bracket. Versatility seems to be a factor. That's why Kurse, Grundy and Juggernaut are mid herald I assumed. Overall power matters I suppose. What else? Experience? How complex their powers are?

Everything. "Total" power. We don't include prep or status, except as tiebreakers when someone is torn between two tiers for a character. But just their power...which is everything from experience and intelligence to raw power and versatility. And those total power gauges for each tier are determined by a composite of the characters within the tiers themselves.

It's not a completely objective criteria. But if it was, I'd end up closing the thread over the controversy that would ensue over minor details, exceptions, and loopholes.

1 for high
batdude123

6 for mid,
Creshosk
Blari Wind
Digi
leonidas
Wagstaff
Original Smurph

4 for low.
Kris Blaze
The Nuul
Blanket
Enyalus

H:1
M:6
L:4

Jubilee for Mid.

Skaar for high meta or mid meta

either works, he has the potential for high but has shown more mid things

1 for high
batdude123

7 for mid,
Creshosk
Blari Wind
Digi
leonidas
Wagstaff
Original Smurph
-Pr-

4 for low.
Kris Blaze
The Nuul
Blanket
Enyalus

Assuming Batdude is serious:
H:1 = 8.33~%
M:7 = 58.33~%
L:4 = 33.33~%

Assuming Batdude is not serious:
M:7 = 63.6363~%
L:4 = 36.3636~%

That makes 8 for and 4 against. I think it's probably safe to put her at mid. Thanks for the discussion guys, and I'll talk to batdude to confirm.

I also need to move Bizarro to MH, so both changes will be implemented soon.

Skaar? HM for me maybe LH.

Originally posted by Digi
I don't want to infer votes, so we'll leave goob out until he comes to solidify his position. Otherwise, thanks.

Others can feel free to vote as well. Be sure to read through the discussion some before voting.


You never actually answered when I asked if we were supposed to base it off of powerset alone like CBR and ignore how the characters are portrayed. If so I agree with the move, but if were judging off of what they've actually shown then I'm against it. I mean we have guys like Klaw, Firehawk, Warpath, Ironfist, and Warlock in the low meta tier, and I'd say that any of them are easily Jubilee's equal in raw power.

edit