KMC Comic Book Tiers

Would one of you chaps be so kind as to PM me a finalized list of changes to the street tier, and meta tier(when you've reached a consensus)..?

I want to edit those tiers on the master list as soon as possible, because the herald tier is going to be a real doozy.

#FirestormToHighHerald 😈

lol

and i nominate borg to organize the finalized votes since he's the last one--AGAIN--to chime in. thanks borg. you're awesome. 👆

😂

I'll send you the verdicts once Saint votes, Galan.

Thanks, Phil. 👆

Originally posted by leonidas
anyway, near as i can figure these are the characters in question by at least one of us:

Basically, I agree with all of these EXCEPT Slade and Hawkman. Seems weird that Bats with his toys is LM....and those two are a tier above.

yeah i agree. i guess i can't help but looking at how the characters would be WITHOUT their gear. in that way i see slade and hall above him....

But Hawkman is already mid-tier, so is this a vote to move him to low meta?

I'm for keeping him at mid for now [and I see Bentley is, too] so I guess it's a no change.

I'll try to tally the votes in a bit.

Meta:
Cyborg to low herald: 3 for 1 against, he moves
Nova to mid-meta: 3 for 1 against, so he stays mid meta
Blue Beetle to high meta: all for, he moves
Morlun to low herald: 3 for 1 against, he moves
Carol to high meta: all for, (s)he moves
Shaw to high meta: all for, he moves
Multiple Man to mid meta: all for, he moves
Reed to mid meta: all for, he moves
Gamora to mid meta: 2 for, 2 abstains, she moves?
Shang Chi: two for high street, two for mid meta, he stays at low meta (lol)
Quicksilver/Northstar/Aurora to high meta: all for, they move
Sinister for low herald: all for, he moves
Ambrose Chase to high meta: 2 for, 1 against, 1 abstain, he moves
Iron Fist to mid-meta: 3 for, 1 against, he moves
Jakita to mid-meta: 3 for, 1 against, she moves
Luke Cage to mid-meta: 3 for, 1 against, he moves
Spider Man to mid-meta: 3 for, 1 against, he moves
Ghost Rider to high-meta: 3 for, 1 abstain, he moves
Slade to mid-meta: 2 for, 2 against, he stays low meta
Kitty to high meta: 2 for, 1 against, 1 abstain, she moves?
Shift to high-meta: all for, it moves
Steel to mid-meta: 3 for (maybe? Darksaint agreed with leo, who proposed mid/high), 1 abstain, he stays..
Aquaman to low-herald: 3 for, 1 against, he moves

To summarize what has to be changed, and what I'll send Galan [if somebody wants to double check]:

Street:

Batman to low meta
Black Panther to low meta

Cap to high street
Winter Soldier to high street

Batroc to mid street
Black Widow to mid street
Catwoman to mid street
Damien to mid street

Two Face to low street
Kate Bishop to low street

Meta

Aquaman moves to low herald
Cyborg moves to low herald
Morlun to low herald
Mr Sinister moves to low herald

Ambrose Chase to high meta
Blue Beetle moves to high meta
Carol moves to high meta
Ghost Rider to high meta
Kitty to high meta
Quicksilver moves to high meta
Shaw moves to high meta
Shift to high meta

Gamora moves to mid meta
Iron Fist to mid meta
Jakita to mid meta
Luke Cage to mid meta
Multiple Man moves to mid meta
Reed moves to mid meta
Spiderman to mid meta
Steel to mid meta

Unless there are any objections to Phil's list, I'll make the edits to the OP master list.

Looks good to me.

But it's Damian, not Damien uhuh

Edited the OP master list to reflect the above changes to the meta and street categories. Give it a look and let me know if anything needs to be changed.

If everything is in order, we can start discussing the herald tiers.

"Don't say anything about Superman, Don't say anything about Superman, Don't say anything about Superman, Don't say anything about Superman"

I'll definitely be chiming in on the herald list... And not just for FS. I think there are quite a few changes that need to be made to that category in particular.

Superman to low herald

Thor to trans

Originally posted by One Big Mob
Superman to low herald

Thor to trans

lol i could have sworn penguin was on that list... would he even make low street?

Originally posted by leonidas
lol i could have sworn penguin was on that list... would he even make low street?

Well if there are no objections to the meta and street changes, I say we start revamping the herald tiers.

A few proposed changes from me right off the bat:

Waverider either moves to trans or he's off the list entirely because he exceeds the parameters. Same with Infinity-Man.
Imperiex Probes to trans.
Superman to trans(yes, I said it)
Maxima to high herald
Orion to high herald
Wonder Woman to high herald
BRB to high herald
Hulk to high herald
Nate Grey to high herald [at least]
DoS Doomsday to high herald
Barry/Wally to high herald
Solomon Grundy to low herald
Terrax to low herald

...And Firestorm to high herald is obviously a given [😖hifty:]

There are more, of course, but those stood out to me.

What say ye?

Originally posted by Galan007
Well if there are no objections to the meta and street changes, I say we start revamping the herald tiers.

A few proposed changes from me right off the bat:

Waverider either moves to trans or he's off the list entirely because he exceeds the parameters. Same with Infinity-Man.
Imperiex Probes to trans.
Superman to trans(yes, I said it)
Maxima to high herald
Orion to high herald
Wonder Woman to high herald
BRB to high herald
Hulk to high herald
Nate Grey to high herald [at least]
DoS Doomsday to high herald
Barry/Wally to high herald
Solomon Grundy to low herald
Terrax to low herald

...And Firestorm to high herald is obviously a given [😖hifty:]

There are more, of course, but those stood out to me.

What say ye?

Superman to trans, but the guy who killed him is HH only?
I'd also move Manchester Black up a tier
Argent down to HM
Atom to HH
Cassandra Nova to mid (if we are taking her mindrape of an amped Prof X at face value 😖hifty:
He-Man and Herc to mid
Cpt Comet to Low

Rest I'm OK with.