Originally posted by Quiero Mota
Why is it a ruse? Sure, other cultures may not have cared for homosexuality, but none before the Abrahamic religions declared that it was officially and objectively wrong, or prohibited it. And then you say "Every known culture around the world says practically the same thing", which is not true. Greeks, Japanese and various American Indian tribes have held homosexuality in high regard and reverence. In fact, both the ancient Greeks and Feudal Japanese considered love between men the purest form of love. So its not true that the whole world hated gays, which you are pointing at in an attempt to show why religion is based on the biases of people.
It's a ruse because people use this loophole to justify their irrational hatred of homosexuality. They're pointing their hateful fingers towards god and saying he's why they hate it. But there are any number of other irrational beliefs that are no longer so strictly followed by the vast majority of christians that they don't cling to so fervently because they simply don't jive with their modern lifestyle. But that one rule is clung to because, like a lot of other societies through out time, homosexuality offends them because they don't understand it or they see something of it in themselves and condemnation of it is a great way to deny themselves the luxury of accepting it or at least understanding it in others.
I am fully aware of some acceptance of homosexuality in the ancient world. I have used it as a basis for arguing it's history and validity in many threads. (although not of Native Americans, that's a new one on me) But I'm talking about the bias of people in cultures. And that often comes from not being able to relate to the feelings that motivate. Which is odd, because they would certainly have to be aware of the feelings that motivate their own heterosexual leanings. But the three major religions of the western world condemn it, and since I believe all three to be the creation of man, not god, there is no conclusion other than it is institutionalized and propogated out of the notion of human offence; not divine. It is unfortunate that the whims and dictates of god can't be so easily ignored in this case as they have been in so many other cases. But, that it isn't is a very clear indication that man made god's religion and that only human arrogance would allow for a man to speak for the creator of the entire universe.
Originally posted by Quiero Mota
I'm not sure what you're asking.
I'm saying I don't understand why you can't see why I'm saying what I'm saying and why I'm saying it.