As requested - The argument about crap music...and a (fair) poll

Started by Victor Von Doom23 pages
Originally posted by EPIIIBITES
You're totally missing the point VVD...you haven't been following the discussion, and I wasn't lying.

That's not really an effective reply, is it?

You seem to use it a lot, in place of...having a point.

Originally posted by EPIIIBITES
AC ISN'T saying ALL you say about a band is you like them or dislike them...he's saying they're "crap to me"..."they're crap in my opinion".

What about that are you having an epic problem with?

They're the same thing, you moron. All you can say about a band, outside of technique and ability, is "I like them/dislike them/their music.".

-AC

Originally posted by Victor Von Doom
That's not really an effective reply, is it?

You seem to use it a lot, in place of...having a point.


I edited my post...read it

Originally posted by EPIIIBITES
I edited my post...read it

Nah. You don't get it.

(Seriously, you don't.)

Whatever VVD. It is YOU who are lying about agreeing with me because you wanna save face.

You agreed...it's undeniable.

And ignoring my edited post isn't gonna help you.

Okay, anyways, can you now tell me why music is in your opinion objective?

Originally posted by EPIIIBITES
So what...what about what I said in my post...are you just ignoring that?
So what...what about what I said in my last major post...are you just ignoring that?

Originally posted by EPIIIBITES
So what...what about what I said in my post...are you just ignoring that?

You've ignored me every single time I've posted my factual and truthful explanation of the notion you continually misinterpret.

You sit there telling people what they do and do not agree with.

-AC

Yes, because you restated my own point. You did the same to Bardock, thinking you were being sly, and it backfired.

You don't even have an argument, you simply bait, ignore, ask people to reply to things while ignoring them, all of which serve the purpose of keeping you involved, for whatever fragile ego-based reasons you have.

If this was a proper debate with someone overseeing it, you'd have been laughed out of it about 400 times by now.

Whatever...you're totally confused with what's going on because you didn't even bother to read my last major post.

I wasn't being sly...you full out SAID you agreed with me

Originally posted by EPIIIBITES
Whatever...you're totally confused with what's going on because you didn't even bother to read my last major post.

I wasn't being sly...you full out SAID you agreed with me

Nah. It was shit every one of the 70 times you reworded it.

So how is music objective?

Prove to us that any song is objectively good or bad. You get to choose the song.

-AC

Originally posted by Victor Von Doom
Nah. It was shit every one of the 70 times you reworded it.

Oh yeah...how is this shit as you say? Read it and tell me

Originally posted by EPIIIBITES
“Good” and “crap” are JUST WORDS you can use to say if something appeals to you or not. THAT’S IT.

BUT that’s what you MAINTAIN I’ve misquoted you on as saying you think this!

[B]And you maintain something CAN BE “crap to me” “crap in my opinion”…or say it’s crap by “determining its quality”. IT CAN’T (according to your beliefs about music).

IT CAN ONLY BE “UNLIKEABLE” or “UNAPEALING” in YOUR opinion!!!!!

It’s not “CRAP” in ANY WAY SHAPE OR FORM to you…or it’s not “GOOD” in ANY WAY SHAPE OR FORM to you…”crap” or “good” are just WORDS you can use to express you don’t like it!!! They are NOT (to you) valid concepts for DEFINING MUSIC! [/B]

That's not the thread anymore, the thread now is saying what we say and getting us to agree, then winning.

Reword count: 71.

Originally posted by Alpha Centauri
So how is music objective?

Prove to us that any song is objectively good or bad. You get to choose the song.

-AC

Answer that.

I'm going to make this as tiresome for you as you've made it for everyone dwelling on these forums.

-AC

Originally posted by Alpha Centauri
So how is music objective?
He's doing it again...

Originally posted by EPIIIBITES
He's doing it again...

About that music thread you opened. How is it objective? (music)

You're ignoring my last major post Bardock, and I know why...what did you think of it...c'mon...

So, prove a song is good or bad, EP.

Prove it objectively.

-AC

That's not what I'm discussing right now...we've discussed that before lots