AOTC Anakin Vs ESB Luke

Started by Riverollv4 pages
Riverollv Mandalorian Pride

What could possibly make you think ESB Luke is a good swordsman, DarthSith? From what we see in the movies, he's terrible. It is OBVIOUS AOTC Anakin kills him. He's had a lot more training and he gave Dooku a fine match. Just like kiddo44 says, by only looking at them you can tell AOTC Anakin is far better.

kiddo44 Senior Member
Originally posted by Riverollv
What could possibly make you think ESB Luke is a good swordsman, DarthSith? From what we see in the movies, he's terrible. It is OBVIOUS AOTC Anakin kills him. He's had a lot more training and he gave Dooku a fine match. Just like kiddo44 says, by only looking at them you can tell AOTC Anakin is far better.

he didn't say ESB Luke was better, he said ROTJ Luke is better.

Riverollv Mandalorian Pride

Anyhow, Anakin beats both. And, there already is an AOTC Anakin v.s. ROTJ Luke thread, so he could comment about that fight in there.

darthsith19 Arm-Wrestler

Originally posted by kiddo44
Yeah but you were also arguing Luke,ROTJ, is more powerful than Anakin in the force, and he obviously had less training, and at best could progress as fast as Anakin, so how could he have gone past him? 10 years of formal training v what 4 years of whatever Luke did>

Why would he only progress as fast as Anakin? Some people progress faster than others, due to more intense training, just more natural ability, ect. Luke, Nomi Sunrider, Bane, they just were just fast learners than Anakin was.
What could possibly make you think ESB Luke is a good swordsman, DarthSith? From what we see in the movies, he's terrible. It is OBVIOUS AOTC Anakin kills him. He's had a lot more training and he gave Dooku a fine match. Just like kiddo44 says, by only looking at them you can tell AOTC Anakin is far better.

Did I say ESB Luke was a good swordsman? It's just that he's NOT terrible. He gets a cut in on Vader's arm and Vader calls him "impressive". Not good, but not at all bad. Yes, I already said that AOTC Anakin wins, I just said it'd be a lot closer than a lot of other people here are saying. He is NOT far better, just a little bit better.

Count Makashi Count Dookus number 1 fan

Anakin put up a good fight against Dooku, ESB Luke would get totally destroyed against Dooku, Dooku would super mega own him.

kiddo44 Senior Member

they just were just fast learners than Anakin was.
But Anakin progressed faster than every other jedi in the PT, says Lucas on the AOTC dvd.

He is NOT far better, just a little bit better
So are your talking that AOTC Anakin is just a little bit better swordsman than ESB Luke?? Your not serious, AOTC Anakin was clearly a better swordsman than ROTJ Luke, he had 10 years of training and was atleast equal to Knight Kenobi, ESB Luke is not close at all. So you think ESB luke is only a little behind AOTC Kenobi in sabers??🤨 DS i know your not that clueless about Star Wars.

darthsith19 Arm-Wrestler

Originally posted by Count Makashi
Anakin put up a good fight against Dooku, ESB Luke would get totally destroyed against Dooku, Dooku would super mega own him.

1. Dooku underestimated Anakin
2. Anakin had 2 blades for some of it
3. Dooku's form is weak against Anakin's

Luke would get owned - but not super mega owned.

But Anakin progressed faster than every other jedi in the PT, says Lucas on the AOTC dvd.

Yup. Unfortunately, Luke and Nomi aren't PT Jedi, and Bane isn't a Jedi at all.

So are your talking that AOTC Anakin is just a little bit better swordsman than ESB Luke?? Your not serious, AOTC Anakin was clearly a better swordsman than ROTJ Luke, he had 10 years of training and was atleast equal to Knight Kenobi, ESB Luke is not close at all. So you think ESB luke is only a little behind AOTC Kenobi in sabers??huh DS i know your not that clueless about Star Wars.

ROTJ Luke beat Vader and Vader was trying to defend himself 100%, he's ahead of Anakin. Glentract provided proof in the other thread that Vader was unable to beat ESB Luke easily, could the same be said for AOTC Anakin? Possibly, though I doubt AOTC Anakin would be very hard for Vader to beat, either. AOTC Kenobi > AOTC Anakin.

So yeah, ESB Luke is close to Vader, not above, but close.

vader11 Senior Member

Vader is still better than Luke in saber, and better than him in the force by a very large margin.