Originally posted by lord xyz
All or most Atheists aren't religious. In fact atheism is usually due to the abscence of religion.
Yeah so? My point is to some people it is and it can be just because its not for you doesnt make a difference.
Originally posted by Alliance
I never said forget it. I'm in finals now and I don't have time to be running around searching for things. I'll ask my friend in religious studies tonight if she knows an online dictionary or a defenition. Usually if you want scholarly knowledge, you have to go looking for it.
Well if we shouldnt forget it whats the problem? At the end of the day they are eytmologists and there information counts.
Originally posted by Alliance
Whic post is that, in PM? Concerning what? I don't seem to remember.
Forget it.
Originally posted by Alliance
Then be careful what is causaution and what is incidence.
I dont need to be careful about anything . Like I said I covered my arse when I said "usually". You damn well know most atheists disbelief in god usually results in disbeleif in teh afterlife etc.
Originally posted by Alliance
By that toke, you could say being Latino is a religion because they are conscientious of their identity.
Yeah you could.
Originally posted by Alliance
The root of the word has no meaning here, its what the word means thats the issue. The word "gay" means very little from the words it came from.
Well not neccesarily if you use an eytmoligist dictionary it helps you to understand the true meaning of the word. Furthermore the dictionary states that a relgion does not have to be about anything supernatural AND so does the eytmologist dictionary.
"To hold, therefore, that there is no difference in matters of religion between forms that are unlike each other, and even contrary to each other, most clearly leads in the end to the rejection of all religion in both theory and practice. And this is the same thing as atheism, however it may differ from it in name." [Pope Leo XIII, Immortale Dei, 1885]
Please dont tell me that this does not count as evidence. I think the owness is up on you to produce your own defintion from your own source. If you think its rubbish thats what you should do.
Originally posted by inimalist
you believe that because you believe something it is truethere is no argument to that. There is no way that anyone can use any type of argument to pursuade you, since the fact that you have a thought is justification for itself.
Look, I don't go around telling Heathans what they believe, and there is a damn good reason I don't, because I would have no idea what I am talking about, and I am not immature enough to think that just because I have an opinion on something means that it is at all worth anyone's consideration.
I'm not trying to piss you off, its just you kinda ended the conversation with that. If what you believe is true because you believe it, then we are done.
Er mate I think your getting it twisted yeah that is what I believe. But you got to understand im into alot of occult philosphy and due to my meditation reality is slightly different from other peoples BUT I perfectly understand why you dont believe it.
This is just my opinion and it doesnt have to have anything to do with you. When I debate with somebody I try to debate from their angle. Im trying to use simple logic to prove my point. I went to dictionary.com AND I went to an eytmologoist dictionary to try and prove that atheism could be religion, what has that got to do with my beliefs? AND I also used this point before I mentioned my beliefs.
Originally posted by leonheartmm
your basic asumption is wrong. im an atheist yet i believe for the most part in more supernatural things then probably u do.
Thats why I used the word "usually". Furthermore what exactly are your beliefs with the supernatural because that could basically make you NOT an athiest. Atheism is the disbelief in God and gods.
Originally posted by leonheartmm
im not saying atheist can not STEM from belief,
Yeah and my point is to some people its a religion and it can be a religion. Whats the problem?
Originally posted by leonheartmm
nor am i saying that all atheists dont have beliefs that go against theism. im saying that BELIEF in DISBELIEF isnt a REQUIREMENT of atheism like BELIEF IN GOD is a reqiurement of theism.thats the basic point, atheists who have beliefs against god existing have those beliefs SEPERATE from the ATHEISTIC part of them, atheism is not a causitive factor for those beliefs but rather, the beliefs are a causitive factor for atheism.
as such there are no ATHEISTIC BELIEFS, as atheism doesnt cause any beliefs, its simply the lack of any belief in god, it doesnt put limits on any number of other beliefs that a person may have inplace of or seperate from THEIST BELIEFS. it just means theist beliefs are not present. also the NATURE of the beleifs found in atheism is different even for people who are atheists due to BELIEF IN ABSENCE OF GOD. they are axiomic, not complicated or dogmatic. those basic ASSUMPTION/AXIOMS{i.e i believe if i lift my leg and push forwards with my leg muscles, il take a step FORWARD AND NOT BACKWARD. now in the STRICT sense, thats a belief, but its an AXIOMIC belief which cannot be characterized the same as when a person says, I BELIEVE JESUS IS THE ONLY WAY TO AN EXISTING HEAVEN. its dogmatic, learnt, non basic and completely different from an axiomic belief.}
You know what I think I just disagree. Even if a human has never heard of God and maybe an athiest it doesnt end there. It seems athiests have different beliefs but im pretty sure somebody who is an athiest is going to believe in other things due to his lack of belief in God other things are going to follow from that regardless of wether he knows about God or not.
Originally posted by leonheartmm
also read my post again, it explained that the definition/criteria for athesim is simply LACK OF BELIEF in god. which does not need another BELIEF to substantiate it{baby etc}
Yeah thats your opinion. Like I said an athiest will believe in other things that stem from athiesm. I dont know if your going to give an example of a baby you might as well give an example of a rock. Anyway I will have to think about the baby example but as far as im concerned at least and adult who is athiest will ahve other beliefs that stem from it.
Yeah ive been thinking about the baby example and I see what you mean. At any rate that is just a particular type of athiesm but that still doesnt mean it can be a religon. Anyway i'll mull it over.