I am far too lazy to go back through this thread entirely right now, but I came across this quote by tee_pirategirl, so I thought I'd respond.
But IS the age difference why WE shipper don't like JE?
No. Although I've heard it's a reason from other W/E shippers, I think it's a pointless one.
My problem with J/E lies in that aside from some big-time flirting well...that's all it is. On top of it all, Jack is the only one who seems to really be interested in Elizabeth; Elizabeth is not all that interested in Jack.
Everything she did with Jack seemed to have some sort of ulterior motive, but with Will it is an honestly felt relationship. Yes, I know, they had their little trust issues, but I've pointed out numerous times that they've worked it out on their own.
And here's another reason I don't like J/E:
Elizabeth killed Jack.
To me, it's appalling and somehow disturbing how people have flocked in numbers to try to pair Jack up with the person who killed him. This is not meant to offend, but come on.
Jack died and suffered because of Elizabeth, hot kiss or not. She did something almost completely unforgivable to him, and you want them to ewwww, run off together because they're hot?
I can't believe it's never occurred to any of you that the natural progression of a relationship is that once someone kills you, the nature of the relationship changes, and not in a good way.
Yeah, yeah, the script said Jack desired her even more after she chained him up, but at that point he wasn't dead yet and hadn't been in some sort of Hell for 7 months going mad(der) bit by bit.
Another thing about J/E....I don't really like them as a couple. Partially this is just because I don't find Johnny that attractive (and I've tried to see the error of my ways, trust me). I just don't like him, I don't really like Jack all that much (fun as he is), and I don't like J/E as a couple because of it. 😛
Now, Norribeth is my main ship, but W/E has worked it's way into a tie. 😄 I just love everything about them, from their first awkward moments together to how they do anything for each other, to that lovely, sexy moment on the beach when they finally, for a few hours, get to put the world on hold and just be together. And other reasons too, but I'm tired and I'm going to nap. 😛