Hawkeye vs Punisher

Punisher gets a range of weapons, pistols, knifes, shotgun, machine gun etc. he has a basic pistol with unlimited ammo. Hawkeye gets a sonic explosion arrow, a few explosive arrows a net arrow and an unlimited supply of regular arrows.

They fight in the Savage land without prep
They fight in a crowded city street with prep
They fight in a a factory full of fully functioning kill everyone sentinels, without prep
They fight on the roofs of New York city without prep

Who wins in each scenario??????????

IMO it goes in order of scenario

Punisher 6/10
Hawkeye 9/10
Hawkeye 6/10
Punisher 5 or 6/10

Punisher for the majority in all scenarios

Punisher never looses in the savage land
and Hawkeye never looses on the roof tops.
others two can go ether way.

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
Punisher for the majority in all scenarios

They fight in the Savage land without prep: Hawk throws a tree at Frank, killing him.

They fight in a crowded city street with prep: Hawk throws a car at Frank, killing him.

They fight in a a factory full of fully functioning kill everyone sentinels, without prep: Hawk throws a sentinel at Frank, killing him.

They fight on the roofs of New York city without prep: Hawk throws a building at Frank, killing him.

Ugh.. one panel of Hawkeye training with Cap and he's Bruce Lee all of a sudden.

Frank wins.

this thread makes me cry...

also, this:

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
Punisher for the majority in all scenarios

Originally posted by SamZED
Ugh.. one panel of Hawkeye training with Cap and he's Bruce Lee all of a sudden.

Frank wins.

No, he lifted a car with one arm.

Originally posted by juggernaut74
I agree, but they are good fights.

He would stomp in Savage land.

Leave Punisher in the jungle with a knife and he can create traps.

Originally posted by The Nuul
No, he lifted a car with one arm.

Um that might be Paladin.

Originally posted by Deadline
He would stomp

period

I dunno think that might be a bit unfair. That sonic arrow could be tricky.

could be, yes

maybe for 1-2/10 in the best cases...

idk, my bias toward modern technology over that 13th century is probably showing here, but I don't see Hawkeye shooting too many volleys

They had sonic arrows in the 13th century?

I really don't see the "sonic-arrow-arguement" as being too convincing in a series of scenarios I can't help but interpret as "how long until Punisher guns down Hawkeye in this location?"

Originally posted by inimalist
I really don't see the "sonic-arrow-arguement" as being too convincing in a series of scenarios I can't help but interpret as "how long until Punisher guns down Hawkeye in this location?"

but fair enough, they probably didn't have sonic arrows in the 13th century

Originally posted by inimalist
but fair enough, they probably didn't have sonic arrows in the 13th century

Originally posted by The Nuul
No, he lifted a car with one arm.

Originally posted by SamZED
He didnt really lift the whole car, meaning it wasnt completely off the ground. Impressive but not something that makes him > Frank. If this comes down to h2h I see Frank outlasting him.