Harry Potter vs. Captain America

Started by Symmetric Chaos18 pages

Originally posted by grey fox
😆

I've read EVERY book , really what does a NORMAL HUMAN have that can compete with his GENETIC AND PHYSICAL SUPERIOR.

Dunno . . . magic 😐

😛

Originally posted by xmarksthespot
So just to be crystal clear under the standard forum rules as amended by ill, you give Captain America the win over the Invisible Woman...

Zatanna?
Emma Frost?
Cyclops?

The rules were changed?

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
Because he has low level superhuman speed and recation time, where as Harry is average at best in those areas?

Just because his reflexes are superhuman doesn't mean his mind is. Thinking is different from reflexes.

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
The rules were changed?
The standard rules now entail similar stipulations as this thread i.e. characters start half a kilometre apart.

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
Yeah I think Cap would take Sue in the same situation. In terms of her speed and reaction time she is an average woman, Captain America isn't an average man by any stretch of the imagination. He can see bullets in slow-mo, his reaction time and perception are off the charts, they can't even be compared to someone like Sue Richards. Against a blood lusted Captain America, she'd get koed before she even released the fight had started. Sure it only takes a single thought for her to put up a shield but Captain America thinks and moves faster then she could ever dream of.

How did you extrapolate that from the forum rules? I simply amended the rules to curb the "speedblitz" one-liner answers that are so prevalent, to make people actually have to think about a fleshed out battle scenario, and to provide more character options.

Sue would kill Cap.

Harry, on the other hand, as has been displayed in this thread, doesn't have the evidence to support his side's claims.

If it's provided it may sway my view.

Originally posted by grey fox
😆

I've read EVERY book , really what does a NORMAL HUMAN have that can compete with his GENETIC AND PHYSICAL SUPERIOR.


If you read the book you would have known Harry is 36 now. Either that or you must have really poor reading skills.

And Harry isn't a NORMAL HUMAN. He's a wizard.

Originally posted by illadelph12
How did you extrapolate that from the forum rules? I simply amended the rules to curb the "speedblitz" one-liner answers that are so prevalent, to make people actually have to think about a fleshed out battle scenario, and to provide more character options.

Sue would kill Cap.

Harry, on the other hand, as has been displayed in this thread, doesn't have the evidence to support his side's claims.

If it's provided it may sway my view.

Do I have to repeat myself. Harry performed Levicorpus nonverbally.

Harry has also done magic without his wand.

Originally posted by tooa/presence
If you read the book you would have known Harry is 36 now. Either that or you must have really poor reading skills.

And Harry isn't a NORMAL HUMAN. He's a wizard.

Yes, he is a wizard-retard.

Does being a wizard enhance your physical features to superhuman or peak human?

Originally posted by tooa/presence
And Harry isn't a NORMAL HUMAN. He's a wizard.

Harry never became retarded 😬

He's still a normalish wizard.

Dammit, quoted the wrong post...

Originally posted by illadelph12
How did you extrapolate that from the forum rules? I simply amended the rules to curb the "speedblitz" one-liner answers that are so prevalent, to make people actually have to think about a fleshed out battle scenario, and to provide more character options.
The part about the standard battlefield being half a kilometre basically, and the notion that in a fraction of a second the shield would traverse that distance and basically decapitate any opponent without reflexes on par with Cap before they could take action, which seems to be the thought of the day.

Edit: Meh I'll just leave this here even though it's a clarification based on a misquote...

edit

Heres what I think. I think Captain America has superhuman speed, reaction time and perceives the world in slow motion in comparison to normal humans. Half a kilometer away we are looking at quick draw contest and against Sue (and Zatanna, Emma Frost, Cyclops), I think Captain America is faster on the draw. He thinks faster then all four of them and he moves faster then they do also.

Originally posted by tooa/presence
If you read the book you would have known Harry is 36 now. Either that or you must have really poor reading skills.

And Harry isn't a NORMAL HUMAN. He's a wizard, retard.

And the difference in age means what ? Nothing.

He still eats unhealthily and barely exercises, also how does magic make any difference to Harry's reflexes or anything to do with his actual physical body AT ALL (Save slowing aging)

Originally posted by llagrok
Yes, he is a wizard-retard.

Does being a wizard enhance your physical features to superhuman or peak human?

Yes. In the book Harry was told that his mom and dad died by a car crash. Hagrid was in disbelief at this and told Harry that a car crash wouldn't kill great wizards/witches like Harry's parents (superhuman). Harry has also shown superhuman physical features in quidditch matches.

Originally posted by tooa/presence
Yes. In the book Harry was told that his mom and dad died by a car crash. Hagrid was in disbelief at this and told Harry that a car crash wouldn't kill great wizards/witches like Harry's parents (superhuman). Harry has also shown superhuman physical features in quidditch matches.

....because the word of a absent minded man who takes 'gifts' from pubs, gets frequently drunk and is blood related to a species whose idea of intelligence is the ability to make rudimentary items should obviously be taken as law.

Also he could just be describing that other wizards could heal Harry's parents with magic.

The only noticable effect magic has on the body is slowing the affects of aging.

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
Heres what I think. I think Captain America has superhuman speed, reaction time and perceives the world in slow motion in comparison to normal humans. Half a kilometer away we are looking at quick draw contest and against Sue (and Zatanna, Emma Frost, Cyclops), I think Captain America is faster on the draw. He thinks faster then all four of them and he moves faster then they do also.
You really think Captain America can aim, go through the movement required to throw a large metal shield, and that the shield can traverse half a kilometer; all before Cyclops could push a button on his palm, Emma can think "Stop." Sue can think "Bubble." and Zatanna can think "Eid."

😬

Originally posted by grey fox
And the difference in age means what ? Nothing.

😱 Except for the 19 years of experience he gains. I wish i knew how to do that thing where the smile pounds his head.
Originally posted by grey fox
He still eats unhealthily and barely exercises, also how does magic make any difference to Harry's reflexes or anything to do with his actual physical body AT ALL (Save slowing aging)

Eats unhealty and barely exercises? WTH?

Originally posted by tooa/presence
The shield might be fast but Captain America's arm throw takes more time than the shield traveling. Expelliarmus would disarm Caps shield before he even released it. Then Harry could turn invisible and put protection spells and what not. After Harry does that there is no way Captain America could win.

But would that be the first thing Harry even chooses to do?? Cap throwing his sheild is pretty much what we expect but for harry what if decides to use something offensive first and cap dodges and throws the sheild, Hell how do we know Cap won't be able to dodge the expelliamus thing? I'm not sure if you can or not does it levitate the sheild it self or is it just a bolt of magic which knocks it away? cause if its just something to knock it away cap has held onto it while being hit by the likes of Hulk and whatnot...

Originally posted by grey fox
....because the word of a absent minded man who takes 'gifts' from pubs, gets frequently drunk and is blood related to a species whose idea of intelligence is the ability to make rudimentary items should obviously be taken as law.

Also he could just be describing that other wizards could heal Harry's parents with magic.

The only noticable effect magic has on the body is slowing the affects of aging.

If you won't take proof from the book, why should I take proof from the comics? I might as well say the comic book writers are retarded and what were they thinking making that shield faster than a missile and Spiderman should beat the LT because he looks cooler.