Mixed Genre & Comic Tier Reference Guide

Started by Creshosk307 pages

Originally posted by psycho gundam
made from a divine source, that much should go without saying
Which is still tech.

Okay lets put it this way.

In palladium's game system "Rifts" you can find out that the "Gods" of that world are actually just supernatural alien intelligences that if a character gets sufficiently powerful enough can be quite capable of killing.

They are still referred to as "Gods" by those that don't truly understand their nature.

Your insistence in pointing out the deus ex machina(Quite literally) Actually goes to prove Arthur C Clarke's point.

Those god's power is technology that is sufficently advanced that its indistinguishable from magic.

Originally posted by Omega Vision
Okay?

Oh yes let me fish out the scan where Metron states that Boomtubes run on God juice, magic beans, and fairy farts. 🙄

might as well, you brought up new god tech like it's got a wayne industries logo on it.

Originally posted by Creshosk
Which is still tech.

Okay lets put it this way.

In palladium's game system "Rifts" you can find out that the "Gods" of that world are actually just supernatural alien intelligences that if a character gets sufficiently powerful enough can be quite capable of killing.

They are still referred to as "Gods" by those that don't truly understand their nature.

Your insistence in pointing out the deus ex machina(Quite literally) Actually goes to prove Arthur C Clarke's point.

Those god's power is technology that is sufficently advanced that its indistinguishable from magic.

envoke a demon with tech please, or science can't do everything

^Kirby's original intent for the New Gods was for them to be the replacements of Thor and Co in Asgard, only instead of being powered by magic and mysticism their power came from science and the power of the mind itself.

Edit: Do you consider Celestial technology to be magical/divine in any way? Because I'd say NG tech and Celestial tech is more or less on the same level.

Originally posted by psycho gundam
try envoking dormammu with that stuff
If I had a powerful enough machine to do that, and that was my goal, why wouldn't I and why couldn't I?

Because you believe it wouldn't work?

Well, the people of 1200 AD would not believe that a man was capable of thinking up a moving building that was shaped like a man that could go out into space to fight other buidlings shaped like men.

And if I'm being too faceteous for you I'm referenceing mecha. in the 1200 you'd be thought insane for coming up with the idea of mecha.

Gundam, Guymelef, Evangelion, Rune God... Whatever you want to call them and however you want them to function.

Originally posted by Omega Vision
^Kirby's original intent for the New Gods was for them to be the replacements of Thor and Co in Asgard, only instead of being powered by magic and mysticism their power came from science and the power of the mind itself.

Edit: Do you consider Celestial technology to be magical/divine in any way? Because I'd say NG tech and Celestial tech is more or less on the same level.

celestial =/= new gods

celestials are based on the sumerian texts and various mexican myths, but they are explicitly depicted to be creatures of science, not divinity in the mythical sense (more like the science behind the myth)

without going to much into this, magic can do things science can't

Originally posted by Creshosk
If I had a powerful enough machine to do that, and that was my goal, why wouldn't I and why couldn't I?

Because you believe it wouldn't work?

Well, the people of 1200 AD would not believe that a man was capable of thinking up a moving building that was shaped like a man that could go out into space to fight other buidlings shaped like men.

And if I'm being too faceteous for you I'm referenceing mecha. in the 1200 you'd be thought insane for coming up with the idea of mecha.

Gundam, Guymelef, Evangelion, Rune God... Whatever you want to call them and however you want them to function.

concession accepted 😛

Originally posted by psycho gundam
might as well, you brought up new god tech like it's got a wayne industries logo on it.

envoke a demon with tech please, or science can't do everything

You want me to ACTUALLY do that? 🤨

Or should I point out where tech was used to summon daemons?

Didn't go over very well but it was possible.

Doom.

Course there's also soul hackers and devil survivor. that use technology to summon demons.

Originally posted by psycho gundam
celestial =/= new gods

celestials are based on the sumerian texts and various mexican myths, but they are explicitly depicted to be creatures of science, not divinity in the mythical sense (more like the science behind the myth)

without going to much into this, magic can do things science can't

Only if the science isn't sufficiently advanced enough.

Originally posted by psycho gundam
concession accepted
Argument from silence and argument from ignorace.

You are SERIOUSLY grasping at straws.

"summon the crimson bands of cyttorak and bind them around an opponent"

"science can do dat"

"😐"

Originally posted by psycho gundam
celestial =/= new gods

celestials are based on the sumerian texts and various mexican myths, but they are explicitly depicted to be creatures of science, not divinity in the mythical sense (more like the science behind the myth)


New Gods aren't like the other Gods of DC. They were cut from the same cloth (Godwave) but AFAIK they don't rely on mortal faith to exist and for power. Darkseid was able to exploit said weakness in the Olympian Gods by splitting them into the Greek and Roman pantheons.

Also even if Zeus himself cobbled together a shoe without using any powers the shoe would still be an ordinary shoe regardless of who made it. AFAWK Metron never did anything that a guy like Reed Richards couldn't do given the same knowledge and resources. So stop forging some false distinction between New God tech and other tech just because a hole was poked in your "you need magic to reach Asgard in a timely fashion" claim.

Originally posted by psycho gundam
"summon the crimson bands of cyttorak and bind them around an opponent"

"science can do dat"

"😐"


Are you seriously arguing that energy-based restraints are impossible with comic based tech?

Originally posted by psycho gundam
"summon the crimson bands of cyttorak and bind them around an opponent"

"science can do dat"

"😐"

You should watch the second season of magic knight rayearth.

While largely based in magic they had a group come in that could detect and analyze the energy that composed "Magic".

Originally posted by Omega Vision
Are you seriously arguing that energy-based restraints are impossible with comic based tech?
I think he is.

Fairly Ironic for a gundam fan to have doubts about tech.

And fairly disgraceful.

If I had a machine that was able to detect, harness store and manipulate the magical energy, it'd still be technology manipulating "Divine energy".

Much like the very machine you're using is harnessing the power of zeus or thor... or whatever lightning god you believe in.

Originally posted by Creshosk
You should watch the second season of magic knight rayearth.

While largely based in magic they had a group come in that could detect and analyze the energy that composed "Magic".

won't help them utilize the winds of watoomb or anything *shrugs*

Originally posted by psycho gundam
won't help them utilize the winds of watoomb or anything *shrugs*
That's what you think.

Like I said, you're currently harnessing the power of zeus, thor <insert lightning god here>.

We analyzed, learned how to harness, store and manipulate an energy that was believed to belong to the gods.

then a god catches wind of it and just shuts off the connection

Originally posted by psycho gundam
then a god catches wind of it and just shuts off the connection

Electromagnetic pulse. Any barefoot terrorist with a stolen nuke can do it. 131

Originally posted by Omega Vision
Electromagnetic pulse. Any barefoot terrorist with a stolen nuke can do it. 131
not the same and you know it

also, summon some lava men while you're at it, they will help you carry the nuclear device

Originally posted by psycho gundam
not the same and you know it

For all intents and purposes the result is the same. Which is what we're arguing about: that at a sufficient level tech can acheive the same results as magic.

Originally posted by psycho gundam
then a god catches wind of it and just shuts off the connection
If they're capable of doing that.

I mean you have to take into account that this machine broke into their realm to harness the energy.

And that's of course only if they detect it. If they don't, there's nothing they can do about it.

Originally posted by psycho gundam
not the same and you know it

also, summon some lava men while you're at it, they will help you carry the nuclear device

Okay, just have to detect irregular movement indicative of lifeforms and pull them in via a transporter like device from the para-elemental plane of heat.

Chances are they'll be lava elementals.