Scathan the Approver vs The Living Tribunal

Started by quanchi1128 pages

Originally posted by Utrigita
The amount would be so insignificant that a amulet could surpass it.

Yes he was, before Thanos attained the Heart of The universe the LT was the top of the food chain, at that point of time he would have been unbeatable.

Meh he went into a different power source because he had to deal with the Protege. He wouldnt tap into the amulet if he didnt need to.

Originally posted by Utrigita
Is it still opposition week Erik?

I tried, but in most threads it seems like nobody is willing to debate.

In any case, in threads where the difference between the overall power difference isn't big enough to make it spite or some sort, I'm willing to debate for either side, eventough if I don't belive that side would actually win.

Originally posted by Utrigita

That the incident cannot be removed because of the PIS that concerns it, Scathan Clearly operated far above what Any single Celestial have ever showed prior, it directly contradicts (as you have said yourself many times) everything we know about the Cosmic Hierarchy. I know that handbook stats that Scathan > LT even though LT is said to second to Toaa.


Ok cool, I actually agree. 👆 ... But I never said otherwise.

Originally posted by Mr Master
Ok cool, I actually agree. 👆 ... But I never said otherwise.

😎

Originally posted by Erik-Lensherr
I tried, but in most threads it seems like nobody is willing to debate.

In any case, in threads where the difference between the overall power difference isn't big enough to make it spite or some sort, I'm willing to debate for either side, eventough if I don't belive that side would actually win.

Well it's just that opposition week and then you are stating that the current situation showed certain restrictions to LT, one could be tempted to believe that actually you where saying there where no restrictions...

Originally posted by quanchi112
Meh he went into a different power source because he had to deal with the Protege. He wouldnt tap into the amulet if he didnt need to.

A amulet which own power is like nothing next to the LT himself, and he taps into it, sounds incrediably strange.

whoever has TOAA's backing is the winner.... 😆

Did Protege ever copy the Amulet himself? If not, it could just be that Protoge is susceptible to powers which he does not embody/copy.

Originally posted by illadelph12

Did Protege ever copy the Amulet himself?
If not, it could just be that Protoge is susceptible to powers which he does not embody/copy.


Perhaps, but there's nothing to substantiate that.

Ills, what happened, I was enjoying that phrase:

"Energy muzzle ftw" ... smilefist

LT said his power feeds on itself at that level. That blast might have been Proteges
power feeding on itself and weakening him. Scathan then stepped in and muzzled him.
With cosmic time beginning anew this sounds like a cyclic thing, like an Indra in Hinduism who is searching for more and more power and eventually defeats himself and a new age begins.
In the Indra and the ants myth, Indra is defeated (sort of), Shiva is there(Eternity) and Brahman (God/One above All) is present in the disguise of a small boy.
The Celestial may have been OAA or si8mply waited for Protege to use his power and defeat himself.

LT is my fave character

Celestials are my 2nd

Win win for me

Scathan>LT.

Proven.

Originally posted by Knowsbleed33
Scathan>LT.

Proven.

Yeah I saw that. I'm saying that conclusion may be wrong and the writers may have a bit more depth than treating cosmic beings as really tall superheros who sneak up on each other and shoot energy like Silver Surfer vs Morg. Scathan was either a manifestation of OAAs will or was waiting for Prot to defeat himself in a pre-destined cyclic event.
I would hope when dealing with god beings the writers are using mythological themes instead of trying to see which god has has bigger biceps. The "cyclic time" thing is a big giveaway that there is more going on than what is literally shown in each picture.

The LT was able to nullify the IG when Adam Warlock had it. Scathan has been around since Odin fought them. So he also was probably there throwing planets at Thanos with the Infinity Gauntlet. He couldn't defeat the IG but LT could.

Although the celestials are a mystery even to Eternity they still can't seem to fight the Gauntlet but LT had no problem with it to Adam warlocks surprise.

The LT was able to do what he did to the IG because TOAA let him do it.

Originally posted by Knowsbleed33
The LT was able to do what he did to the IG because TOAA let him do it.
?

I was simply debunking his IG arc comparison.

If what he said was true, TOAA would've simply empowered the LT to defeat Protege.

Originally posted by Knowsbleed33
I was simply debunking his IG arc comparison.

If what he said was true, TOAA would've simply empowered the LT to defeat Protege.

I didn't real read what he wrote but where are you getting that TOAA empowers the LT directly and that LT's power level varies depending on situation?

Originally posted by Knowsbleed33
Scathan>LT.

Proven.

😛

i still believe scathan was given that power for that one time only due to Lt being stymied by protege.

the only evidence there is, and the only evidence that matters is that all that scathan did with his great power was give the Lt the signal to absorb protege.

Originally posted by kgkg
I didn't real read what he wrote but where are you getting that TOAA empowers the LT directly and that LT's power level varies depending on situation?

Uhh provided scan perhaps?

"Because of rulings beyond my control"