Superman vs Silver surfer

Originally posted by Cosmic Cube
Not the actual issue.

However, I have scans of the entire fight.

Here is Morg, lying on a fragment of the planet they were fighting on.

Originally posted by juggernaut74
Yea but they are Vol. 2 issues he mentioned not Vol. 1

There is no post-crisis Volume 2 of Action Comics.

Go to comicspriceguide.com and look at a scan of it. Does it look like 1941 book to you? Superman #153 he mentioned is Vol. 2.

Originally posted by juggernaut74
Yea but they are Vol. 2 issues he mentioned not Vol. 1

Yea, I thought so as well lol.

part1

part 2

Originally posted by juggernaut74
Well I have this issue sitting right in from of me and it does not look like a Planet to me, even if it is its a very small one. I also have the Hulk vs. Superman issue here too ready to go to battle with you on.

This is clearly a planet that the two are fighting on.

Originally posted by Cosmic Cube
This is clearly a planet that the two are fighting on.

Originally posted by juggernaut74
Go to comicspriceguide.com and look at a scan of it. Does it look like 1941 book to you? Superman #153 he mentioned is Vol. 2.

Could you post the image? Nothing is coming up in the search.

lol what is the difference are we trying to prove something???

Originally posted by juggernaut74
Well you call it a planet and Ill call it a Asteroid, sound good?

No, that's not ok. You are undercutting the Surfer's powers to benefit your argument. The Silver Surfer destroyed a planet not an asteroid. Let's continue from there.

How can you say it is a planet when it looks like a a rock?

A planet is a rock. A huge rock.

Originally posted by Cosmic Cube
Could you post the image? Nothing is coming up in the search.

Originally posted by Cosmic Cube
A planet is a rock. A huge rock.

Planet: an extremely large round mass of rock and metal, such as Earth, or of gas, such as Jupiter, which moves in a circular path around the Sun or another star:

Asteroids aren't round.

Originally posted by juggernaut74
Yea but they do not look like that.

What does a planet look like? Planets are only uniform in shape.

Originally posted by Cosmic Cube
What does a planet look like? Planets are only uniform in shape.

.....

Lol. Well from the scans it does look like they are fighting on a meteor or asteroid. Second, the Superman book doesnt look like it was from the 40's unless its a re-print lol. I think you won this one Juggs