Superman vs Silver surfer

Started by fangirl101387 pages

Originally posted by Endrict Nuul
Who the hell are you to tell a mod off? and you don't even know Quan's history here. So don't even bother to start sticking your noise in other people issues.

Indeed. I wonder how many people got temp bans, and perma bans, and reports on them due to Quan's baiting. I'm sure it would be interesting to see the numbers.

NVR.....leave it alone, Quan got wat he deserved. Lets stay on topic thanks.

Originally posted by The Great Galen NVR.....leave it alone, Quan got wat he deserved. Lets stay on topic thanks.
Don't know why you are saying never leave it alone but, I do think Quan is problematic. I agree with the mods on this one. I'm just saying, I wonder how long he's done this and how many people were affected by his behavior that he got away with for so long.

Originally posted by fangirl101
Indeed. I wonder how many people got temp bans, and perma bans, and reports on them due to Quan's baiting. I'm sure it would be interesting to see the numbers.

Yeah, Nvr let it go...

SS wins.... 😄

Originally posted by fangirl101
Indeed. I wonder how many people got temp bans, and perma bans, and reports on them due to Quan's baiting. I'm sure it would be interesting to see the numbers.
Warned for continuing with off topic posts after requests to stop.

Originally posted by Endrict Nuul
Yeah, Nvr let it go...

SS wins.... 😄


Of course we all know SS wins. This thread should have died a while ago. Surfer 7/10.

Originally posted by fangirl101
Don't know why you are saying never leave it alone but, I do think Quan is problematic. I agree with the mods on this one. I'm just saying, I wonder how long he's done this and how many people were affected by his behavior that he got away with for so long.
there was one poster, called nvr, who was a victim of being bashed here on KMC...

Originally posted by Starscream M there was one poster, called nvr, who was a victim of being bashed here on KMC...
Surfer wins._ 😘

Originally posted by Starscream M
there was one poster, called nvr, who was a victim of being bashed here on KMC...
I've told you about accusations before. One more time and it's a warning.

Originally posted by fangirl101
Of course we all know SS wins. This thread should have died a while ago. Surfer 7/10.

agreed

Originally posted by Starscream M
anyone you have in mind? 😕

nvrmind 😉

😂

Originally posted by fangirl101
Of course we all know SS wins. This thread should have died a while ago. Surfer 7/10.

It should have, in fact we all pretty much agreed SS would take 7-8/10....but then somehow it jsut kept on expanding. Anyhow lets continue I guess heh, oh and Nvr just ignore the haters.

Originally posted by Philosophía
No. Pretty much the only difference is that Silver Surfer saw and calculated his trajectory (Thus Surfer saying "But since I'm able to see his movement, [b][i]I can calculate his trajectory[/i]), thus he too knew the location where his adversary would be, while Magneto sensed and knew the destination in which his opponent would arrive.

So let's rewind a little bit.

They both reacted during the teleportation.

They both knew where the opponent would be before the oponnent arrived there.

They both attacked the opponent once he arrived at the spot he wanted to.

It's really quite simple. [/B]


Yes thats what i've said but Mags knew it before the opponent arrives thats the diff.. Surfer did not therefore his time in which to react are far shorter than that of Mags feat..

Really to what other showing has Magneto ever done that is equalled/similar reflex speed to this one? Less his got more then i'd agree, he'd be able to keep up w/ Supes but unlike Surfer his got a few more quantifiable reaction/reflex feats to warrant such proposition..

Originally posted by Avlon
Except none of it is quantifiable proof of great battle speed. If there was a quick n easy scan or numerous scans that actually easily dispelled the BP reaction time incident in battle, they would have been posted and I doubt there would be any complaints, but since there aren't... SS fans want to scapegoat me.

There are quick and easy scans and most of them HAVE been posted(repeatedly in fact), you just choose to ignore them. It’s very, very simple…

If Surfer can track and react to someone TELEPORTING behind him…
http://img504.imageshack.us/img504/6231/silversurfer198902312rp5.jpg

…then he should be able to react to a street level character with no actual super speed like BP try to leap behind him.

If he can block energy blast after they’re fired…
http://img60.imageshack.us/img60/4254/silversurferannual0124re5.jpg

Dodge energy blast after they’re fired while on his board…
http://img524.imageshack.us/img524/6328/silversurferannual0624rx0.jpg
http://img505.imageshack.us/img505/37/silversurferannual0625rl2.jpg

Duck beneath energy blast after they’re fired while OFF his board…
http://img60.imageshack.us/img60/8656/silversurferv306409hn2.jpg

…then BP’s speed shouldn’t be a problem for him unless Bp moves faster than the energy blast in question.

If he can simultaneously grab both DD and Spiderman by the throat when they go swinging in on him…
http://img244.imageshack.us/img244/9884/silversurferv3128p14pa4.jpg
http://img524.imageshack.us/img524/8136/silversurferv3128p17tx7.jpg

…then he should be able to do the same to BP.

Originally posted by Avlon
I'm not having it. I used the scan in a nice long post with multiple scans and reasonable explanation.

Difference is, the SS supporters were posting scans out of spite which is completely different. Oh, and with scans with names like "Supessucks" of course no bias is shown, correct?


Difference? Did you not read Bada’s post…

Originally posted by Badabing
For anyone who has a problem with what I said to Quan.....

He has continually posted low feats which go against the majority of showings just to support his case. That's against the rules. Pointing out another person's behavior to justify something doesn't work with me. I handle each report on an individual basis based on past problems. I would say the same thing to people who continually posted low end Thanos feats. The Boneclaw incident comes to mind. Or the SS/BP armbar feat. The fact that I've personally talked with him about this numerous times and his report, warning and ban record support my post. Any more questions or discussion should be taken off the threads and to a PM.

BlackJackal, I don't even know who you are. But the insults, flaming and trolling will not be tolerated.

Horrorwolf, your name has been in the reports with considerable regularity the past few days. I suggest you relax a bit. If you see any problems or feel you're being harassed then PM me with a link or use the report.

This isn't up for debate or discussion on a thread. Quan's history on KMC is what got him in trouble several times and is why I said something to him. I'm not here to be popular but maintain some consistency and order on the forum.

See the only “differences” between what you're doing and what quan did is that quan has been warned before and HE gets reported.

Originally posted by Avlon
Correct. Let's reprimand everyone who belives SS is a perfect 10/10 winner and has absolutely no weaknesses in battle at all and won't accept anything less. Your post is quite defensive of Quan. That disclaimer doesn't hide that.

Quan wasn’t warned because of what he believed, he was warned because he kept on posting a low end showing which is exactly what your doing. If the Mods want to warn quan for using a low end showing I fully support their actions because I don’t like using low showings like that. But the thing is that I don’t like ANYONE doing it, whether their name happens to be quanchi112 or not. And I wasn’t seeking equal punishment or anything like that either just some kind of equal standard being applied to the Surfer/BP incident and the Supes scan in question. And luckily for us we now know that there is such a standard in place…

Originally posted by Badabing
I handle each report on an individual basis based on past problems. I would say the same thing to people who continually posted low end Thanos feats. The Boneclaw incident comes to mind. Or the SS/BP armbar feat.
Originally posted by The Great Galen
It should have, in fact we all pretty much agreed SS would take 7-8/10....but then somehow it jsut kept on expanding. Anyhow lets continue I guess heh, oh and Nvr just ignore the haters.

I wouldn't say we all, since I and I'm sure quiet a few others say Superman would take the majority aswell. And it really can go both ways, I just see Supes (close the distance going right for the combination of punches) style of fighting being much more effective than SS (which scans weakness, then blast and move).

Originally posted by darthgoober
Difference? Did you not read Bada’s post…

Maybe you missed this post. It's not up for discussion anymore.

Originally posted by Badabing
This means the debate and discussion has ended. Period. Raoul is a mod and can address posts as he sees fit. We are all responsible for our own actions. If a person is banned then it's on them. Nobody "makes" people break rules or act inappropriately.

Originally posted by dvampire
I wouldn't say we all, since I and I'm sure quiet a few others say Superman would take the majority aswell. And it really can go both ways, I just see Supes (close the distance going right for the combination of punches) style of fighting being much more effective than SS (which scans weakness, then blast and move).
👆

It's time for this topic to die anyway.

Originally posted by Avlon
Maybe you missed this post. It's not up for discussion anymore.

I wasn't questioning or even really discussing quan's reprimand, the point of my post was to address the Surfer/armbar so you'd stop bring it up as if it's valid evidence. quans actions were ruled to be beyond discussion, not yours.

But you're probably still right in saying that it's not really up for discussion anymore given Bada's addressing of the feat in question.

Originally posted by Avlon
It's time for this topic to die anyway.

But why when we're FINALLY making some progress? Now we won't have to waste our time arguing over a the BP armbar and we can move on and figure out who has the best chances for victory.

Originally posted by Avlon
Maybe you missed this post. It's not up for discussion anymore.

👆

It's time for this topic to die anyway.


Fatality.

I'm not shy about saying that I dislike everybody in this thread. uhuh

durelly

Originally posted by darthgoober
I wasn't questioning or even really discussing quan's reprimand, the point of my post was to address the Surfer/armbar so you'd stop bring it up as if it's valid evidence. quans actions were ruled to be beyond discussion, not yours.

But you're probably still right in saying that it's not really up for discussion anymore given Bada's addressing of the feat in question.

But why when we're FINALLY making some progress? Now we won't have to waste our time arguing over a the BP armbar and we can move on and figure out who has the best chances for victory.


It's simple math and logic and probability. Superman and Surfer have about the same level of power overall. Surfer has more versatile powers. Superman is stronger and a bit tuffer. And has faster battle Speeds. Superman has exploitable weaknesses that just happen to be right up Surfer's alley. So really. Superman gets a few wins based upon the hand to hand and speed combo. After that, Surfer just owns him. This thread would be different if it were Black adam. Surfer would have a much tuffer time IMO. But Sueprman can't win more than 3. Not according to KMC rules. In a comic, yes, Superman would win everytime.