Originally posted by Naija boyMore probable than Surfer having read some report or overheard a conversation at some undisclosed time before encountering Gladiator and discovering it that way.
And uve far surpassed that level of stupidity a long time ago by failing to see the need for inference in this scenarioIts either surfer knew gladiatorrs vulnerability via having prior knowledge of it or by somehow uncovering it there and then. We know that ON panel surfer never discovered gladiators weakness and we know that it isnt common knowledge. We could then make the assumption that surfer found out about it in some unknown far off adventure. Quite a stretch to say the least. however we know that surfer has been able to sense very specific details about people before including,race,personal abilities and even bodily conditions. Now gladiators vulnerability to energy is a specific detail very much in line with that which surfer has previously sensed on panel. And our only other option is to assume that surfer found out about it in some far off incident that no one knows about. One conclusion is clearly more plausible than the other.
Silver Surfer 7/10. At least.
Originally posted by OneDumbG0he's scanned the universe several times, and felt half of the universe's sentient life evaporate before dr.strange did, evolved an entire planet's populace, etc. picking up on strontian's weakness to a certain wavelength of radiation is elementary.
More probable than Surfer having read some report or overheard a conversation at some undisclosed time before encountering Gladiator and discovering it that way.Silver Surfer 7/10. At least.
Originally posted by OneDumbG0
More probable than Surfer having read some report or overheard a conversation at some undisclosed time before encountering Gladiator and discovering it that way.Silver Surfer 7/10. At least.
Not sure i understand ODG.
to supeprime, i concede the point as indeed i didnt realize at the time that telepathy was an attribute of all rigellians and not just tana nile. (and trust me im only conceding because ive checked through evry single rigellian appearance to make sure its true). If i had known at the time i wouldnt have pressed that point since its relevance is little to the total outcome of this battle.still kudos to u.
^ As far as I'm concerned, what's more probable to explain Surfer's specific knowledge that he knew of Gladiator's weakness? Surfer read it in some report or overheard other characters talking about it sometime in the past off-panel? Or did he simply sense it?
I choose to believe the latter is more probable.
Silver Surfer 7/10.
Originally posted by OneDumbG0
^ As far as I'm concerned, what's more probable to explain Surfer's specific knowledge that he knew of Gladiator's weakness? Surfer read it in some report or overheard other characters talking about it sometime in the past off-panel? Or did he simply sense it?I choose to believe the latter is more probable.
Silver Surfer 7/10.
Meh imo the latter is still more probable(because of the lack of an onpanel instance of surfer discovering it and the fact that it isnt common knowledge) but without an instance of surfer using his Cosmic senses to perform similar to base an inference upon, its hard to arrive at a conclusive answer.
Originally posted by OneDumbG0
^ As far as I'm concerned, what's more probable to explain Surfer's specific knowledge that he knew of Gladiator's weakness? Surfer read it in some report or overheard other characters talking about it sometime in the past off-panel? Or did he simply sense it?I choose to believe the latter is more probable.
Silver Surfer 7/10.
*snicker*
Originally posted by AvlonGiven we have to choose between two options, characterizing those who choose the more probable option as "Marvel wanking fanboys" hardly seems fair.
Probability still doesn't make it true.Especially when the probability comes from Marvel wanking fanboys.
As a matter of fact, going into probability means that Supeprime made his point.
In fact, it's downright ignorant.
And considering Supeprime was arguing against the possibility that Surfer used his abilities to discern Gladiator's weakness, no he didn't. Not at all. He was presented with the same two options. He clearly believes the former to be true (that Surfer read some report or talked to someone about Gladiator's weakness, etc.) rather than the latter because he's opined the latter to not just be unprobable, but quite frankly from the below post, impossible:
Originally posted by SupeprimeShifting his position is a decision for him to make. It doesn't arise from you putting words into his mouth.
How am I trollling when I said the Surfer wins a majority over Superman? I however, actually know the character's abilities and I am not going to go on and on (like say you and some of your misguided buddies) about how he can sense people's specific weaknesses, because he cannot. He has NEVER done that.
Originally posted by OneDumbG0
Given we have to choose between two options, characterizing those who choose the more probable option as "Marvel wanking fanboys" hardly seems fair.
The "probability" only exists for those who want to see it. Like those who see Elvis in their waffles. The on panel does not show anything to actually prove the claim made about CA.
