Superman vs Silver surfer

Started by Adam Grimes387 pages

Silver Surfer 5,02 / 10

Surfer, 10/10.

Superman 6-7/10.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Superman 6-7/10.
Based on ?

Superman punches his lights out just like Thor did. Even suckershotting Thor when he was fighting Warlock didn't help him getting his head smashed in.

😂

Surfer fans pretend it never happened though.

Surfer 10/10

How?

This is the Surfer's fight to lose. He holds nearly every advantage, and could end it before it ever became serious.

Originally posted by Stoic
This is the Surfer's fight to lose. He holds nearly every advantage, and could end it before it ever became serious.

This requires a Surfer that clearly goes against his standard portrayals. A standard that you routinely point out to neuter Superman's abilities when brought up in debates.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Superman punches his lights out just like Thor did. Even suckershotting Thor when he was fighting Warlock didn't help him getting his head smashed in.

😂

Surfer fans pretend it never happened though.

That was blood and thunder Thor written well above his normal portrayals. He was running through characters in the past like nothing.

We see a recent Surfer/Thor confrontation. Surfer wasn't easily kod nor does the Hulk easily ko him like you imply. You can't ignore the history of the character while just focusing on the blood and thunder storyline alone. No one pretends it never happened you just seem to imply it's the only thing that ever happened.

Surfer wins this fight as he has advantages over Superman that a magical hammer that Superman doesn't possess as your reasoning as to how Superman wins.

Originally posted by Stoic
This is the Surfer's fight to lose. He holds nearly every advantage, and could end it before it ever became serious.

No he doesn't.

In that case, superman simply blitzes the shit out of him.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Based on ?

His own undying love for Superman, nothing else.

Originally posted by abhilegend
No he doesn't.

In that case, superman simply blitzes the shit out of him.

Did it work for Ganymede ?

Originally posted by abhilegend
No he doesn't.

In that case, superman simply blitzes the shit out of him.

😆 You still on that standby bullshit???

Funny how hypocritical you are when it comes to your character. Whenever Kal fails, you are quick to come up with excuse after excuse- He was weakened, it was a sucker punch, he fought ___ 9 issues ago and was still recovering, etc. But when it comes to serving your agenda, you conveniently fail to mention the Thor that knocked out Surfer wasn't a more powerful version of Thor. Did you really think no one would notice that?

Originally posted by Blue Area Vet
😆 You still on that standby bullshit???

Funny how hypocritical you are when it comes to your character. Whenever Kal fails, you are quick to come up with excuse after excuse- He was weakened, it was a sucker punch, he fought ___ 9 issues ago and was still recovering, etc. But when it comes to serving your agenda, you conveniently fail to mention the Thor that knocked out Surfer wasn't a more powerful version of Thor. Did you really think no one would notice that?


I didn't mention it because Thor was never more powerful than usual.

He was bloodlusted and that's it.

BRB beat the shit out of him in the same issue where he koed surfer in one hit.

If you have any mentions of him being more powerful than usual, feel free to post scans.

Until then? Shut up.

Originally posted by abhilegend
I didn't mention it because Thor was never more powerful than usual.

He was bloodlusted and that's it.

BRB beat the shit out of him in the same issue where he koed surfer in one hit.

If you have any mentions of him being more powerful than usual, feel free to post scans.

Until then? Shut up.

Oh, he wasn't portrayed as move powerful, huh? Sorry slappy, you can't have it both ways. If you are saying he wasn't portrayed as more powerful, then you are saying the character you are constantly insisting is so weak is in fact powerful as shit, but he holds back......sorta like you describe Superman. If you are saying he was portrayed as more powerful than normal like the rest of the sane comic reading community, then it's understandable why this ONE time he was able to one shot Surfer, and they have fought countless times. Either way you are ****ed and you are showing your frustration.

The thing that's funny is you are attempting to discredit Surfer's durability based on ONE portrayal while ignoring all the times Surfer has taken blows from Mjolnir, sometimes with no effect. Everyone is on to you.

Originally posted by abhilegend
I didn't mention it because Thor was never more powerful than usual.

He was bloodlusted and that's it.

BRB beat the shit out of him in the same issue where he koed surfer in one hit.

If you have any mentions of him being more powerful than usual, feel free to post scans.

Until then? Shut up.

BrB was also defeated and came back after he had time to recover. Thor ended up whopping him again when he had time to recover. Context.

Thor was portrayed as more powerful than in his typical story lines. Anyone who says otherwise isn't being honest with his ps signet portrayals. This is extremely high end for Thor. Superman doesn't possess mjiolnir and what happened when surfer met up with Thor recently outside this storyline ?

Was surfer easily kod ?

Originally posted by quanchi112
BrB was also defeated and came back after he had time to recover. Thor ended up whopping him again when he had time to recover. Context.

Thor was portrayed as more powerful than in his typical story lines. Anyone who says otherwise isn't being honest with his ps signet portrayals. This is extremely high end for Thor. Superman doesn't possess mjiolnir and what happened when surfer met up with Thor recently outside this storyline ?

Was surfer easily kod ?

Thor walloped Surfer with Mjolnir and put a lump on his head, Surfer just stared at him. In the same story, Thor literally flew through Galactus's head, so it's not like Thor was being portrayed as weak. You getting all this, Abby?

Originally posted by Blue Area Vet
Thor walloped Surfer with Mjolnir and put a lump on his head, Surfer just stared at him. In the same story, Thor literally flew through Galactus's head, so it's not like Thor was being portrayed as weak. You getting all this, Abby?
👆

Originally posted by Blue Area Vet
Thor walloped Surfer with Mjolnir and put a lump on his head, Surfer just stared at him. In the same story, Thor literally flew through Galactus's head, so it's not like Thor was being portrayed as weak. You getting all this, Abby?

Didn't Thor suffer from a wound though? Even Surfer asked him about this and it seemed to hurt Thor which would mean he wasn't at 100%.