Villain Grading Tiers

Ok, guys, heroes are nice and good and everybody loves them, but villains are a dime a dozen. And most are good for a laugh, from the really effective, to... Rhino.

So, based off of the other comics tiering systems we have around here, I was thinking of a tiering system designed to rank the effectiveness, fame (to an extent), and accomplishments of the various villains throughout comics. This keeps in mind goals of said villains, how often they're stopped, as well as intelligence, and whatnot.

I'll start it off, but feel free to add on, or vote for changes.

--------------------------------------------

A+

Anti-Monitor, Dr. Doom, Joker, Ozymandias

--------------------------------------------
A

Bullseye, Doomsday, Darkseid, Luthor, Magneto, Sabertooth, Sinestro

--------------------------------------------
B

Bane, Green Goblin, Kingpin, Loki, Mr. Sinister, Venom, Ra's al Ghul, Ronan

--------------------------------------------
C
Harley Quin, Killer Croc, Mojo, Scorpion

--------------------------------------------
F

Pastepot Pete, Rhino

Originally posted by SpookySmurph
Ok, guys, heroes are nice and good and everybody loves them, but villains are a dime a dozen. And most are good for a laugh, from the really effective, to... Rhino.

So, based off of the other comics tiering systems we have around here, I was thinking of a tiering system designed to rank the effectiveness, fame (to an extent), and accomplishments of the various villains throughout comics. This keeps in mind goals of said villains, how often they're stopped, as well as intelligence, and whatnot.

I'll start it off, but feel free to add on, or vote for changes.

--------------------------------------------

[b]A+

Dr. Doom, Joker, Ozymandias, Rhino

--------------------------------------------
A

Bullseye, Doomsday, Darkseid, Luthor, Magneto, Sabertooth, Sinestro

--------------------------------------------
B

Bane, Green Goblin, Kingpin, Loki, Mr. Sinister, Venom, Ra's al Ghul, Ronan

--------------------------------------------
C
Electro, Harley Quin, Killer Croc, Mojo, Scorpion

--------------------------------------------
F

Anti-Monitor, Pastepot Pete [/B]

oh

Get out.

Maxwell Lord must go on there pretty high.
Thanos also seems to be missing.

Proposals:

Thanos to A+ - 1 (Smurph) vs. 0
Maxwell Lord to A- 1 (Smurph) vs. 0

Thanos for A+ 2(smurph, chaos) vs 0

Thanos to A+

Absorbing Man to something low.

Thanos to A+.

--------------------------------------------

A+

Anti-Monitor, Dr. Doom, Joker, Ozymandias, Thanos

--------------------------------------------
A

Bullseye, Doomsday, Darkseid, Luthor, Magneto, Sabertooth, Sinestro

--------------------------------------------
B

Bane, Green Goblin, Kingpin, Loki, Mr. Sinister, Venom, Ra's al Ghul, Ronan

--------------------------------------------
C
Harley Quin, Killer Croc, Mojo, Scorpion

--------------------------------------------
F

Pastepot Pete, Rhino

Proposals:
Maxwell Lord to A- 1 (Smurph) vs. 0
Absorbing Man to C- 1 (Smurph) vs. 0

Changes:
-Added Thanos to A+

Proposal:

Galactus to A

Tyrant to A+

Galactus averages to B at best.

I actaully think sabertooth is in a good spot. hmm maybe add cyber to a as well

Proposals:
Maxwell Lord to A- 1 (Smurph) vs. 0
Absorbing Man to C- 1 (Smurph) vs. 0
Galactus to A- 1 (Masterbruce) vs. 2 (Smurph, Soljer)
Tyrant to A+ - 1(Masterbruce) vs. 0

Yeah... Big G doesn't have nearly the track record that he should have.

venom to b- or c+ maybe lower

the dude has all the powers, but he acts like an idiot. I mean for one spiderman really should not be a threat.

Logan should not be stalemating him either.

the guy is just not very effective considering his powers

How about Black Adam, Apocalypse, Grodd, Juggernaut and.......and.......Mole Man and Toy Man! w00t

Originally posted by Master-Borg
Proposal:

Galactus to A

Tyrant to A+

here your proving why your on the very low end of knowledge when considering the rest fo the board.

the fantastic four has defeat Big G. Big G loses to people he should smoke.

Galactus track record is B-ish, but his importance is A+, so averages out to A imo

he effectiveness and accoplisments are extremely low considering his abilties . Hell at best he be ranked a B over all. Though he likly a c

Proposal:

Luthor to A+

Originally posted by Battlehammer
venom to b- or c+ maybe lower

the dude has all the powers, but he acts like an idiot. I mean for one spiderman really should not be a threat.

Logan should not be stalemating him either.

the guy is just not very effective considering his powers

Proposals:
Maxwell Lord to A ... 1 (Smurph) vs. 0
Absorbing Man to C ... 1 (Smurph) vs. 0
Galactus to A ... 1 (Master-Borg) vs. 2 (Smurph, Soljer, Battlehammer)
Tyrant to A+ ... 1 (Master-Borg) vs. 0
Cyber to A ... 1 (Battlehammer) vs. 0
Luthor to A+ ... 1 (Master-Borg) vs. 1 (Smurph)