Villain Grading Tiers

Originally posted by SpookySmurph
I'm not making -/+ tiers except the first one.

[b]Proposals:
Maxwell Lord to A 1 (Smurph) vs. 0
Absorbing Man to C 1 (Smurph) vs. 0
Galactus to A 1 (Masterbruce) vs. 2 (Smurph, Soljer)
Tyrant to A+ 1(Masterbruce) vs. 0
Cyber to A 1(Battlehammer) vs. 0 [/B]

Originally posted by Battlehammer
here your proving why your on the very low end of knowledge when considering the rest fo the board.

the fantastic four has defeat Big G. Big G loses to people he should smoke.

Also, Galactus isn't even a villain...

Proposal:

Juggernaut to B

Apocalypse to B

Carnage to A

Originally posted by Master-Borg
Proposal:

Juggernaut to B

Apocalypse to B

Carnage to A

Originally posted by Battlehammer
carnage fights jsut as dumb as venom does if not worse

Originally posted by Master-Borg
Carnage is much more of a threat than Venom ever is. Carnage is dangerous, if Sabretooth is A, then so is Carnage.

sabertooth is an A becuase he actaully effective. He actaully kills people that Logan does nto want him to kill.

carnage fights like a morron. get beat by spiderman who should not even be a threat.

hell carnage is supose to be more powerful then venom yet venom tends to coem off as superior.

Originally posted by Battlehammer

carnage fights like a morron. get beat by spiderman who should not even be a threat.

whereas Logan fights off Sabretooth by himself, Spiderman usually has help fighting Carnage

If they fight heroes often, whether truly villainous or not, they can go on here, I suppose.

Proposals:
Maxwell Lord to A ... 1 (Smurph) vs. 0
Absorbing Man to C ... 1 (Smurph) vs. 0
Galactus to A ... 1 (Master-Borg) vs. 2 (Smurph, Soljer, Battlehammer)
Tyrant to A+ ... 1 (Master-Borg) vs. 0
Cyber to A ... 1 (Battlehammer) vs. 0
Luthor to A+ ... 1 (Master-Borg) vs. 1 (Smurph)
Juggernaut to B ... 1 (Master-Borg) vs. 0
Carnage to A ... 1 (Master-Borg) vs. 1 (Battlehammer)
Apocalypse to B ... 1 (Master-Borg) vs. 0

Start agreeing or defeating, guys... list's getting kinda big.

Disagree with Carnage and Galactus to A. Agree with Luthor to A+.

Galactus isn't a villain...

That's like putting Eternity on the list, or Adam Warlock.

Originally posted by SpookySmurph
If they fight heroes often, whether truly villainous or not, they can go on here, I suppose.

[b]Proposals:
Maxwell Lord to A ... 1 (Smurph) vs. 0
Absorbing Man to C ... 1 (Smurph) vs. 0
Galactus to A ... 1 (Master-Borg) vs. 2 (Smurph, Soljer, Battlehammer)
Tyrant to A+ ... 1 (Master-Borg) vs. 0
Cyber to A ... 1 (Battlehammer) vs. 0
Luthor to A+ ... 1 (Master-Borg) vs. 1 (Smurph)
Juggernaut to B ... 1 (Master-Borg) vs. 0
Carnage to A ... 1 (Master-Borg) vs. 1 (Battlehammer)
Apocalypse to B ... 1 (Master-Borg) vs. 0

Start agreeing or defeating, guys... list's getting kinda big. [/B]

Well, with Big G, he purposely tries to harm heroes, or their planets, and thus has a specific goal concerning the death of the heroes... so I don't mind if he's on the list. He has a dependant success rate, and is a natural enemy to heroes.

Proposals:
Maxwell Lord to A ... 1 (Smurph) vs. 0
Absorbing Man to C ... 2 (Smurph, Jason) vs. 0
Galactus to A ... 1 (Master-Borg) vs. 4 (Smurph, Soljer, Battlehammer, hugekent)
Tyrant to A+ ... 1 (Master-Borg) vs. 0
Cyber to A ... 1 (Battlehammer) vs. 0
Luthor to A+ ... 2 (Master-Borg, hugekent) vs. 1 (Smurph)
Juggernaut to B ... 1 (Master-Borg) vs. 0
Carnage to A ... 1 (Master-Borg) vs. 2 (Battlehammer, hugekent)
Apocalypse to B ... 1 (Master-Borg) vs. 0

Notes:

Vote to have Galactus on the list?

1 (Smurph) vs. 1 (Bran)

Originally posted by SpookySmurph
Well, with Big G, he purposely tries to harm heroes, or their planets, and thus has a specific goal concerning the death of the heroes... so I don't mind if he's on the list. He has a dependant success rate, and is a natural enemy to heroes.

It's like when a Lion has to eat, he eats something, I'm sure. Is he 'evil'?
When Galactus has to eat, he eats planets. Is that 'evil'?

If he's on the list, then you might as well throw Thor on the list for eating animals.

Galactus is just as evil as anyone who eats meat, I'm afraid.

Originally posted by Bransolute
He doesn't purposely.
When he has to, he defends himself.

It's like when a Lion has to eat, he eats something, I'm sure. Is he 'evil'?
When Galactus has to eat, he eats planets. Is that 'evil'?

If he's on the list, then you might as well throw Thor on the list for eating animals.

Galactus is just as evil as anyone who eats meat, I'm afraid.

Unlike meat eaters or lions Galactus is both aware of the sentientience of his prey and sentient himself.

Originally posted by Bransolute
He doesn't purposely.
When he has to, he defends himself.

It's like when a Lion has to eat, he eats something, I'm sure. Is he 'evil'?
When Galactus has to eat, he eats planets. Is that 'evil'?

If he's on the list, then you might as well throw Thor on the list for eating animals.

Galactus is just as evil as anyone who eats meat, I'm afraid.

Carnage is not A.

Agree with Absorbing Man.

Agree with Maxwell Lord.

Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos
Unlike meat eaters or lions Galactus is both aware of the sentientience of his prey and sentient himself.

Plus, the things Galactus eats, are so below him in intelligence, and tech, just like our good eats are.

Originally posted by Bransolute
We know monkeys are smart... but we still eat them... 😖hifty:

Plus, the things Galactus eats, are so below him in intelligence, and tech, just like our good eats are.

Do you have negotiations with your food? There's a massive difference.

Glactus considers himself superior but he's aware that his actions kill creature that build civilization and have thoughts and emotions. Yet he does it anyway. Of course he does it to save all of reality but meh.

Originally posted by Bransolute
We know monkeys are smart... but we still eat them... 😖hifty:

Plus, the things Galactus eats, are so below him in intelligence, and tech, just like our good eats are.

Originally posted by Soljer
Carnage is not A.