Villain Grading Tiers

A+

Anti-Monitor, Dr. Doom, Joker, Lex Luthor, Magneto, Ozymandias, Thanos

--------------------------------------------

A

Bullseye, Doomsday, Darkseid, Green Goblin, Sinestro

--------------------------------------------

B

Apocalypse, Bane, Kingpin, Loki, Mr. Sinister, Ra's al Ghul, Ronan, Sabretooh , Venom

--------------------------------------------

C

Absorbing Man, Harley Quin, Killer Croc, Mojo, Scorpion

--------------------------------------------

F

Pastepot Pete, Rhino

--------------------------

Proposals:
Maxwell Lord to A ... 3 (Smurph, Soljer, Capt. Spaulding) vs. 0
Tyrant to A+ ... 2 (Master-Borg, Bran) vs. 1 (Capt. Spaulding)
Cyber to A ... 1 (Battlehammer) vs. 2 (Capt. Spaulding, Bran)
Luthor to A+ ... 6 (Master-Borg, hugekent, Capt. Spaulding, jrodslam, V , Bran) vs. 1 (Smurph)
Juggernaut to B ... 1 (Master-Borg) vs. 1 (Capt. Spaulding)
Apocalypse to B ... 4 (Master-Borg, Capt. Spaulding, Ash, Switch) vs. 1 (Bransolute)
Green Goblin to A ... 4 (Master-Borg, Capt. Spaulding, Jyppe, Rhinoceros ) vs. 1 (Switch)
Black Adam to A+ ... 3 (Bran, Switch, V) vs. 2 (Smurph, Capt. Spaulding)
Red Hood for A ... 1 (Martian Mind) vs. 3 (Soljer, Smurph, Capt Spaulding)
Malefic for A ... 1 (Maritan) vs. 1 (Smurph)
Mephisto to A+ ... 1 (Maestro) vs. 2 (Smurph Capt. Spaulding)
Zoom to B ... 1 (Gecko) vs. 1 (Soljer)
Two-Face for B ... 2 (Erik L, Capt. Spaulding) vs. 0
Hush for B ... 2 (Erik L, Capt. Spaulding) vs. 0
Exodus for B ... 1 (Erik L) vs. 0
Morlun for B ... 2 (Erik L, Niñoaraña) vs. 1 (Gecko)
Zoom to A ... 1 (Soljer) vs. 1 (Gecko)
Cassandra Nova to A+ 2 (Jyppe, llagrok) vs 0
Xorn to B 1 (Jyppe) vs 0
Hulk to A ... 1 (Jyppe) vs 1 (Capt. Spaulding)
Onslaught to A ... 1 (Jyppe) vs 1 (Capt. Spaulding)
Loki to A ... 3 (Bran, Capt Spaulding, llagrok) v.s 0
Sabretooth down to B ... 6 (Bran, Capt. Spaulding, batdude123, Switch, V, llagrok) v.s 2 (Soljer, Smurph)
Ra's al Ghul to A ... 2 (batdude123, Capt. Spaulding) vs. 0
Major Force to C ... 1 (Capt. Spaulding) v.s 0
Doctor Octopus to B ... 1 (Capt. Spaulding) v.s 0
Bullseye to B ... 1 (Capt. Spaulding) v.s 0

Originally posted by Bransolute
I object to Goblin moving up.

Originally posted by Capt Spaulding
A+

Anti-Monitor, Dr. Doom, Joker, Lex Luthor, Magneto, Ozymandias, Thanos

--------------------------------------------

A

Bullseye, Doomsday, Darkseid, Green Goblin, Sinestro

--------------------------------------------

B

Apocalypse, Bane, Kingpin, Loki, Mr. Sinister, Ra's al Ghul, Ronan, Sabretooh , Venom

--------------------------------------------

C

Absorbing Man, Harley Quin, Killer Croc, Mojo, Scorpion

--------------------------------------------

F

Pastepot Pete, Rhino

--------------------------

Proposals:
Maxwell Lord to A ... 3 (Smurph, Soljer, Capt. Spaulding) vs. 0
Tyrant to A+ ... 2 (Master-Borg, Bran) vs. 1 (Capt. Spaulding)
Cyber to A ... 1 (Battlehammer) vs. 2 (Capt. Spaulding, Bran)
Luthor to A+ ... 6 (Master-Borg, hugekent, Capt. Spaulding, jrodslam, V , Bran) vs. 1 (Smurph)
Juggernaut to B ... 1 (Master-Borg) vs. 1 (Capt. Spaulding)
Apocalypse to B ... 4 (Master-Borg, Capt. Spaulding, Ash, Switch) vs. 1 (Bransolute)
Green Goblin to A ... 4 (Master-Borg, Capt. Spaulding, Jyppe, Rhinoceros ) vs. 1 (Switch)
Black Adam to A+ ... 3 (Bran, Switch, V) vs. 2 (Smurph, Capt. Spaulding)
Red Hood for A ... 1 (Martian Mind) vs. 3 (Soljer, Smurph, Capt Spaulding)
Malefic for A ... 1 (Maritan) vs. 1 (Smurph)
Mephisto to A+ ... 1 (Maestro) vs. 2 (Smurph Capt. Spaulding)
Zoom to B ... 1 (Gecko) vs. 1 (Soljer)
Two-Face for B ... 2 (Erik L, Capt. Spaulding) vs. 0
Hush for B ... 2 (Erik L, Capt. Spaulding) vs. 0
Exodus for B ... 1 (Erik L) vs. 0
Morlun for B ... 2 (Erik L, Niñoaraña) vs. 1 (Gecko)
Zoom to A ... 1 (Soljer) vs. 1 (Gecko)
Cassandra Nova to A+ 2 (Jyppe, llagrok) vs 0
Xorn to B 1 (Jyppe) vs 0
Hulk to A ... 1 (Jyppe) vs 1 (Capt. Spaulding)
Onslaught to A ... 1 (Jyppe) vs 1 (Capt. Spaulding)
Loki to A ... 3 (Bran, Capt Spaulding, llagrok) v.s 0
Sabretooth down to B ... 6 (Bran, Capt. Spaulding, batdude123, Switch, V, llagrok) v.s 2 (Soljer, Smurph)
Ra's al Ghul to A ... 2 (batdude123, Capt. Spaulding) vs. 0
Major Force to C ... 1 (Capt. Spaulding) v.s 0
Doctor Octopus to B ... 1 (Capt. Spaulding) v.s 0
[b]Bullseye to B ... 1 (Capt. Spaulding) v.s 1 (Bran) [/B]

Originally posted by Bransolute
I object to Bullseye moving down.

Originally posted by Bransolute
I object to Bullseye moving down.

I also object.

A+

Anti-Monitor, Dr. Doom, Joker, Lex Luthor, Magneto, Ozymandias, Thanos

--------------------------------------------

A

Bullseye, Doomsday, Darkseid, Green Goblin, Sinestro

--------------------------------------------

B

Apocalypse, Bane, Kingpin, Loki, Mr. Sinister, Ra's al Ghul, Ronan, Sabretooh , Venom

--------------------------------------------

C

Absorbing Man, Harley Quin, Killer Croc, Mojo, Scorpion

--------------------------------------------

F

Pastepot Pete, Rhino

--------------------------

Proposals:
Maxwell Lord to A ... 3 (Smurph, Soljer, Capt. Spaulding) vs. 0
Tyrant to A+ ... 2 (Master-Borg, Bran) vs. 1 (Capt. Spaulding)
Cyber to A ... 1 (Battlehammer) vs. 2 (Capt. Spaulding, Bran)
Luthor to A+ ... 6 (Master-Borg, hugekent, Capt. Spaulding, jrodslam, V , Bran) vs. 1 (Smurph)
Juggernaut to B ... 1 (Master-Borg) vs. 1 (Capt. Spaulding)
Apocalypse to B ... 4 (Master-Borg, Capt. Spaulding, Ash, Switch) vs. 1 (Bransolute)
Green Goblin to A ... 4 (Master-Borg, Capt. Spaulding, Jyppe, Rhinoceros ) vs. 2 (Switch, Bran)
Black Adam to A+ ... 3 (Bran, Switch, V) vs. 2 (Smurph, Capt. Spaulding)
Red Hood for A ... 1 (Martian Mind) vs. 3 (Soljer, Smurph, Capt Spaulding)
Malefic for A ... 1 (Maritan) vs. 1 (Smurph)
Mephisto to A+ ... 1 (Maestro) vs. 2 (Smurph Capt. Spaulding)
Zoom to B ... 1 (Gecko) vs. 1 (Soljer)
Two-Face for B ... 2 (Erik L, Capt. Spaulding) vs. 0
Hush for B ... 2 (Erik L, Capt. Spaulding) vs. 0
Exodus for B ... 1 (Erik L) vs. 0
Morlun for B ... 2 (Erik L, Niñoaraña) vs. 1 (Gecko)
Zoom to A ... 1 (Soljer) vs. 1 (Gecko)
Cassandra Nova to A+ 2 (Jyppe, llagrok) vs 0
Xorn to B 1 (Jyppe) vs 0
Hulk to A ... 1 (Jyppe) vs 1 (Capt. Spaulding)
Onslaught to A ... 1 (Jyppe) vs 1 (Capt. Spaulding)
Loki to A ... 3 (Bran, Capt Spaulding, llagrok) v.s 0
Sabretooth down to B ... 6 (Bran, Capt. Spaulding, batdude123, Switch, V, llagrok) v.s 2 (Soljer, Smurph)
Ra's al Ghul to A ... 2 (batdude123, Capt. Spaulding) vs. 0
Major Force to C ... 1 (Capt. Spaulding) v.s 0
Doctor Octopus to B ... 1 (Capt. Spaulding) v.s 0
Bullseye to B ... 2 (Capt. Spaulding, Switch) v.s 2 (Bran, V)

Originally posted by Capt Spaulding
Proposals:
Maxwell Lord to A ... 3 (Smurph, Soljer, Capt. Spaulding) vs. 0
Tyrant to A+ ... 2 (Master-Borg, Bran) vs. 1 (Capt. Spaulding)
Cyber to A ... 1 (Battlehammer) vs. 2 (Capt. Spaulding, Bran)
Luthor to A+ ... 6 (Master-Borg, hugekent, Capt. Spaulding, jrodslam, V , Bran) vs. 1 (Smurph)
Juggernaut to B ... 1 (Master-Borg) vs. 1 (Capt. Spaulding)
Apocalypse to B ... 4 (Master-Borg, Capt. Spaulding, Ash, Switch) vs. 1 (Bransolute)
Green Goblin to A ... 4 (Master-Borg, Capt. Spaulding, Jyppe, Rhinoceros ) vs. 1 (Switch)
Black Adam to A+ ... 3 (Bran, Switch, V) vs. 2 (Smurph, Capt. Spaulding)
Red Hood for A ... 1 (Martian Mind) vs. 3 (Soljer, Smurph, Capt Spaulding)
Malefic for A ... 1 (Maritan) vs. 1 (Smurph)
Mephisto to A+ ... 1 (Maestro) vs. 2 (Smurph Capt. Spaulding)
Zoom to B ... 1 (Gecko) vs. 1 (Soljer)
Two-Face for B ... 2 (Erik L, Capt. Spaulding) vs. 0
Hush for B ... 2 (Erik L, Capt. Spaulding) vs. 0
Exodus for B ... 1 (Erik L) vs. 0
Morlun for B ... 2 (Erik L, Niñoaraña) vs. 1 (Gecko)
Zoom to A ... 1 (Soljer) vs. 1 (Gecko)
Cassandra Nova to A+ 2 (Jyppe, llagrok) vs 0
Xorn to B 1 (Jyppe) vs 0
Hulk to A ... 1 (Jyppe) vs 1 (Capt. Spaulding)
Onslaught to A ... 1 (Jyppe) vs 1 (Capt. Spaulding)
Loki to A ... 3 (Bran, Capt Spaulding, llagrok) v.s 0
Sabretooth down to B ... 6 (Bran, Capt. Spaulding, batdude123, Switch, V, llagrok) v.s 2 (Soljer, Smurph)
Ra's al Ghul to A ... 2 (batdude123, Capt. Spaulding) vs. 0
Major Force to C ... 1 (Capt. Spaulding) v.s 0
Doctor Octopus to B ... 1 (Capt. Spaulding) v.s 0
[b]Bullseye to B ... 2 (Capt. Spaulding, Switch) v.s 2 (Bran, V) [/B]

Originally posted by Bransolute
I object to Goblin moving up.

fixed

Cyber A - Against
Onslaught A - Against
Zoom A - For
Black Adam A+ - Against
Blastaar C - For
Annihilus A+ - For

Proposals:

Cyber to A ... against
Black Adam to A+ ... against
Mephisto to A+ ... against
Two-Face for B ... agree
Morlun for B ... agree
Onslaught to A ... agree
Sabretooth down to B ... agree
Ra's al Ghul to A ... agree
Doctor Octopus to B ... agree
Bullseye to B ... agree

Originally posted by jrodslam
For - Black Adam, Apocalypse and Luthor.

DC
I nominate Cyborg for A+
I nominate Major Force for B or A
I nominate Despero for A
I nominate Eclipso for A+

Marvel
I nominate Mr. Sinister to A
I nominate Red Skull to A or B

Im FOR Bullseye and Sabes being bumped down a level.

Originally posted by Switch 07
I object.

Originally posted by Bransolute
I object to Goblin moving up.

Proposals:
Maxwell Lord to A ... 3 (Smurph, Soljer, Capt. Spaulding) vs. 0
Tyrant to A+ ... 2 (Master-Borg, Bran) vs. 1 (Capt. Spaulding)
Cyber to A ... 1 (Battlehammer) vs. 4 (Capt. Spaulding, Bran. llagrok, Master-Borg)
Luthor to A+ ... 6 (Master-Borg, hugekent, Capt. Spaulding, jrodslam, V , Bran) vs. 1 (Smurph)
Juggernaut to B ... 1 (Master-Borg) vs. 1 (Capt. Spaulding)
Apocalypse to B ... 4 (Master-Borg, Capt. Spaulding, Ash, Switch) vs. 1 (Bransolute)
Green Goblin to A ... 4 (Master-Borg, Capt. Spaulding, Jyppe, Rhinoceros ) vs. 1 (Switch)
Black Adam to A+ ... 3 (Bran, Switch, V) vs. 3 (Smurph, Capt. Spaulding, Master-Borg)
Red Hood for A ... 1 (Martian Mind) vs. 3 (Soljer, Smurph, Capt Spaulding)
Malefic for A ... 1 (Maritan) vs. 1 (Smurph)
Mephisto to A+ ... 1 (Maestro, Master-Borg) vs. 2 (Smurph Capt. Spaulding)
Zoom to B ... 1 (Gecko) vs. 1 (Soljer)
Two-Face for B ... 2 (Erik L, Capt. Spaulding, master-Borg) vs. 0
Hush for B ... 2 (Erik L, Capt. Spaulding) vs. 0
Exodus for B ... 1 (Erik L) vs. 0
Morlun for B ... 2 (Erik L, Niñoaraña, master-borg) vs. 1 (Gecko)
Zoom to A ... 1 (Soljer) vs. 1 (Gecko)
Cassandra Nova to A+ 2 (Jyppe, llagrok) vs 0
Xorn to B 1 (Jyppe) vs 0
Hulk to A ... 1 (Jyppe) vs 1 (Capt. Spaulding)
Onslaught to A ... 1 (Jyppe, master-borg) vs 1 (Capt. Spaulding)
Loki to A ... 3 (Bran, Capt Spaulding, llagrok) v.s 0
Sabretooth down to B ... 7 (Bran, Capt. Spaulding, batdude123, Switch, V, llagrok, Master-borg) v.s 2 (Soljer, Smurph)
Ra's al Ghul to A ... 3 (batdude123, Capt. Spaulding, Master-Borg) vs. 0
Major Force to C ... 1 (Capt. Spaulding) v.s 0
Doctor Octopus to B ... 2 (Capt. Spaulding, Master-borg) v.s 0
Bullseye to B ... 3 (Capt. Spaulding, Switch, masterborg) v.s 2 (Bran, V)

this is way to time consuming, add your name, if you want to change it

Originally posted by Capt Spaulding
Proposals:
Maxwell Lord to A ... 3 (Smurph, Soljer, Capt. Spaulding) vs. 0
Tyrant to A+ ... 2 (Master-Borg, Bran) vs. 1 (Capt. Spaulding)
[b]Cyber to A ... 1 (Battlehammer) vs. 4 (Capt. Spaulding, Bran. llagrok, Master-Borg)
Luthor to A+ ... 6 (Master-Borg, hugekent, Capt. Spaulding, jrodslam, V , Bran) vs. 1 (Smurph)
Juggernaut to B ... 1 (Master-Borg) vs. 1 (Capt. Spaulding)
Apocalypse to B ... 4 (Master-Borg, Capt. Spaulding, Ash, Switch) vs. 1 (Bransolute)
Green Goblin to A ... 4 (Master-Borg, Capt. Spaulding, Jyppe, Rhinoceros ) vs. 1 (Switch, Bran, Jason)
Black Adam to A+ ... 3 (Bran, Switch, V) vs. 3 (Smurph, Capt. Spaulding, Master-Borg)
Red Hood for A ... 1 (Martian Mind) vs. 3 (Soljer, Smurph, Capt Spaulding)
Malefic for A ... 1 (Maritan) vs. 1 (Smurph)
Mephisto to A+ ... 1 (Maestro, Master-Borg) vs. 2 (Smurph Capt. Spaulding)
Zoom to B ... 1 (Gecko) vs. 1 (Soljer)
Two-Face for B ... 2 (Erik L, Capt. Spaulding, master-Borg) vs. 0
Hush for B ... 2 (Erik L, Capt. Spaulding) vs. 0
Exodus for B ... 1 (Erik L) vs. 0
Morlun for B ... 2 (Erik L, Niñoaraña, master-borg) vs. 1 (Gecko)
Zoom to A ... 1 (Soljer) vs. 1 (Gecko)
Cassandra Nova to A+ 2 (Jyppe, llagrok) vs 0
Xorn to B 1 (Jyppe) vs 0
Hulk to A ... 1 (Jyppe) vs 1 (Capt. Spaulding)
Onslaught to A ... 1 (Jyppe, master-borg) vs 1 (Capt. Spaulding)
Loki to A ... 3 (Bran, Capt Spaulding, llagrok) v.s 0
Sabretooth down to B ... 7 (Bran, Capt. Spaulding, batdude123, Switch, V, llagrok, Master-borg) v.s 2 (Soljer, Smurph)
Ra's al Ghul to A ... 3 (batdude123, Capt. Spaulding, Master-Borg) vs. 0
Major Force to C ... 1 (Capt. Spaulding) v.s 0
Doctor Octopus to B ... 2 (Capt. Spaulding, Master-borg) v.s 0
Bullseye to B ... 3 (Capt. Spaulding, Switch, masterborg) v.s 2 (Bran, V) [/B]

Originally posted by Capt Spaulding
this is way to time consuming, add your name, if you want to change it

Originally posted by jrodslam
For - Black Adam, Apocalypse and Luthor.

DC
I nominate Cyborg for A+
I nominate Major Force for B or A
I nominate Despero for A
I nominate Eclipso for A+

Marvel
I nominate Mr. Sinister to A
I nominate Red Skull to A or B

Im FOR Bullseye and Sabes being bumped down a level.

Someone add this...

Adding what I feel is a MUCH needed piece of criteria for this list:

Character Quality
-This included character complexity, tribulations, originality, and overall appeal.

This is to rank as equal criteria against/with:
-Accomplishments
-Capacity for villainous acts
-Fame

🙂

-Should we have more tiers? If so, what should they be, where should they be? Be specific.

---------------------

Thanks everyone who kept this list updated. Especially Red.

Soon I'll be adding/changing Maxwell Lord, Luthor, Apocalypse, Two-Face, Doc Ock, Morlun, Loki and Ra's al Ghul. Object now, or hold your peace for the next few days.

Cyber has been defeated.

Proposals:
Apocalypse to B ... 5 (Master-Borg, Capt. Spaulding, Ash, Switch, Jrod) vs. 1 (Bransolute)
Black Adam to A+ ... 4 (Bran, Switch, V, Jrod) vs. 3 (Smurph, Capt. Spaulding, Master-Borg)
Bullseye to B ... 4(Capt. Spaulding, Switch, masterborg, Jrod) v.s 3 (Bran, V, Smurph)
Cassandra Nova to A+... 2 (Jyppe, llagrok) vs 0
Despero for A ... 1 (Jrod) vs. 0
Doctor Octopus to B ... 3 (Capt. Spaulding, Master-borg, Smurph) v.s 0
Eclipso for A+ ... 1 (Jrod) vs. 1 (Smurph)
Exodus for B ... 1 (Erik L) vs. 0
Hulk to A ... 2 (Jyppe, Smurph) vs 1 (Capt. Spaulding)
Hush for B ... 2 (Erik L, Capt. Spaulding) vs. 0
Juggernaut to B ... 1 (Master-Borg) vs. 1 (Capt. Spaulding)
Loki to A ... 3 (Bran, Capt Spaulding, llagrok) v.s 0
Luthor to A+ ... 7 (Master-Borg, hugekent, Capt. Spaulding, jrodslam, V , Bran, Jrod) vs. 1 (Smurph)
Major Force to A ... 1 (Jrodslam) vs. 1 (Capt. Spaulding)
Major Force to B ... 1 (Jrodslam) vs. 1 (Capt. Spaulding)
Major Force to C ... 1 (Capt. Spaulding) v.s 1 (Jrodslam)
Malefic for A ... 1 (Maritan) vs. 1 (Smurph)
Maxwell Lord to A ... 3 (Smurph, Soljer, Capt. Spaulding) vs. 0
Mephisto to A+ ... 2 (Maestro, Master-Borg) vs. 2 (Smurph, Capt. Spaulding)
Morlun for B ... 2 (Erik L, Niñoaraña, master-borg, Smurph) vs. 1 (Gecko)
Mr. Sinister for A ... 1 (Jrodslam)
Onslaught to A ... 1 (Jyppe, master-borg) vs 2 (Capt. Spaulding, Smurph)
Ra's al Ghul to A ... 3 (batdude123, Capt. Spaulding, Master-Borg) vs. 0
Red Hood for A ... 1 (Martian Mind) vs. 3 (Soljer, Smurph, Capt Spaulding)
Red Skull to A ... 1 (Jrodslam)
Red Skull to B ... 1 (Jrodslam)
Two-Face for B ... 3 (Erik L, Capt. Spaulding, master-Borg) vs. 0
Tyrant to A+ ... 2 (Master-Borg, Bran) vs. 1 (Capt. Spaulding)
Xorn to B ... 1 (Jyppe) vs 0
Zoom to A ... 1 (Soljer) vs. 1 (Gecko)
Zoom to B ... 1 (Gecko) vs. 2 (Soljer, Smurph)

Hulk shouldn't be on the list.

Originally posted by Switch 07
Hulk shouldn't be on the list.

Agreed. He's very VERY rarely a villain...