IT Doesnt matter if ROTS Sids could or could not...though is very cool regardless.. Cannonly Sids has been declared the most powerful Sith EVER(by lucas)(however sad it seems and however dissapointed i am with lucas's ideas and decisions.)
we have to accept that fact and say Sids as Force and Saber skills no other sith can beat.
SIDS Win though Nihilus is up there
Originally posted by vader11
There's no doubt that Sidious is the most powerful Sith. But DE Sidious is much more pwerful than OT version and OT is more powerful than ROTS version. I think there maybe some siths that can beat ROTS Sidious.
I'm curious to hear who you think that can take out ROTS Sidious
Originally posted by Darth Hord
I'm curious to hear who you think that can take out ROTS Sidious
Sith Lords that can take out ROTS Sidious ? I'd say that Exar Kun might have a good chance there. One could add Revan to the list and if you want to enter the realm of speculation, Ragnos would be another good candidate. Sidious, as he is in ROTS, is "just" the strongest Sith Lord of Bane's Order. He is the strongest Sith up to that point in his DE incarnation. And even that doesn't mean that he can archieve a guaranteed victory against every single Sith Lord that lived before him.
Originally posted by Borbarad
Sith Lords that can take out ROTS Sidious ? I'd say that Exar Kun might have a good chance there. One could add Revan to the list and if you want to enter the realm of speculation, Ragnos would be another good candidate. Sidious, as he is in ROTS, is "just" the strongest Sith Lord of Bane's Order. He is the strongest Sith up to that point in his DE incarnation. And even that doesn't mean that he can archieve a guaranteed victory against every single Sith Lord that lived before him.
Kun is the only one who someone could make a semi-decent case for. And the "guarenteed victory" goes without saying. There's no guarentee that Ragnos could take out Coleman Trebor.
Well I'm not sure that ROTS Sidious could defeat Nihilus in a purely TK fight. For one, Nihilus seems to be stronger in the Force than he is in lightsaber fighting, so he could still be weaker than Sidious overall but beat him in a purely Force fight such as this. However, this is only ROTS Sidious; DE Sidious would dominate Nihilus I think.
Originally posted by Darth_Glentract
Well I'm not sure that ROTS Sidious could defeat Nihilus in a purely TK fight. For one, Nihilus seems to be stronger in the Force than he is in lightsaber fighting, so he could still be weaker than Sidious overall but beat him in a purely Force fight such as this. However, this is only ROTS Sidious; DE Sidious would dominate Nihilus I think.
DE Sidious would definitely dominate Darth Nihilus, but refering to RotS Sidious as ONLY RotS Sidious makes me think you're saying he's not very, very powerful, or at least not a match for Nihilus. Even though this is "only" RotS Sidious, he is still one of the most powerful Sith Lords ever, and I believe he could give Nihilus a very, very tough fight.