Should the Mace/Sideous fight be redone?

G got it.

It would be so awesome if they re-did this fight. Mace is like the best duelist in the jedi order, and Sidious can click his fingers to throw a freakin spaceship. To be honest, I was kinda bothered about waiting to see Anakin vs. Oi-Wan, but i really wanted to know how the best jedi duelist died, and this fight did not do him justice. Redo Redo REDO!

But if they redo it, then that means Lucas is admitting he did wrong, and he can't do that.

Nope.

Proved. It has queeq's agreement. 😛

It was ridiculous at the beginning.

Indeed.

There is nothing freaking wrong with the fight. It should be left alone. Ian may not have done every part of it but he did train to be able to do most of it. Give the man credit. He never had it so tough as Palpatine ie having to use a lightsaber.

It was the parts WITH Ian that kinda sucked. The faces.... those faces...

Originally posted by MrCampion
There is nothing freaking wrong with the fight. It should be left alone. Ian may not have done every part of it but he did train to be able to do most of it. Give the man credit. He never had it so tough as Palpatine ie having to use a lightsaber.

If you read posts before...people don't really have a problem that he didn't do the whole fight, it is more of it lacked quite a bit of quality and entertainment the others had.

Entertainment enough with Ian's funny faces.

Originally posted by General G
If you read posts before...people don't really have a problem that he didn't do the whole fight, it is more of it lacked quite a bit of quality and entertainment the others had.

I did read the posts before and tailored my reply based on that. Perhaps I was not clear, but my first sentence that there is nothing wrong with the fight includes it being full of the qaulity and entertainment value you speak of. I found it more exciting than the other ROTS duels. It had quality and was entertaining.

G's point is that many disagree with your assesment of that fight. And you;re entitled to your opinion.

Originally posted by MrCampion
I did read the posts before and tailored my reply based on that. Perhaps I was not clear, but my first sentence that there is nothing wrong with the fight includes it being full of the qaulity and entertainment value you speak of. I found it more exciting than the other ROTS duels. It had quality and was entertaining.

I don't think it was too clear, over half the post was based on Ian not doing the whole fight, and having a stunt double, so I based my post off of that, and it was semi-interesting, i liked the flip he did, that added to Sidious in my opinion, but the whole fight as a whole didn't offer much.

Well it may not have been completely clear before but it is now. Or should be.

Clear enough, and yet I still disagree.

Disagree about the the wording o my first post?

Disagree with your opinion that it is a comparable duel to other good ones.

OKay then fair enough.

I think Sidious let Windu "win" so Anakin could intervene, therefore Mace was not superior.

I really doubt, if he had let himself into the dire position and Anakin had left or refused, he would've let Windu's saber touch him, either with lightning or a force push. Nobody's probably cutting through Sidious' lightning. But he knew Anakin was going to turn.