Who really wone: Yoda vs Sidious"

Who really won this fight?

It was a draw. had it remained a saber duel, Yoda would have won.

Yoda should have won, as he was superior. he lost because of circumstances he couldn't control.

But anyway yeah Yoda had actually succeeded in disarming Sideous, and he was winning the force fight to but he fell off.

Yoda fled... so he lost.

live to fight another day, man. he didnt lose, he just chose to fight another day.

[i]live to fight another day, man. he didnt lose, he just chose to fight another day

live to fight another day, man. he didnt lose, he just chose to fight another day

You don't need to run to fight another day if you aren't losing. 😉

felt the need to tell me that twice, did you?

Actually I have no idea why the first post is there, it must be an error, seeing as how its incomplete.

Originally posted by fascistcrusader
live to fight another day, man. he didnt lose, he just chose to fight another day

You don't need to run to fight another day if you aren't losing. 😉

Depends, losgng is relative.

Yoda would have beaten Sideous, he was actually beating him the entire match, but he would have lost against the clone troopers that came to his rescue.

Yoda would have beaten Sideous, he was actually beating him the entire match, but he would have lost against the clone troopers that came to his rescue.

It seemed to me it was on equal ters and then Sisious gained the upper hand after it went to a force fight. And if Yoda could penetrate the Jedi temple and defeat Sidious no problem, no amount of clones could stop him.

He just lost to Sidious, plain and simple.

Originally posted by fascistcrusader
Yoda would have beaten Sideous, he was actually beating him the entire match, but he would have lost against the clone troopers that came to his rescue.

It seemed to me it was on equal ters and then Sisious gained the upper hand after it went to a force fight. And if Yoda could penetrate the Jedi temple and defeat Sidious no problem, no amount of clones could stop him.

He just lost to Sidious, plain and simple.

Originally posted by fascistcrusader
Yoda would have beaten Sideous, he was actually beating him the entire match, but he would have lost against the clone troopers that came to his rescue.

It seemed to me it was on equal ters and then Sisious gained the upper hand after it went to a force fight. And if Yoda could penetrate the Jedi temple and defeat Sidious no problem, no amount of clones could stop him.

It "seemed" doesn't mean anything, really. You can see it plainly from he battle. They were in the force battle and at first Sideous seemed to win, then Yoda got pissed and forced the lightning back, you can even see Sideous starting to lean back from the power, and then it exploded. Yoda, being smaller, lighter, and mroe on the edge, simpyl fell off while Sideous got lucky and managed to grab on to a handhold. At that point it was over.

And if Yoda could penetrate the Jedi temple and defeat Sidious no problem, no amount of clones could stop him.

You are a fool. Yoda, without a lightsaber, can't fight Sideous AND an ARMY of Clone Troopers at the same time. No one can, except for Luke "I make planets invisible with the force" Skywalker.

Originally posted by Blax_Hydralisk
It "seemed" doesn't mean anything, really. You can see it plainly from he battle. They were in the force battle and at first Sideous seemed to win, then Yoda got pissed and forced the lightning back, you can even see Sideous starting to lean back from the power, and then it exploded. Yoda, being smaller, lighter, and mroe on the edge, simpyl fell off while Sideous got lucky and managed to grab on to a handhold. At that point it was over.

You are a fool. Yoda, without a lightsaber, can't fight Sideous AND an ARMY of Clone Troopers at the same time. No one can, except for Luke "I make planets invisible with the force" Skywalker.

As my brother says about this kind of thing- saying someone 'should' have won is a bit like saying that the Texans 'should' have won at the Alamo, Doesn't change the fact they lost, which kinda wraps up the thread regardless of any other consideration.

Originally posted by Ushgarak
As my brother says about this kind of thing- saying someone 'should' have won is a bit like saying that the Texans 'should' have won at the Alamo, Doesn't change the fact they lost, which kinda wraps up the thread regardless of any other consideration.

Yoda won. If Sidious hadn't got lucky and held on, Old man woulda broke his back.

It "seemed" doesn't mean anything, really. You can see it plainly from he battle. They were in the force battle and at first Sideous seemed to win, then Yoda got pissed and forced the lightning back, you can even see Sideous starting to lean back from the power, and then it exploded. Yoda, being smaller, lighter, and mroe on the edge, simpyl fell off while Sideous got lucky and managed to grab on to a handhold. At that point it was over.

Yoda was below Sidious the entire fight, if he was winning then him falling to the floor would mean nothing. Sidious was winning and did win the fight in the end.

You are a fool. Yoda, without a lightsaber, can't fight Sideous AND an ARMY of Clone Troopers at the same time. No one can, except for Luke "I make planets invisible with the force" Skywalker.

Yoda throws around armies of the CIS like nothing, and was the most powerful Jedi in history. If he was doing so well against Sids like you think, it wouldn't be very difficult for him to just force throw them to their deaths.

you really are clueless as to a Jedi and the limitations of their powers.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
live to fight another day, man. he didnt lose, he just chose to fight another day.

There never was another day. So he fled, he ran, with his tail between his legs. And he admitted it himself: "Failed have I", ergo, he lost.