Hercules vs Wendigo

Started by olympian8 pages
Originally posted by jinzin
So what? He wasn't crackin jokes when Wolverine whipped out the claws

Oh, he did cracked more jokes. Didnt you saw him laugthing? You probably could see it if you looked at the whole pages instead just the two panels where he does *something*.

Originally posted by jinzin
And once again, Hercules on two seperate occasions has needed a foreign object to negotiate Wolverine's claws and keep from getting turned into meat cubes.

"You cant use foregein weapons"

(but he used the table to make the other man trip)

"that doesnt count, arsehole".

Of course, of course.

Originally posted by jinzin
He needed Captain America's shield.... Give him an indesctructible shield and the odds obviously change.

Dont have Logan sneak on him or bring backup. How about it?

Not that it actually helped him,in the end.

Originally posted by jinzin
For one, Wendigo never fought Hulk and Wolverine at the same time "doing good", as soon as both characters joined up, Wendigo was in a one sided curbstomp.

He was certainly doing better than the time the other mudball lost against Wolverine alone, wouldnt you think?

This isent rocket science, kid. I mean, damn.

Originally posted by jinzin
Second, the Wendigo in question WAS having trouble with Wolverine alone. He was staggering back, weakening, not landing blows, he was losing. So your logic here is flawed as well as your recollection of the events that tooks place.

I find it weird that you say he "was losing" when after the three panels where Wolverine spends the time cutting him, he was still figthing the Hulk.

Originally posted by jinzin
Evidenced by what?
Prove it.

Use your brains and compare both showings. How hard is it?

Originally posted by jinzin
See? You want to equate me to a child, yet you can't even follow simple trains of thought. I'm not refering to the Mauvais/Wendigo-Hybrid. I didn't bring the hybrid up, and have in fact clarified that I wasn't reffering to the hybrid... So why do you bring him up? To ignore the fact that Wolverine WAS outclassing a Wendigo who was a threat to a Doc Strange level villain.

I brougth the hybrid to the obvious comparations about the different Wendigo. That every Wendigo is different. Because of the host. Its not a depowerment issue. Wich is what you keep bringing up:

"oh, your talking about him being depowered!!"

No, im not. You dont know a background of a character, dont discuss it.

Originally posted by jinzin
Based on what proof aside from losing to Wolverine?

He in two different ocassions to Wolverine and Snowbird alone. The others didnt. Tell, do you regard the same Wendigo who got killed by Saber with the same level as the ones who always fougth Hulk together with someone else?

I keep telling this isent rocket science, and you dont really need a university degree to understand it. But you are made of fail.

Originally posted by jinzin
Do I REALLY need to start bringing every example of Wolverine taking out top tier level menaces? The man put down Kierrok by himself in 4 panels in his 9th appearance. Kierrok owned the whole X-Men and 2 shotted Colossus.

Colossus isent top tier. And unless those two teams had the likes of Phoenix or Juggernaut and have them being beaten head on, that doesnt make Wolverine a top tier teamwrecker, either.

Originally posted by jinzin
Wolverine one shotted Arkon.

Arkon isent a physical top tier. Just like Logan what makes him dangerous is the weapons he sports.

Nullify that, and he goes down the way he consistantly has.

Originally posted by jinzin
And, again, Hulk himself has had trouble with Wolverine.. Your logic is flawed.

Having troubles with someone doesnt translate into beating them. Wich is what you sport. You cleary think he can take a majority over Hercules, despite being humiliated twice against one off panel showing. I think you would think the same about Wolverine and Hulk, wouldnt you?

Despite the fact he never did to Green Hulk what he only accomplished with Gray. And the guy still got up.

Originally posted by jinzin
Wendigo is always portrayed as a brick level character and nothing less, including the monkey sized one in Fanfare. Even his handbook entries give him brick level strength with no mention of a clearly changing consistency. Wendigo from Uncanny was portrayed as a brick level as well.

"Brick" is a defination that only refers to someone who mainly relies in strength. Handbook piece? Its for my toilet.

His visual appearance? Why do you bring that up when its obvious that i am talking about the differences in power showings?

Originally posted by jinzin
You think they weren't treating Wendigo like he was a class 100?

Whatever initial intention they may had, i think the actual resume speaks for himself. He may scare away people like a huge threat such as Hulk, but when it comes down to it, what he did simply isent top tier material.

This isent a unique example in comic books. "Look, Apocalypse is going to return migthier than ever"

"Oh, he lost to Colossus. Oh well, maybe he wasent that migthy this time".

Originally posted by jinzin
Funny how even though you think that's the "best he can do" being off panel that he's taken down Namor on panel or held his own every time they've fought. But like I said before.. whatever it takes to help you rationalize your favorite character losing. 😉

I keep saying im ok with it, you keep bring up i need to rationalize something. Someone is projecting insecurity, here.

Clameront cleary gave a big deal of though about it. The off panel win is an amazing description on how someone like *bone claw* Wolverine can take down Hercules. And what we saw was..what? Its like the writer had no clue at all. On a mini that had the most popular characters go ahead, despite the power difference, like Natasha against WonderMan. What is there to rationalize? Context speaks for itself.

Say, since you take off panels contests in great estimation, i bet you take the ones involving Wolverine as a big deal, dont you?

Originally posted by olympian
Oh, he did cracked more jokes. Didnt you saw him laugthing? You probably could see it if you looked at the whole pages instead just the two panels where he does *something*.

I'm sure that was an attempted insult at my intelligence, but those don't work when they don't make sense. 😉

Herc was cracking jokes until Wolverine unleashed his claws. Then? "Zounds!" Sure herc started laughin it up when Logan got his claws stuck in the table.. You know which one, the one that Herc was using to hide behind. But after he got floored he was done crackin jokes again wasn't he?

Originally posted by olympian
"You cant use foregein weapons"
(but he used the table to make the other man trip)
"that doesnt count, arsehole".
Of course, of course.

Horrid misrepresentation of the points being made here. You thought all that happened in both other encounters was Wolverine getting "tossed around" which is clearly another misrepresentation, when on one of those occasions he got floored and on BOTH of those occasions he was scared of Wolverine's claws.

The important point? He's afraid of those claws for a reason, when he doesn't have a table or Cap's shield to hide behind what would happen? Given the two pages we see of the Hulk/Wolverine fight in CoC2 the answer is quite obvious.

Wolverine flooring Herc was only used to point out that those events were not just Wolverine getting tossed around as you had stated.

Originally posted by olympian
Dont have Logan sneak on him or bring backup. How about it?

In a h2h... How about it indeed, since we've seen the result of that kind of fight. Herc on the floor unconscious.

Originally posted by olympian
He was certainly doing better than the time the other mudball lost against Wolverine alone, wouldnt you think?

Uh no. He was losing against Wolverine without landing one blow or sticking one defensive maneuver. And Wolverine was perfectly calm. The Wendigo that got downed in uncanny lost to a berserker Wolverine. The same kind of Wolverine who's had Hulk on the ropes.

Originally posted by olympian
This isent rocket science, kid. I mean, damn.

Clearly; issues concerning gravity, retrofires, geosynchronous orbits, satellite periods, AU, perigees, and apogees aren't a part of this particular discussion concerning your inability to accept that Logan downs Hulk level Wendigo's and Herc level threats... yeah I'm IN a rocket science class btw... 😐

Nice failed attempt at belittling my intelligence though.. AGAIN...

Now if we're to look at you're level of intelligence you think/stated that THIS was Wendigo "doing good" here:
http://i125.photobucket.com/albums/p68/DCHawks_photo/TheIncredibleHulkv2-181-05.jpg
Yup. He's doin a hell of a job ain't he? 🙄

Originally posted by olympian
I find it weird that you say he "was losing" when after the three panels where Wolverine spends the time cutting him, he was still figthing the Hulk.

You WOULD find it weird since your Herc blinders prohibit you from initiating any sort of rational logic in this argument. I find it weird that you think Wendigo who was staggering back, weakening and unable to land a hit or put up a defense against Logan was doing "better" than one who also lost.. Especially considering that Wendigo at least was able to almost KO him in 3 hits...

Originally posted by olympian
Use your brains and compare both showings. How hard is it?

Nice... So if someone argues that a creature who is always represented as a brick WAS in fact a brick that's not using brains... I love your boundless irrationalities.

Like you using your "brains" to dictate that Nightcrawler and Vindi weren't treating Wendi as a brick threat.. lol. How else should they have responded?

How about when you used your "brains" to determine Vindicator wasn't around in that instance.. lmao... what a joke.

As for what I asked?
Proof?
Nope?
Okay, no proof then...

Originally posted by olympian
I brougth the hybrid to the obvious comparations about the different Wendigo.

Exactly, you brought up the hybrid Wendigo as a red herring to Wolverine serving another Wendigo who was a threat to a Strange level villain...
Nice defection.

Originally posted by olympian
That every Wendigo is different. Because of the host. Its not a depowerment issue. Wich is what you keep bringing up:
"oh, your talking about him being depowered!!"
No, im not. You dont know a background of a character, dont discuss it.

It IS a depowerment issue when every Wendigo is portrayed as a brick, When wendigo is stated to be at brick level strength in every handbook entry and card bio he has where strength is stated. For those first two factors to be true, and then to have you sit there and insist that the Wendigo Wolverine fought was of a lower level IS an argument to the depowerment of the character.

Lol I don't know the history of the character based on what proof? The fact that I don't agree with you that Uncanny Wendigo wasn't a Hulk level brick? Wow...

Mauvais was a more powerful Wendigo because he already started out a Strange level foe. That's a MASSIVE difference in power. But.. you think that one man who engages in semi-regular exercise is going to serve as a better host for the curse than ANOTHER man who engages in semi-regular exercise? 😕 There was no clear difference between the hosts, and none between the Wendigo's...

Originally posted by olympian
He in two different ocassions to Wolverine and Snowbird alone. The others didnt.
Wrong. The one your very premise is built on was losing and DID lose to Wolverine. You keep insisting that Wolverine could not have done it without Hulk's assistance, but that's purely your speculation. And it's speculation that doesn't even fit the panels or suggestion of what was taking place.. Wolverine landing hits, Wendigo staggering back, unable to defend himself, and weakening....

You can't honestly say that two Hulk punches served more damage than he managed to make in two entire fights previously to Wolverine taking Wendigo down.
Hulk even states to his own amazement that Wolverine could do what he failed to do.

Originally posted by olympian
Tell, do you regard the same Wendigo who got killed by Saber with the same level as the ones who always fougth Hulk together with someone else?

Yes. That Wendigo shrugged off Sasquatches attack, and brought Sas down faster than Sasquatch could even defend himself. It stands to reason he was within the same scope of power...

Again, every Wendigo is in the same level of brickhood given their hosts are similar... Wendigo just doesn't fair well with Lupins.
This has been evidenced 4 times already.

Originally posted by olympian
I keep telling this isent rocket science, and you dont really need a university degree to understand it. But you are made of fail.

When you're capable of spelling "isn't" correctly perhaps you can attempt to attack my intelligence without looking like a dipshit.
So far the only one failing here is yourself.. I've asked you to bring proof to the table at least 3 times now and thus far you've done nothing but support your speculation with more speculation.

You've defaulted to:
ad hominem
ad ignorantiam
ad nauseam
Circulus in demonstrando
and the fallacy of the complex question

You're doing enough "failing" for the both of us.

Originally posted by olympian
Colossus isent top tier. And unless those two teams had the likes of Phoenix or Juggernaut and have them being beaten head on, that doesnt make Wolverine a top tier teamwrecker, either.

😂 You have no idea who the 'Ngarai are do you?
ONE 'Ngarai drone was able to give Hulk all hell... ONE DRONE... Kierrok was the lord of the 'Ngarai, and Wolverine's beaten him after killing hundreds of those same drones.

And at the time Colossus was top tier enough to be standing toe to toe with Juggernaught, and Gladiator so I don't know what the hell you're talking about.

Originally posted by olympian
Arkon isent a physical top tier. Just like Logan what makes him dangerous is the weapons he sports.

Tell that to Thor, WonderMan, and Colossus.

Originally posted by olympian
Having troubles with someone doesnt translate into beating them. Wich is what you sport.

And yet Wolverine has beaten him too. Thing is, you want to pretend that just because Wendigo went up against Hulk in host A and didn't in host B that A was clearly a far more powerful version in spite of the fact that both had the same type of showing against Wolverine.

Again, all you think that happened was Wolverine getting humiliated.. it's a misinterpretation or a misrepresentation of what happened in their first encounter for sure, Herc was on his ass. He needed the shield to protect himself from being skewered. You think that Herc with Cap's shield is going to manage the same result as he would without, ignoring WHY he needs a shield in the first place.

And no. Unlike Hulk, Hercules doesn't sport a liquid metal like healing factor, or get multitudes stronger and more durable as a fight progresses.

Originally posted by olympian
Despite the fact he never did to Green Hulk what he only accomplished with Gray. And the guy still got up.

Ahem... He's beaten almost killed Savage Hulk... 😐
He has at least several other wins over a green version of Hulk as well. And yes Hulk got up.. because he has a liquid metal healing factor... herc doesn't...

Originally posted by olympian
"Brick" is a defination that only refers to someone who mainly relies in strength. Handbook piece? Its for my toilet.
His visual appearance? Why do you bring that up when its obvious that i am talking about the differences in power showings?
Well I can't help you if you're going to clearly give your own arguments the benefit of the doubt in spite of being against ALL forms of evidence. 😬
I bring it up to further the point that Wendigo is ALWAYS portrayed as a brick. He's never had an incarnation that wasn't. Which is what your argument beckons one to believe.

Originally posted by olympian
Whatever initial intention they may had, i think the actual resume speaks for himself. He may scare away people like a huge threat such as Hulk, but when it comes down to it, what he did simply isent top tier material.

And all that resume says is that Wendigo< Wolverine, or Snowbird as a Wolverine.
That doesn't = Wendigo<<<Hulk. Wendigo clearly does better against brute force, and concussive force than he does against evisceration.

What he did was almost KO logan in two or three hits... Something that characters like Wonderman, Hulk himself, and Moses Magnum were failing to do at the time.

Originally posted by olympian
This isent a unique example in comic books. "Look, Apocalypse is going to return migthier than ever"
"Oh, he lost to Colossus. Oh well, maybe he wasent that migthy this time".

Given that this has nothing to do with our discussion you'll have to excuse me if I ignore it.

Originally posted by olympian
I keep saying im ok with it, you keep bring up i need to rationalize something. Someone is projecting insecurity, here.

"off panel"
"that's the best he can do"... Yeah that sounds "okay with it".

Originally posted by olympian
Clameront Clearly gave a big deal of though about it. The off panel win is an amazing description on how someone like *bone claw* Wolverine can take down Hercules. And what we saw was..what? Its like the writer had no clue at all. On a mini that had the most popular characters go ahead, despite the power difference, like Natasha against WonderMan. What is there to rationalize? Context speaks for itself.

Exactly. So Wolverine>Herc without anything to shield himself with, cause that's the context we got.

Originally posted by olympian
Say, since you take off panels contests in great estimation, i bet you take the ones involving Wolverine as a big deal, dont you?
This sentence doesn't even begin to make sense. C'mon formulating a coherent thought in the English language "isn't rocket science kid"...

Which by the way is ridiculous, assuming that I AM younger than you for you to keep tossing that bit into the debate as if age somehow , makes a difference where it concerns the validation of comic book proof... Something you continuously fail to provide.

Originally posted by jinzin
Given that this has nothing to do with our discussion you'll have to excuse me if I ignore it.

Please, do so. Its what you have been doing all along.

Could it be more appearant that the reason you champion that single showing as something grand and amazing (wich certainly wasent in comparation with some of the others) as nothing but an attempt to make Wolverine pass out as something akin to a "top tier"?

I guess Snowbird is as well. But i disgress:

One particular Wendigo showing goes down to either Snow and Logan alone, while other particular showings (that we are discussing as well) wer only taken care off by teamwork. Is it a math problem?

In reality, it cant be anything else, when you sport an opinion that Logan would take the majority against a credible physical top tier like Hercules or even perhaps take ties with Hulk, something he also never did.

Originally posted by jinzin
This sentence doesn't even begin to make sense. C'mon formulating a coherent thought in the English language "isn't rocket science kid"...

Given your powerful inability to grasp a simple comparation issue, to pompously ignore what is obvious, there is no way i can adress you, other than this way.

Worse than this, is only if i end up having to draw it for you.

Originally posted by jinzin
Exactly. So Wolverine>Herc without anything to shield himself with, cause that's the context we got.

Are you forgetting the backup he had and the fact he needed a sneak?

Take that all out, and we have a whole different setting. Considering how Logan got the adamantium claws, you shouldnt cry if someone rends them useless. Its fair game. Especially when he isent figthing alone.

Originally posted by jinzin
"off panel""that's the best he can do"... Yeah that sounds "okay with it".

But it is. He did in an off panel act something he never came close to acomplish otherwise. Im perfectably okay with the particular writer`s view on it. Or should i say, the lack thereof?

Originally posted by olympian
Please, do so. Its what you have been doing all along.

That's just what i do with irrelivant nonsense.

Originally posted by olympian
Could it be more appearant that the reason you champion that single showing as something grand and amazing (wich certainly wasent in comparation with some of the others) as nothing but an attempt to make Wolverine pass out as something akin to a "top tier"?

Nope. Wolverine is what he is. I use feats as a measurment of that, and I never try to deny his low showings or exaggurate his higher ones. I simply state what he's done and leave the estimation of his "status" up to those who choose to read my posts, listen to my rationale, and uphold facts as evidence.. You clearly have an aversion to that last part.

Originally posted by olympian
I guess Snowbird is as well. But i disgress:

Ignoring that Batman has a lump of Kryptonite in his hand when he beats Superman doesn't make him a top tier but I digress.

Originally posted by olympian
One particular Wendigo showing goes down to either Snow and Logan alone, while other particular showings (that we are discussing as well) wer only taken care off by teamwork. Is it a math problem?

No it's a comprehension problem on your behalf. The Wendigo's in other showings faired no better. You keep ignoring that fact.

Originally posted by olympian
In reality, it cant be anything else, when you sport an opinion that Logan would take the majority against a credible physical top tier like Hercules or even perhaps take ties with Hulk, something he also never did.

Nothing else than what? And what reality are you talking about? I'm talking about 616 😉...
There's no credible reason why Herc should take a majority over Logan who is his 1on1 h2h superior. Logan has several advantages over Logan while Herc only has strength as an advantage over Logan... and heaven forbid! It's not like Wolverine's ever had to face down super strength before. Or like he's been doing so since day one.

Hulk's a different matter and I've alreay stated multiple times that Hulk would take a majority over Wolverine... So forgive me if I just set aflame that particular strawman.

Originally posted by olympian
Given your powerful inability to grasp a simple comparation issue, to pompously ignore what is obvious, there is no way i can adress you, other than this way.

How can you compare those two feats? There's only ONE point of comparison, Wolverine. Wendigo didn't do well against Wolveirne in either case.

Originally posted by olympian
Worse than this, is only if i end up having to draw it for you.
You insisting speculation is a fact with more speculation is a logical fallacy.. Not proof.

Originally posted by olympian
Are you forgetting the backup he had and the fact he needed a sneak?

I'm talking about CoC2

In that reference are you forgetting the fact that he had Cap's shield? or just ignoring it like everything else?

Originally posted by olympian
Take that all out, and we have a whole different setting. Considering how Logan got the adamantium claws, you shouldnt cry if someone rends them useless. Its fair game. Especially when he isent figthing alone.
No one was really fighting Herc... 🤨
Wolverine went for one attack and he blocked it with a foreign object he wouldn't have in a forum fight, that he DIDN'T have in CoC2... I'm not crying or whinning like you imagine. I'm simply calling out these facts since you think Herc with Cap's shield is = Herc without Cap's shield... which is ludicrous.

Originally posted by olympian
But it is. He did in an off panel act something he never came close to acomplish otherwise. Im perfectably okay with the particular writer`s view on it. Or should i say, the lack thereof?
Wasn't entirely off panel.
He has come close to accomplishing it otherwise.. he's beaten people on hercs level, above hercs level and had herc on his ass and scared of his claws two times.

You clearly misrepresent arguments, feats, and interpretations so you can ignore what you don't like... Whatever.

and why is losing to Snowbird a bad thing again?

Originally posted by -K-M-
and why is losing to Snowbird a bad thing again?

Yeah, I'm still trying to figure that one out Munge.

I'm calling you munge cause I like it better. 🙂

I've heard worse 😛
----
Sidenote for those who are interested. I recently redid the Wendigo respect thread and made it more organized

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f98/t481568.html

Originally posted by -K-M-
I've heard worse 😛
----
Sidenote for those who are interested. I recently redid the Wendigo respect thread and made it more organized

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f98/t481568.html

either that or the mungester!

Originally posted by jinzin
either that or the mungester!

I hate you 😐

😂

Originally posted by jinzin
[B]Nope. Wolverine is what he is. I use feats as a measurment of that, and I never try to deny his low showings or exaggurate his higher ones. I simply state what he's done and leave the estimation of his "status" up to those who choose to read my posts, listen to my rationale, and uphold facts as evidenceB]

And im using what it is. Him being bitchslapped and only doing one good thing. If you used brains you would see that the whole table thing is even a bad showing for either character.

One, for Hercules, since Logan in that same story already showed that his strength alone couldnt even budge the guy (and thus a table toss shouldnt do anything) and Two because Logan`s claws shouldnt had been stuck in a wooden table of all places, and cut it like butter. But it didnt.

Originally posted by jinzin
[B]Ignoring that Batman has a lump of Kryptonite in his hand when he beats Superman doesn't make him a top tier but I digress.B]

Are you saying that Logan is the clear underdog?

If Hercules doenst have any adamantium, can you tell us, why making the claws useless is a tactic he shouldnt use at all?

Originally posted by jinzin
[B]No it's a comprehension problem on your behalf. The Wendigo's in other showings faired no better. You keep ignoring that fact. B]

Ah i see. Its IS a reading comprehention problem. You dont know how to compare showings. Why didnt you said so?

Originally posted by jinzin
[B]Logan has several advantages over Logan while Herc only has strength as an advantage over Logan... and heaven forbid! It's not like Wolverine's ever had to face down super strength before. Or like he's been doing so since day one.B]

Can you explain us how a bone claw Wolverine took out immortal Hercules? Can you ran down the whole thing to us? If you cant and just accept it as something it just happened, its cool with me. But dont try to act like it wasent sheer popularity that drove out the result, especially in the circunstances both charaters wer presented at the time. And it wasent an unique case in those series.

I could certaily think that a standart Logan would have the shot, albeigh not the majority of the times like you seem to champion, but bone claw? Off panel?

If Hercules got a win over Hulk on an off panel without showcasing any action whatsoever on how he acomplished that, not one person would take it seriously. Well, except you, so in case it does happen in the future i can count surely on your support.

Originally posted by jinzin
[B]How can you compare those two feats? There's only ONE point of comparison, Wolverine. Wendigo didn't do well against Wolveirne in either caseB]

Some Wendigo wer only and always beaten by teamwork, Logan included. Another wasent. Stop being stubburn.

Originally posted by jinzin
[B]In that reference are you forgetting the fact that he had Cap's shield? or just ignoring it like everything else?B]

No. Are you forgetting Logan had backup and attacked before there was even a figth?

Originally posted by jinzin
[B]No one was really fighting Herc... 🤨B]

Wich is pure balloney. Logan attacked Hercules before he ran down on them. Then Iron Man posed a threath on him that they would take him down. But surely, it wasent for figthing porpuses *winks*

Originally posted by jinzin
[B]Wolverine went for one attack and he blocked it with a foreign object he wouldn't have in a forum fight, that he DIDN'T have in CoC2... I'm not crying or whinning like you imagine. I'm simply calling out these facts since you think Herc with Cap's shield is = Herc without Cap's shield... which is ludicrous.B]

You know what else he didnt had in COC2? Adamantium.

Originally posted by jinzin
[B]Wasn't entirely off panel.B]

We saw two panels alone. One of the beginning of the figth and one in the end. And nothing in the middle.

So, what exactly was On panel other than, you know NOT how the figth went?

In the end, all he accomplished so far was make someone stronger than him trip over, in a way that said person shouldnt, and using something he shouldnt be stuck with in the first place. Logan having a clear advantage hand to hand nowadays is something i find even arguable at best. And its not like with all his migthy durability he hasent been knocked out with strength alone.

He sure can cut someone like Hercules. But can he beat someone like that with such cut alone?

But hey, more power to you. Its not like you are going to learn to compare different showings or change your tune.

Originally posted by -K-M-
and why is losing to Snowbird a bad thing again?

It isent, but it sure as hell isent as impressive to be taken down on its lonesome by Snowbird when she is sporting an animal form, compared with being taken down by a teamwork of heavier hitters.

That much should be obvious to you, given how you are usually a capable poster.

Originally posted by olympian
And im using what it is. Him being bitchslapped and only doing one good thing. If you used brains you would see that the whole table thing is even a bad showing for either character.

I don't know at which point you think that I defended that it wasn't. 😕 Another nice strawman though, You're getting good at making those, I know a farmer who could use your help to make scarecrows..
"only doing one good thing" huh? More like three... Scaring Hercules, forcing him into shielding himself, and florring Hercules on his ass... It isn't the "humiliation" you keep insisting that it was.

Originally posted by olympian
One, for Hercules, since Logan in that same story already showed that his strength alone couldnt even budge the guy (and thus a table toss shouldnt do anything) and Two because Logan`s claws shouldnt had been stuck in a wooden table of all places, and cut it like butter. But it didnt.

Yeah I didn't defend that it was good writing for either character so this red herring like your others is useless to the discussion at hand.

Originally posted by olympian
Are you saying that Logan is the clear underdog?
Once again unable to follow trains of thought. No, what I'm saying is that instead of Wendigo being a weaker version when Wolverine beats him, that he's simply more vulnerable to the types of damage that Wolverine dishes out, and much more vulnerable to it when it's dished out by Lupins.

What you're doing here, arguing that the versions of Wendigo that Wolverine and Sabretooth beat is akin to looking at a fight between Bats with Kryptonite and Supes, watching Supes get owned, and concluding that it was a weaker version of Superman instead of realizing that it was the Kryptonite that put him down.

Originally posted by olympian
If Hercules doenst have any adamantium, can you tell us, why making the claws useless is a tactic he shouldnt use at all?

I'm going to assume you're back onto the shield bit.
I never said Hercules "shouldn't use a shield"... if he can, he very much should for the sake of his life use a shield. What I'm alluding to is that in any typical 1on1 or forum fight he wouldn't have one. Thus, you coming to the conclusion that Wolverine "shouldn't beat Herc" based on two occassions where he had for all intents and purposes a plot device, is a skewed perception on the matter.

Originally posted by olympian
Ah i see. Its IS a reading comprehention problem. You dont know how to compare showings. Why didnt you said so?

😂
Originally posted by jinzin
No it's a comprehension problem on your behalf.

Look, I know you were trying to use my own quote against me because at this point all you have are petty insults to throw about when you've run out of wild speculation, but once again, if you're going to try to insult my intelligence the least you could do is keep from looking like an ass when you do so. You've basically just inadvertantly admitted to having a reading comprehension problem...

Originally posted by olympian
Can you explain us how a bone claw Wolverine took out immortal Hercules? Can you ran down the whole thing to us? If you cant and just accept it as something it just happened, its cool with me. But dont try to act like it wasent sheer popularity that drove out the result, especially in the circunstances both charaters wer presented at the time. And it wasent an unique case in those series.

By slashing, stabbing and otherwise beating the shit out of him?
Wolverine bone claws were capible of cutting up bricks like Hulk, Wendigo, Psychoman, Prime Sentinals, a Skrull Thing, and Warbird. It's no big deal to add Herc to that list too.

Originally posted by olympian
I could certaily think that a standart Logan would have the shot, albeigh not the majority of the times like you seem to champion, but bone claw? Off panel?

Yup.. considering his showings against the previously described bricks on panel...

Originally posted by olympian
If Hercules got a win over Hulk on an off panel without showcasing any action whatsoever on how he acomplished that, not one person would take it seriously. Well, except you, so in case it does happen in the future i can count surely on your support.

Well if it doesn't show ANY action? Yeah that'd might as well be hyperbole. If it gives two panels like WHAT HAPPENED in the fight we're discussing, One with Herc punching Hulk, and another with Hulk KOed. it'd very much be admissible as evidence.

Originally posted by olympian
Some Wendigo wer only and always beaten by teamwork, Logan included. Another wasent. Stop being stubburn.

Me not submitting to your SPEC-U-LATION is not stubborn it's being objective. You keep insisting that the Wendigo in Hulk181 was beaten with teamwork and that that's the only way he could have been beaten, but he was losing his fight with Wolverine before teamwork ever became a factor so teamwork in that instance is irrelivent.

Originally posted by olympian
No. Are you forgetting Logan had backup and attacked before there was even a figth?

Are you forgetting that he had Cap's shield? lol.

Originally posted by olympian
Wich is pure balloney. Logan attacked Hercules before he ran down on them. Then Iron Man posed a threath on him that they would take him down. But surely, it wasent for figthing porpuses *winks*
The only one who attacked Herc was Wolverine no one else made a move..

Originally posted by olympian
You know what else he didnt had in COC2? Adamantium.
Lol, aside from the fact that my post you responded to here was reffering to Hercules and your lack of specification leads one to believe that you're ALSO referring to Hercules, I know you mean Wolverine... This though, only goes to show how you can't follow trains of thought and DO have comprehension problems... Just a tip for the future.. Specifiy.

Anyways... So what? Wolverine with bone claws could still take brick punches and deliver bricks damage. His senses were heightened even further, he was faster, stronger, and his HF was unhindered...

Originally posted by olympian
We saw two panels alone. One of the beginning of the figth and one in the end. And nothing in the middle.
Well at least you're acknowledging that there were in fact two panels now lol.

Originally posted by olympian
So, what exactly was On panel other than, you know NOT how the figth went?
And that invalidates it? We saw a little of how the fight went, both characters facing eachother with Logan landing a blow and Hercules reeling back from said blow.

Originally posted by olympian
In the end, all he accomplished so far was make someone stronger than him trip over, in a way that said person shouldnt, and using something he shouldnt be stuck with in the first place.

You say this as if Hercules would have faired just as well had he taken the claw shot. 😐

Originally posted by olympian
Logan having a clear advantage hand to hand nowadays is something i find even arguable at best. And its not like with all his migthy durability he hasent been knocked out with strength alone.

Wolverine has every advantage except strength. That's all Hercules brings to the table between the two. Wolverine has been KOed by strength sure, but not a majority of the time, and even less without compounding circumstances.

Originally posted by olympian
He sure can cut someone like Hercules. But can he beat someone like that with such cut alone?

Considering he has to Herc and to Namor.
Consdering he's done it to bigger characters with healing factors like Abomination, Hulk, and Wendigo.

Yeah cutting, stabbing, and chopping'll do just fine.

Originally posted by olympian
But hey, more power to you. Its not like you are going to learn to compare different showings or change your tune.
And it's not like your going to learn to bring proof to back your wild claims up... but whatever.

Originally posted by olympian
It isent, but it sure as hell isent as impressive to be taken down on its lonesome by Snowbird when she is sporting an animal form, compared with being taken down by a teamwork of heavier hitters.

That much should be obvious to you, given how you are usually a capable poster.

*Shrugs* She is powered by the same mystical energies as the Wendigo, for all we know that could have played a factor. She also can become Wendigo, but that's neither here nor there

comes down to h2h skills for me. wendigo has none. herc could defend himself. his durability is also pretty retarded though often underrated, as are his h2h skills. his claws are not unbreakable and while they would/could damage herc, the damage would not be as extensive as the damage wolvie could do even though wendy is so much stronger.

wolvie is more of a threat to herc than wendigo is. still say immortal herc takes him almost every time.

Originally posted by leonidas
comes down to h2h skills for me. wendigo has none. herc could defend himself. his durability is also pretty retarded though often underrated, as are his h2h skills. his claws are not unbreakable and while they would/could damage herc, the damage would not be as extensive as the damage wolvie could do even though wendy is so much stronger.

wolvie is more of a threat to herc than wendigo is. still say immortal herc takes him almost every time.

.......ummm...lulz? 😕

Originally posted by -K-M-
.......ummm...lulz? 😕

nah. 🙂

though i'll concede it may depend on the host. the 'typical' wendigo loses almost everytime imo.

Originally posted by leonidas
nah. 🙂

though i'll concede it may depend on the host. the 'typical' wendigo loses almost everytime imo.

Uh huh...

Lets ignore the fact Hulk has always needed aid from someone else to help put Wendigo down, but following your logic Hercules should beat Hulk every time.

Not sure if your overestimating Hercules, or underestimating Wendigo

if hulk didn't get stronger i'd say he'd beat him every time, yes. could be you're underestimating herc.