Sabretooth vs Carnage, who wins?

Started by SamZED31 pages

Originally posted by jinzin
Don't remember the Kraven incident so I can't comment, when Brock got poisioned by stingers they hardly went in very deep and he still got dropped to his knees as I recall. Wolverine only stabbed him through the gut, and again put venom on his ass.

His clone doesn't count for reasons previously mentioned. And lets face it, the short, chubby lady inside venom at the time was never in danger because none of her limbs/etc were ever long enough to be hit by any one of Wolverine's attacks to the head or when he severed it's arm..

Pretty sure we can't compare anti-venom to the real deal, but I also haven't seen that so I can't comment. Also i think you're chalking up artistic interpretation to somethin way too literal here.


The force of hit dropped him on his knees, but the stab itself didnt do anything to him, he puked the venom and asked for more, got up and kicked that guy's ass. Same with Kraven, except Kraven's spear went much deeper, almost through as far as I remember. Will post the scan as soon as I find it.

Um.. actually all Wolverine did was make Venom laugh, he didn't drop him. His attacks were pretty much useless, im talking abot the time they fought before teaming up, all Wolverine did was cut Venom's tongue and stab him in the face, to which Venom replied something like "that supposed to hurt?". Not even gonna mention the waterfall fight, the worst PIS Ive seen, Venom getting koed after falling from waterfall... and even in that poorly written book I dont recall Logan doing any damage with his claws.

And why does the clone thing not count? It does, the clone was a copy of Venom symbiote (a poor one that is, seeing how Venom beat and absorbed it later) but with an old lady as a host and still Wolverine couldnt do anything to put him down just like he couldnt with Venom, not even close. Not to mention Venom can increase his mass and get much bigger in which case just like you said with the old lady Wolverine or ST reaching the host wont be an issue at all, making their attacks even more useless.

What do you mean? Frank put a shotgun to Brock's head, pulled the trigger and we've seen blood and chunks of brain fly away. I think its called Amazing Spider-man: Anti-Venom 2 good read btw, check it out. And comparing anti-Venom to the real deal makes sense since it's a small part of the same symbiote that remained in Brock's blood but got effected by Negative's power.

.

The force of some weak ass robotic legs from a nobody put Venom on his knees? Oh really? Even though they failed to penetrate deep at all?....
Really?
Venom? The guy who almost without a working symbiote, braced an entire ferris wheel? uh-huh.

As I said, haven't seen the Kraven example so I can't comment.

And are you using the Venom/Wolverine 3 part as evidence? What the hell? Wolverine never even landed more than a glancing blow on Venom there, there was NO, nadda, zip, attacks that hit any vital areas, hell he never even attempted to land a penetrating attack in that story, and none of their fighting was a real there... They were purposefully pretending to fight so they could get closer to whatsherface in that arc.
So that does NOTHING to lend credence to your argument...

Their nightmare fight had Venom on his ass after getting gutchecked so not really sure what your talking about there.
so that also does not lend credit to your position....

And neither does using the Venom clone for that matter. Like seriously...... WTF? Just because Brock is a better/more experienced host and was able to beat up the clone with sheer power doesn't somehow conclude that they had the same abilities.
The clone spontaneously developed new attributes in Brock's absence. We already went over some of them.

With Wolverine again.... Had that been a regular symbiote overlapping a typical host the fight hold have been VERY different. Brock NEVER had the power to increase his mass until the end of the Venom: Run storyarc, before that it was dispurst over his body like a suit.

And we've seen MULTIPLES of times where Venom had to draw the suit from one part of his body to expand it or send it to another.
For instance the mace arch, Lethal Protector, Bride of Venom. There's tons of times the symbiote had to stretch itself thin to compensate for being overused. The ability to increase his mass only showed up after Venom and his clone merged, and please don't go back to cartoonish artists interpretations to try and prove differently....

In any case it doesn't matter... Carnage has also never displayed the ability to increase his mass, he's no where near the mass of Venom, and he DOES wear his symbiote like a suit over his body... so that's that.

As for anti-venom... Uhhhh.... 😐
That suit has all of his strengths, none of his weaknesses and powers ON TOP OF THAT... you can't honestly compare the two as though they're the same thing... and once again, haven't seen that book so I can't comment further than this.

I've yet to see one credible point to help support your argument here.

Originally posted by jinzin
In any case it doesn't matter... Carnage has also never displayed the ability to increase his mass, he's no where near the mass of Venom, and he DOES wear his symbiote like a suit over his body... so that's that.

Originally posted by Parmaniac

Originally posted by jinzin

That suit has all of his strengths, none of his weaknesses and powers ON TOP OF THAT... you can't honestly compare the two as though they're the same thing...
I agree on that

😕

I'm....ummmm.... Not quite sure what you think that means....

Carnage's symbiote runs through his body and blood stream... already covered that.

Symbiotes reform from sonic attacks once the attacks are finished... already went over that.

All I see here is a team that tried to rely on two weaknesses that carnage had already built immunities to as per his own admission, and failing.

Lol, as it stands to reason, the uber healing factor he should be sporting is nowhere to be seen with an open wound refusing to close on his face hehe.

^ Sorry then I got that wrong, I thought the part with "wears it like a suit" means that he's ONLY having it OVER his body. Nevermind.

oh lol, no not what I was driving at in that particular context.

Originally posted by jinzin
The force of some weak ass robotic legs from a nobody put Venom on his knees? Oh really? Even though they failed to penetrate deep at all?....
Really?
Venom? The guy who almost without a working symbiote, braced an entire ferris wheel? uh-huh.

As I said, haven't seen the Kraven example so I can't comment.

And are you using the Venom/Wolverine 3 part as evidence? What the hell? Wolverine never even landed more than a glancing blow on Venom there, there was NO, nadda, zip, attacks that hit any vital areas, hell he never even attempted to land a penetrating attack in that story, and none of their fighting was a real there... They were purposefully pretending to fight so they could get closer to whatsherface in that arc.
So that does NOTHING to lend credence to your argument...

Their nightmare fight had Venom on his ass after getting gutchecked so not really sure what your talking about there.
so that also does not lend credit to your position....

And neither does using the Venom clone for that matter. Like seriously...... WTF? Just because Brock is a better/more experienced host and was able to beat up the clone with sheer power doesn't somehow conclude that they had the same abilities.
The clone spontaneously developed new attributes in Brock's absence. We already went over some of them.

With Wolverine again.... Had that been a regular symbiote overlapping a typical host the fight hold have been VERY different. Brock NEVER had the power to increase his mass until the end of the Venom: Run storyarc, before that it was dispurst over his body like a suit.

And we've seen MULTIPLES of times where Venom had to draw the suit from one part of his body to expand it or send it to another.
For instance the mace arch, Lethal Protector, Bride of Venom. There's tons of times the symbiote had to stretch itself thin to compensate for being overused. The ability to increase his mass only showed up after Venom and his clone merged, and please don't go back to cartoonish artists interpretations to try and prove differently....

In any case it doesn't matter... Carnage has also never displayed the ability to increase his mass, he's no where near the mass of Venom, and he DOES wear his symbiote like a suit over his body... so that's that.

As for anti-venom... Uhhhh.... 😐
That suit has all of his strengths, none of his weaknesses and powers ON TOP OF THAT... you can't honestly compare the two as though they're the same thing... and once again, haven't seen that book so I can't comment further than this.

I've yet to see one credible point to help support your argument here.

"uh-huh" come on Jin, I already once told you I joined this forum 5 years ago after reading your comments in "Venom vs Carnage" thead, even have them saved somewhere on my pc. There's no need for the sarcasm, just say you dont agree and ill try to give better arguments.

Venom is strong but that doesnt mean he can't be knocked off balance, especially if attacked from behind, and I believe that's what happened since he showed no signs of injury and instantly got back up after mocking the guy.

Fair enough. In that book Wolverine only cut his face. Doesnt help my case here. I'll drop this one example.

The nightmare thing actually does. They weren't fighting, they were just standing there when Wolverine all of a sudden gutted Venom because he wanted to even the score, his claws went right through, yeah Venom fell from that attack but he didn't see it coming and falling doesn't = getting injured. Venom didn't make a sound, not even an "ouch". Wolverine gutted him, Venom fell, said something like "ok we're even, so no we can get along", instantly got up and swung away like nothing hapened. Wolverine could've as well just PUSHED him on his ass with the same result. It proves my point. And in the very same story Wolverine admitted that he can't possibly kill Venom and only MIGHT be able to hurt him. He knew what he was talking about.

It was a copy. What makes you think that he is better at taking Wolverine's stabs than the original Venom? They had matching size, strength, durability, hf etc. So it can be used as an argument as well. Also in that book the symbiote was drawn so huge it made no difference if the host is an old lady or Brock, they'd still be out of reach. And later Venom merged with that clone anyway.

Sometimes it was shown like a suit, sometimes they were shown like a merged being. Otherwise that She-Hulk incident I mentioned would've been impossible. But Venom was always shown to be able to get stabbed, gutted etc and not give a crap about it even before the run.
What cartoonish interpritation? I never did that. I was always talking about the comics. And Brock forcing to retract the symbiote was only his earlier appearances and when he had to use TOO much webbing leaving himself exposed. And not only after "run", there's a book (im pretty sure it's 616, can post scans) that showed the time when Parker still had the suit, the symbiote left him and battled Sandman (who's grown the size of a small building) The symbiote increased its own size as well and wtfstomped Sandman. That apperantly explains where his "nightmares" about Venom came from. So Venom could increase his mass making all the stabs useless. Not that they bothered him before.

Carnage never did that, true. But wasn't his blood shown to be symbiotic already? So I dont think cutting him would be that effective. i.e when Logan did it even though its been just a shoulder. Also, there's the whole mindcontrol thing. The symbiote has the ability to controle minds and even without leaving the host. Might work on ST if it worked even on Silver Surfer.

Well, other than the "curing" ability and lack of weeknesses Anti-Venom never displayed anything impressive to put him on the same lelvel as classic Venom. Let alone above him.

"I've yet to see one credible point to help support your argument here."
I believe I made several. For Venom-Brock merging together as well as that Venom or his clone (or both of them combined doesnt matter) cant be put down simply by getting cut, gutted, stabbed etc.

Originally posted by Parmaniac
I didn't know all those characters were German. 😕

Originally posted by Blanket
I didn't know all those characters were German. 😕
After re-reading the pages after years in german, for the first time I realized how aweful they were translated. But same goes for german dialogues in current US comics, the latest JLA issue comes to mind.

Two pages of block o' texts have gone by with many participants. It's obviously a lively discussion. But I'm not rereading it all.

Where are we right now on things?

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
Two pages of block o' texts have gone by with many participants. It's obviously a lively discussion. But I'm not rereading it all.

Where are we right now on things?

creed beats carnage because they're roughly equal in terms of strength, durabiltiy, and speed...but creed is far more skilled whereas cassidy is a nutcase with a few screws loose

Originally posted by Starscream M
creed beats carnage because they're roughly equal in terms of strength, durabiltiy, and speed...but creed is far more skilled whereas cassidy is a nutcase with a few screws loose
Lol Sabes has not demonstrated anywhere near the strength of Carnage, hell he hasn't shown strength feats like Spiderman, much less Venom or much less Carnage.

Speed, nope, Carnage is faster than Spiderman, where are these speed feats of Sabes.

Durability? Nope, Carnage's suit is vampiric. So Sabes healing advantage is negated. Plus Carnage is pretty much immune to his attacks and can attack him from the inside. Plus cloaking, distance attacks, and everything else he has too many advantages.

Originally posted by Tha C-Master
Lol Sabes has not demonstrated anywhere near the strength of Carnage, hell he hasn't shown strength feats like Spiderman, much less Venom or much less Carnage.

Speed, nope, Carnage is faster than Spiderman, where are these speed feats of Sabes.

Durability? Nope, Carnage's suit is vampiric. So Sabes healing advantage is negated. Plus Carnage is pretty much immune to his attacks and can attack him from the inside. Plus cloaking, distance attacks, and everything else he has too many advantages.

sabes has thrown a cop car up into a 2 story building. besides, carnage doesnt have any impressive strength feats either.

carnage isn't faster than spiderman, at least not enough to make a difference. his speed advantage over creed is negligible at best.

creed is actually more durable. his hf trumps the symbiote because he can rip carnage outta the symbiote or still hurt carnage, the symbiote doesn't heal the host.

Originally posted by Starscream M
sabes has thrown a cop car up into a 2 story building. besides, carnage doesnt have any impressive strength feats either.

carnage isn't faster than spiderman, at least not enough to make a difference. his speed advantage over creed is negligible at best.

creed is actually more durable. his hf trumps the symbiote because he can rip carnage outta the symbiote or still hurt carnage, the symbiote doesn't heal the host.

Spiderman has thrown a jeep up a building, and he has also lifted a tank and done some mega high feats, Carnage is vastly stronger than him, he isn't a strength reliant character though.

Carnage is faster.

Durability is different because Carnage's durability is more unconventional and exotic.

Originally posted by Tha C-Master

Durability is different because Carnage's durability is more unconventional and exotic.

that doesn't nec make it better

if you impale carnage...cassidys gonna be severely injured

if you impale creed, he can heal relatively quickly

both venom and carnage have shown simple srhedding causes the pain from small force of separation.

both carnage and venom have inflicted said pain by purposely doing that by clawing at one another and tearing pieces off.. their pain thresh hold is also far below sabretooth b/c of this and can be easily exploitable.

Originally posted by Starscream M
that doesn't nec make it better

if you impale carnage...cassidys gonna be severely injured

if you impale creed, he can heal relatively quickly

Good luck impaling Carnage. Creed's is better in some ways, but Carnage is in others since he is almost immune to certain types of attacks.

Carnage and Venom problem has always been cis. If carnage used his abilities to there true potential he should destroy sabre-tooth, but sadly it very unlikely that carnage would.

Originally posted by Battlehammer
Carnage and Venom problem has always been cis. If carnage used his abilities to there true potential he should destroy sabre-tooth, but sadly it very unlikely that carnage would.
cis is part of the character...unlike PIS.

carnage is a nut and oftentimes an idiot. creed is smarter and can find ways to beat carnage.