Silver Surfer (Exiles) vs Superman Prime

If we give this Surfer the same attributes as 616 Surfer, and use the rules of the forum, where his powers and skills are used at peak performance, Surfer should win.

That's just the way it is. Surfer has too many options open to him, and they are not based on will-power, or absorbing energy from a sun, or how mad he gets.

It is just RIGHT THERE, at his command. He can pretty much do ANYTHING with matter or energy.

So, if you are going to say he is at his BEST, how exactly is Prime going to beat him?

Because, if you say Prime is at his best, you have to do the same for Surfer. If this is the case, all Prime has to utilize is his strength and fighting skills. And, Surfer can negate the Strength part with energy manipulation.

So, how does Prime overcome that? I'm just asking.

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
Other posters have kept touting Superman Prime as having the strength of a PC Kyrptonian. That paragraph wasn't directed at you personally. I don't think his Earth-15 feat is questionable at all. Nobody here does except you. But there are others who don't question it, but question Exiles Surfer. Double standard.

That's other posters, but is it the majority? No. How isn't the feat qustionable? We have no idea the level of power Zod-Superman was at or Donna-Wonder Woman. It's the same thing here, we don't know what level they are at as their really no evidence to suggest otherwise. Do we know Gladiator was at/below/above the power of 616 Gladiator? No. Like I said some members, and most of those members have been banned lately.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Exactly. There is a double standard going on here. This isnt the first time a dc character gets a pass while the marvel character is questioned.

and vice versa, come on now it's not like Marvel is just the victim. To say otherwise is asinine. 😬

bump

Prime cuts Surfer in half with his board.

Exile Surfer went out like a chump, but he was mowing through people like they were nothing. The beating he gave Galactus causes me to give him a slight majority.