Superman vs Black Adam(punchfest)

Started by Bentley27 pages
Originally posted by quanchi112
It was a possession so it isn't a fair look either way of how the characters interact.

People tend to argue a big deal about the sacrifice arc when Diana fights Kal. I don't just shut their argument because there is a mind-whammy in place. We have to take them into consideration to some degree imo.

Originally posted by Bentley
People tend to argue a big deal about the sacrifice arc when Diana fights Kal. I don't just shut their argument because there is a mind-whammy in place. We have to take them into consideration to some degree imo.
I don't use that fight as an indicator of how a fight between the two of them would go. I use that fight to show how WW can tank all out attacks. Not really since their minds are altered IMO. They shouldn't be entirely discounted but possession and mind alterations aren't good indicators of how fights between them would normally go.

bump

Superman
If he cuts loose then we are using OWAW Superman.

Could go either way.

Originally posted by h1a8
Superman
If he cuts loose then we are using OWAW Superman.

minus the sun amp.

Originally posted by "Id"
minus the sun amp.

I assumed no sun amp. Just the version that was cutting through probes like fodder.

Teth still wins.

Originally posted by quanchi112
I don't use that fight as an indicator of how a fight between the two of them would go. I use that fight to show how WW can tank all out attacks. Not really since their minds are altered IMO. They shouldn't be entirely discounted but possession and mind alterations aren't good indicators of how fights between them would normally go.

What do you mean when you say she can tank all out attacks? At one point in space Superman hits her so hard he knocks her unconscious and it is only the heat from re-entry that wakes her up. At another point he seems to break her wrist merely by squeezing it with one hand.

She survives due to bad writing and birds. Yeah..she summons some birds at one point. I'm not sure if she has done that before or if she just busted it out for that special occasion.

Originally posted by h1a8
Superman always holds back. Even when he doesn't seem like it. It is due to his mental blocks (subconsciously doesn't want to take life).
For example, he was holding back nearly the whole time in his first fight with DD. It wasn't till the very end where Lois talked him in to not holding back. After I read that, I was blown away at the fact that Superman was actually fighting DD not holding back (his crazy as$). Because it certainly didn't seem like it to me.
Lol. Superman mental blocks are for weak people he may kill. Instead of reminding himself EVERY time he engages a weakling or someone he may accidentally kill he trained himself to subconsciously be careful. He had went all out plenty of times. There is Nothing going on in supermans head that prevents him from using his full strength and powers. Black Adam wins a close one.

Originally posted by JBL
Lol. Superman mental blocks are for weak people he may kill. Instead of reminding himself EVERY time he engages a weakling or someone he may accidentally kill he trained himself to subconsciously be careful. He had went all out plenty of times. There is Nothing going on in supermans head that prevents him from using his full strength and powers. Black Adam wins a close one.
It was retconned in OWAW that Superman had to train and meditate to release mental blocks. If Superman always was capable of it then there would be no need for training or meditation. And also, the fact that Superman was shredding probes like tissue is in support of this and far beyond anything BA has done. If Superman hits BA (or other heralds) with the same power he hit those probes with then BA and they are dead instantly.

Superman wins 👆

Originally posted by h1a8
It was retconned in OWAW that Superman had to train and meditate to release mental blocks. If Superman always was capable of it then there would be no need for training or meditation. And also, the fact that Superman was shredding probes like tissue is in support of this and far beyond anything BA has done. If Superman hits BA (or other heralds) with the same power he hit those probes with then BA and they are dead instantly.
If black Adam was the hero he would have destroyed those probes too. If superman is strong enough to destroy the probes, then so is ba, CM, Thor or any other of his peers.

Originally posted by JBL
Lol. Superman mental blocks are for weak people he may kill. Instead of reminding himself EVERY time he engages a weakling or someone he may accidentally kill he trained himself to subconsciously be careful. He had went all out plenty of times. There is Nothing going on in supermans head that prevents him from using his full strength and powers. Black Adam wins a close one.
Originally posted by JBL
If black Adam was the hero he would have destroyed those probes too. If superman is strong enough to destroy the probes, then so is ba, CM, Thor or any other of his peers.

Haha, seriously?

Yes, of course you are serious. One probe destroyed JLA. One probe killed 100k daxamites. One probe took on Mordru and entire LOSH. But somehow that doesn't counts.

Forget Probes, Adam wasn't even able to take down a random robot in Imperiex's ship. Even with the aid of Power Girl, Ray and Airwave. Until Dr. Fate stepped in.

Originally posted by JBL
If black Adam was the hero he would have destroyed those probes too. If superman is strong enough to destroy the probes, then so is ba, CM, Thor or any other of his peers.

You don't attribute a characters feats to another character, that's faulty logic.

Unless of course there is reason to.

If Character A lifted a planet and then in a later instance same circumstances of course Grappled with Character B with B overpowering A.Then it's safe to say B is stronger then A.

If Character A has a consistent history of Stalemating with Character B in strength but then goes on to do something massive I wouldn't say their still equal.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Haha, seriously?

Yes, of course you are serious. One probe destroyed JLA. One probe killed 100k daxamites. One probe took on Mordru and entire LOSH. But somehow that doesn't counts.

Forget Probes, Adam wasn't even able to take down a random robot in Imperiex's ship. Even with the aid of Power Girl, Ray and Airwave. Until Dr. Fate stepped in.

really dude? Firelord took on Thor and did well, he took on Surfer and did well, but big ole skyfather Spider-Man took down the mighty firelord. Get the picture now. If one of those probes were to attack asgard, Thor would struggle with it until it harms a child. Then Thor would yell and send his hammer through 20 probes. That's how comics work😘

Originally posted by JBL
Lol. Superman mental blocks are for weak people he may kill. Instead of reminding himself EVERY time he engages a weakling or someone he may accidentally kill he trained himself to subconsciously be careful. He had went all out plenty of times. There is Nothing going on in supermans head that prevents him from using his full strength and powers. Black Adam wins a close one.

You don't know shit about Superman. Just because you don't accept his dynamic strength doesn't mean it doesn't exist.

Also, he killed Doomsday in not a lot of blows when he stopped holding back, despite Doomsday was getting stronger.

http://s1199.photobucket.com/user/Delta1938/library/SupermanVS/Villains/Doomsday/DOS/REBIRTH

Originally posted by JBL
If black Adam was the hero he would have destroyed those probes too. If superman is strong enough to destroy the probes, then so is ba, CM, Thor or any other of his peers.

This is a circular argument. Prove your case or concede you're talking out your ass. I'll give you a pineapple as a reward for either.

Originally posted by JBL
really dude? Firelord took on Thor and did well, he took on Surfer and did well, but big ole skyfather Spider-Man took down the mighty firelord. Get the picture now. If one of those probes were to attack asgard, Thor would struggle with it until it harms a child. Then Thor would yell and send his hammer through 20 probes. That's how comics work😘

Are you taking one showing against Spider-man and applying it to entire arc of OWAW?

Where is the probe busting black adam?

No, he wouldn't. A single probe shitstomped Zod, Ignition and Bizarro together. Tore apart Warrior Guy Gardner to molecular level. Destroyed Almerac, destroyed Kalanor etc.

The probes were unstoppable to pretty much everyone save Doomsday or Superman. Thor isn't that powerful.

Originally posted by Surtur
What do you mean when you say she can tank all out attacks? At one point in space Superman hits her so hard he knocks her unconscious and it is only the heat from re-entry that wakes her up. At another point he seems to break her wrist merely by squeezing it with one hand.

She survives due to bad writing and birds. Yeah..she summons some birds at one point. I'm not sure if she has done that before or if she just busted it out for that special occasion.

He was at the sun when he koed her.

Wasn't bad writing. Diana is just that powerful. Also, she was holding back.

This is a good fight and could go either way. They need to do this in a comic. I use to vote for Adam but Superman has proven he can pull wins. Don't know how many though.