Punisher vs Wolverine

Started by grey fox58 pages
Originally posted by Raoul
yeah, cos i'd trust tony stark, mister 50 state initiative who needed spider-woman to tell him that the skrulls were coming... 😛

So then he DOES lie.

Originally posted by grey fox
So then he DOES lie.

one thing always bugged me about the initiative (besides its inception, etc), and its that afaik, 99% of large villain attacks happen in new york, so what good is that going to do when one of the main guys you need to stop a skrull armada is sitting on his ass in texas or LA and can't fly...

Originally posted by Raoul

except the differentiating clones, knowing mystique is whoever she's pretending to be, etc...

Well I did says hes been able to differentiate between people by scent...we dont know wether DD can identfiy between different clones but since hes been able to identify certain odours from distances that Wolverine has not its a reasonable possiblity.

The problem is eventhough DD has enhanced sense of smell we mainly concentrate on his hearing.

Originally posted by Raoul

question: how much x-men have you actually read?

Lots actually. Lots of issues from the 70,s Falll Of The Mutants and Morlock Mutant Massacre, Astonishing X-men and oh yeah I read the limited series that Wolverine had in the 80s. So not as much as some people but thats a fair amount.

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
[B]Well I did says hes been able to differentiate between people by scent...we dont know wether DD can identfiy between different clones but since hes been able to identify certain odours from distances that Wolverine has not its a reasonable possiblity.

The problem is eventhough DD has enhanced sense of smell we mainly concentrate on his hearing.

that's because, imo, his hearing is his most useful ability sense-wise, the whole sonar thing etc...

while i do think dd has very impressive hearing, i think it lacks the subtleties that logan's might possess...

Lots actually. Lots of issues from the 70,s Falll Of The Mutants and Morlock Mutant Massacre, Astonishing X-men and oh yeah I read the limited series that Wolverine had in the 80s. So not as much as some people but thats a fair amount.

cool... did you like messiah complex?

Originally posted by Raoul
that's because, imo, his hearing is his most useful ability sense-wise, the whole sonar thing etc...

while i do think dd has very impressive hearing, i think it lacks the subtleties that logan's might possess...

Yeah but where is the evidence, but you might be right there. Maybe in terms of analytical abilities Wolverines sense of smell is better but DDs has a better range, but range is important to this discussion because we are talking about Wolverine ability not to get sneaked up on.

Originally posted by Raoul

cool... did you like messiah complex?

Havent read it....suprise!

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
Yeah but where is the evidence, but you might be right there. Maybe in terms of analytical abilities Wolverines sense of smell is better but DDs has a better range, but range is important to this discussion because we are talking about Wolverine ability not to get sneaked up on.

Havent read it....suprise!

This is for not reading Messiah Complex.... uhuh and durfist

Originally posted by Badabing
This is for not reading Messiah Complex.... uhuh and durfist

durhulk I kill you!

Wolverine senses of smell>>DD

How is this up for debate? DD has stated this.

Logan has proven it by discovering imposter before DD was able to. And if not mistaken DD was in the presences of the imposters Longer the Logan was.

Originally posted by Battlehammer
Wolverine senses of smell>>DD

How is this up for debate? DD has stated this.

Logan has proven it by discovering imposter before DD was able to. And if not mistaken DD was in the presences of the imposters Longer the Logan was.

Got proof? Not taking your word for it. You did also say Wolverine and Darkness was canon...*shrug*

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
durhulk I kill you!
biscuits
Originally posted by Battlehammer
Wolverine senses of smell>>DD

How is this up for debate? DD has stated this.

I thought DD stated that Wolverine SMELLED more as in BO? 😕

😛

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
Got proof? Not taking your word for it.

did jinzin already post the issue for you? It was during the infinity crisis if not mistaken. I will try and find the issue.

Originally posted by Battlehammer
did jinzin already post the issue for you? It was during the infinity crisis if not mistaken. I will try and find the issue.

What earlier on in the thread? I might have missed it.

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
You did also say Wolverine and Darkness was canon...*shrug*

It is and there really nothing to suggest it not. bading agree's it is as well. The writer interview on the issue clearly implies it was made to be part of Logans past and present. In no were in it does he implie or state it was suposes to be another realities wolverine.

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
Got proof? Not taking your word for it. You did also say Wolverine and Darkness was canon...*shrug*
I believe it is since it goes with the current Wolverine solo titles.

Originally posted by Badabing
I believe it is since it goes with the current Wolverine solo titles.

yup and then there is the interview which seem to heavly imply it was suposes to be revealing part of Logans past.

Originally posted by Battlehammer
It is and there really nothing to suggest it not. bading agree's it is as well. The writer interview on the issue clearly implies it was made to be part of Logans past and present. In no were in it does he implie or state it was suposes to be another realities wolverine.

Er the thing is sometimes you cant tell wether hes taking the piss....I have a feeling hes taking the piss....

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
Er the thing is sometimes you cant tell wether hes taking the piss....I have a feeling hes taking the piss....
What does relieving his bladder have to do with this? dur

😛

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
Er the thing is sometimes you cant tell wether hes taking the piss....I have a feeling hes taking the piss....

..............what that came out as gibberish.

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
Yeah but where is the evidence, but you might be right there. Maybe in terms of analytical abilities Wolverines sense of smell is better but DDs has a better range, but range is important to this discussion because we are talking about Wolverine ability not to get sneaked up on.

if you had read as much x-men as you say, i doubt you'd seriously ask that question...

Havent read it....suprise!

somehow i'm not that surprised... srug

Originally posted by Badabing
What does relieving his bladder have to do with this? dur

😛

I cant see the pic in that post....maybe I dont wanna see it. 😂

Originally posted by Battlehammer
..............what that came out as gibberish.

What im trying to say is that Bada is having a laugh he actually doesnt agree with you....