Punisher vs Wolverine

Started by Eternal Idol58 pages
Originally posted by Phantom Zone
What the hell has that got to do with anything?? He got the stash he said "Get to work", he didnt say "im going to get to work". Therefore common sense dictates that the stash was for Punisher to use.

Common sense dictates Wolverine stomps the Punisher. 😐

Again, you don't know how long Clarke's had that stash. There's no way he could've acquired an entire friggin' SHIELD armory while attending to Castle the four days he was knocked out. Common sense says he already had at least a decent amount of weapons hid away before he even met Castle.

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
Yes it does becaue we have to establish wether the equimpment belongs to him. If the equipment main purpose is for his benefit then its still his equipment. One of the things that you ahve to take into account is that in prep there is no outside help. Since the blackbird mains purpose is for the X-men he may not be able to use it when he want to and he would have to ask for permission (Wolverine probably wouldnt because he breaks rules but thats whats supposed to happen). Frank doesnt have to ask permission to get the Satans Claw. Saying that the Blackbird belongs to Wolverine is like saying that a book in the library is your personal property.

Well, you screwed yourself there-- the library's books don't belong to you, but so long as you're a member of that library, you can use the books for your own personal use. Sure, it's standard procedure to check out the books before you take them out of the library, but what if you just took them and brought it back later? No one would know until it was too late. Same applies here. You admitted just now Wolverine wouldn't ask for permission. I never said the Blackbird belonged to Wolverine. I said he had access, to all three Blackbirds, no less. I asked what's to stop him from taking one?

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
Ok how many other superheroes do you know that would use a pizza and a steamroller as a weapon, must heroes would just keep using there barehands the whole point is that Punisher will use anything that works. There are also other examples of him using a motorbike to drag Wolverine around and also for him to use gasoline that happened to be present to try and light him up.

What part of what you think doesnt matter? The writers so that it was fit for him to use the Satans Claw and the venom suit not you.

Anything around him that works, usually AS A LAST RESORT. If his 30+ years of comics have shown us anything, it's that the Punisher will go into a fight armed to the teeth with CONVENTIONAL weaponry ELEVEN times out of TEN. And yes, I realize that's not mathematically kosher, but since it's about Castle and weapons of choice, then 11/10 is about right.

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
I could say the samething about Mung, conventional weapons dont work so he decided to use something more powerful or something else. If he feels that something better is going to use the job he'll do it like I said hes never had somebody like Stu Clark before. When he was with Microchip he probably never used some of that stuff before now hes got somebody even better.

So then why doesn't he ALWAYS wear a mock symbiote? Clarke seemed to whip that one up rather quickly and with limited resources, so why the hell isn't Castle ALWAYS wearing one? Same with the Satan Claw. They get the job done quicker and more effectively, right? Why doesn't he have Clarke build him a custom variant of the Iron Man armor?

Because the Punisher will always favor guns. Most of the SHIELD guns we saw him using are just lighter variants of existing firearms. Satan Claw and Venomtech suit? Definitely not Frank.

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
No they are not!!!!!!! You are being a smart ass and you're wasting my time.

No, up until now, I wasn't being a smart-ass.

A writer. One, single writer-- Matt Fraction. Don't get me wrong-- So far, I've loved the new Punisher War Journal, but until a couple of others keep Frank rolling in futuristic weaponry, then it doesn't really fit. It's like Jeph Loeb writing that Lupine bit about Wolverine. It doesn't fit with what's already been established, and in this case, it's that Punisher primarily sticks with guns.

Again, I'm not arguing that he shouldn't have the SHIELD tech on him for the fight. I'm saying it doesn't really fit the character to use all that.

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
Look your seriously wasting my time. First of all Wolverines HF is reduced. We got scans in thie thread of Wolverine getting dropped and hurt by gunshots WHICH ARE NON-EINNIS. What the hell do you want me to do? You got Frank using weapons that you think are out of charcater for him to use despite the fcat the writers dont have a problem with him using it. We got non-einnis feats with Wolverine getting hurt and dropeed by bullets but despite that i guess the writers are crap. So basically you're just wasting my time and your going to either define everything as either out of character or crap if you dont like it.

You waste more of EVERYONE'S time by not using spell-check. We're all too busy either deciphering your rantings or laughing at their all-round poor execution. I've brought up some new points in the debate since joining in. You've just kept re-hashing a few lackluster points about Wolverine's healing factor.

Jean Grey pointed to Logan in Wolverine #65, after Logan had let some dude in a bar punch him in the face with brass knuckles:

"You have a healing factor, Logan, not a pain-dampening factor. That must be excruciating..."

That speaks volumes about his threshold for pain, and not just about the bar scene. Wolverine has scrapped with many of Marvel's top-tiers BEFORE his Healing Factor was amped up to Hulk levels. The Healing Factor enables him to fight longer, but it's his own sheer will that keeps him from dropping to excruciating pain.

Originally posted by Eternal Idol
Common sense dictates Wolverine stomps the Punisher. 😐

Not with 1hrs prep. Not when hes done well against Wolverine WITHOUT prep in NON-EINNIS fights. Everybody agrees that without prep he loses 8-9/10 to Wolverine.

Originally posted by Eternal Idol

Again, you don't know how long Clarke's had that stash. There's no way he could've acquired an entire friggin' SHIELD armory while attending to Castle the four days he was knocked out. Common sense says he already had at least a decent amount of weapons hid away before he even met Castle.

Well again I dont know what to say. Its just another example if you disagree with something on panel because you dont like it. Stu said:

1. They shut him down.
2. Hes also a genuis. Thats the whole bloody point of being a genuis in comic books you're able to do the impossible.

Originally posted by Eternal Idol

Well, you screwed yourself there-- the library's books don't belong to you, but so long as you're a member of that library, you can use the books for your own personal use. Sure, it's standard procedure to check out the books before you take them out of the library, but what if you just took them and brought it back later? No one would know until it was too late. Same applies here. You admitted just now Wolverine wouldn't ask for permission. I never said the Blackbird belonged to Wolverine. I said he had access, to all three Blackbirds, no less. I asked what's to stop him from taking one?
.

You do realise that if you want a book from the library you may not be able to get it because somebody else is using it? There are alot of X-men and somebody else could be using the jets even if he wanted to use it. Thats not the case with Punisher.

Originally posted by Eternal Idol

Anything around him that works, usually AS A LAST RESORT. If his 30+ years of comics have shown us anything, it's that the Punisher will go into a fight armed to the teeth with CONVENTIONAL weaponry ELEVEN times out of TEN. And yes, I realize that's not mathematically kosher, but since it's about Castle and weapons of choice, then 11/10 is about right.

Im saying it does not have to be a last resort but it can be a better option. No I dont see him using a pizza instead of a gun but theres nothing wrong him using a suit if he thinks it can get the job done.

Originally posted by Eternal Idol

So then why doesn't he ALWAYS wear a mock symbiote? Clarke seemed to whip that one up rather quickly and with limited resources, so why the hell isn't Castle ALWAYS wearing one? Same with the Satan Claw. They get the job done quicker and more effectively, right? Why doesn't he have Clarke build him a custom variant of the Iron Man armor?

Because the Punisher will always favor guns. Most of the SHIELD guns we saw him using are just lighter variants of existing firearms. Satan Claw and Venomtech suit? Definitely not Frank.

1. He doesnt always face people like Mung and Rhino.
2. Hes only just met Stu, im pretty sure that Microchip gave him tech thats hes never used before didnt stop him from using it.

Originally posted by Eternal Idol

No, up until now, I wasn't being a smart-ass.

A writer. One, single writer-- Matt Fraction. Don't get me wrong-- So far, I've loved the new Punisher War Journal, but until a couple of others keep Frank rolling in futuristic weaponry, then it doesn't really fit. It's like Jeph Loeb writing that Lupine bit about Wolverine. It doesn't fit with what's already been established, and in this case, it's that Punisher primarily sticks with guns.

Again, I'm not arguing that he shouldn't have the SHIELD tech on him for the fight. I'm saying it doesn't really fit the character to use all that.

Already made my points.

Originally posted by Eternal Idol

You waste more of EVERYONE'S time by not using spell-check. We're all too busy either deciphering your rantings or laughing at their all-round poor execution.

Brilliant still deosnt change the fact that alot of people on this thread agree with my opinion. *shrug*

Originally posted by Eternal Idol

I've brought up some new points in the debate since joining in. You've just kept re-hashing a few lackluster points about Wolverine's healing factor.

If you actually read the thread you havent even made any new points but you're acting like you've made a difference to this thread.

Originally posted by Eternal Idol

Jean Grey pointed to Logan in Wolverine #65, after Logan had let some dude in a bar punch him in the face with brass knuckles:

"You have a healing factor, Logan, not a pain-dampening factor. That must be excruciating..."

That speaks volumes about his threshold for pain, and not just about the bar scene. Wolverine has scrapped with many of Marvel's top-tiers BEFORE his Healing Factor was amped up to Hulk levels. The Healing Factor enables him to fight longer, but it's his own sheer will that keeps him from dropping to excruciating pain.

So...what you're telling me is that eventhough he currently gets taken, down by bullets thats all rubbish because Jean Grey said something about his tolerance for pain? I dont know what to say really, hes been shown on panel non-einnis having trouble with bullets. I hate to break it to you when somebody has feats you have to look at his overall career Wolverine has taken class 100 shots and been hurt by much less.... but currently he gets dropped by bullets so what Jean Grey said doesnt mean a goddamn thing.

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
Not with 1hrs prep. Not when hes done well against Wolverine WITHOUT prep in NON-EINNIS fights. Everybody agrees that without prep he loses 8-9/10 to Wolverine.

Ennis, in one issue had Wolverine blasted with with a rocket and take like it was nothing and a few pages later DD was able to take him down with a pressure point strike. The other non-prep that you're referring to is a great example of PIS, just like BP putting SS in a kimura or Wolverine cutting Thanos with IG.

And everybody agrees Punisher wins 8-9/10? That's funny, considering most people seem to be arguing against Punisher winning..

Originally posted by Ha-Son
Ennis, in one issue had Wolverine blasted with with a rocket and take like it was nothing and a few pages later DD was able to take him down with a pressure point strike.

So MA experts have been able to take down Wolverine or have the capability of doing so eg Mister X.

Originally posted by Ha-Son

The other non-prep that you're referring to is a great example of PIS, just like BP putting SS in a kimura or Wolverine cutting Thanos with IG.

What example are you talking about and why is it PIS?

Originally posted by Ha-Son

And everybody agrees Punisher wins 8-9/10? That's funny, considering most people seem to be arguing against Punisher winning..

Are you refering to my post you quoted? That refers to Punisher without prep.

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
So MA experts have been able to take down Wolverine or have the capability of doing so eg Mister X.

What example are you talking about and why is it PIS?

Are you refering to my post you quoted? That refers to Punisher without prep.


Mr. X was able to take down Logan due to his telepathy and deliver enough damage to put him down, from what I remember it wasn't a simple nerve strike. Anyways, I'm trying to point out Ennis' flaws in that comic by itself, as he had Wolverine get blasted by a rocket then get put down by a pressure point strike. The issue also had Wolverine put Spiderman down with one kick. While I do think Wolverine could match Spidey (like Cap did), I doubt he'd be able to put down Parker with one kick. Heh, Parkers spider sense didn't even go off.

------------------------------------

Misread the last part. Thought you said Punisher without prep could beat Logan. My bad, I stayed up all night studying for an exam, so just a lil tired...

Originally posted by Ha-Son
Mr. X was able to take down Logan due to his telepathy and deliver enough damage to put him down, from what I remember it wasn't a simple nerve strike.

Im aware of that but Mister Xs telepathy did not make his strikes more powerful. He may not have used nerve strikes but Wolverine stated that if Mister X used weapons on him he would be in trouble.

Originally posted by Ha-Son

Anyways, I'm trying to point out Ennis' flaws in that comic by itself, as he had Wolverine get blasted by a rocket then get put down by a pressure point strike.

Yeah and there is no flaw because the samething could be said about Mister X. How is it somebody with peak human strength is able to take out somebody who has taken class 100 shots?

Originally posted by Ha-Son

The issue also had Wolverine put Spiderman down with one kick. While I do think Wolverine could match Spidey (like Cap did), I doubt he'd be able to put down Parker with one kick.

From what I remember Spiderman got kicked in the nuts.

Originally posted by Ha-Son

Heh, Parkers spider sense didn't even go off.

Heres the scans I hope this explains it.

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
I cant be assed with this but heres some stuff on spidermans senses.

http://img142.imageshack.us/img142/3140/feat10sspd4.jpg

note how the door has an explosive trap but Spiderman senses only warn him when she puts the key in, and thus triggering the bomb.

http://img154.imageshack.us/img154/2306/feat7ssml0.jpg

note how Spiderman is hanging on a rotten rafter but his spider sense only warns him just before its about to break.

Originally posted by Mindset
http://img166.imageshack.us/img166/7823/feat41ss1bl0.jpg

He sees the guns drawn and point at him, it still goes off.

Originally posted by Sado22
thanks.
notice they go off [b]when
they start shooting him. not before.
by that logic it probably means that his senses would have gone off WHEN the claymore would explode....only they wouldn't cuz they werne't real.

makes sense now.

~Sado [/B]

Originally posted by Ha-Son

Misread the last part. Thought you said Punisher without prep could beat Logan. My bad, I stayed up all night studying for an exam, so just a lil tired...

Ok.

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
Thats despite the fact that most people in this thread think that Punisher wins the majority
How the hell is two people the majority out of 11+?

Sado, Phantom Zone for Punisher

Creshosk, Jinzin, Battlezone, Ha-son, Master-Borg, Eternal Idol, Buster 1, Raoul, AJ ... etc. For Wolverine.

Talk about deluded...

Originally posted by Creshosk
How the hell is two people the majority out of 11+?

Sado, Phantom Zone for Punisher

Creshosk, Jinzin, Battlezone, Ha-son, Master-Borg, Eternal Idol, Buster 1, Raoul, AJ ... etc. For Wolverine.

Talk about deluded...

Er theres more than two people but im not going to going to count them if you want to go back and count every single person thats up to you. Anyway ive already stated I can settle for 5/10 but no less.

You guys forgot about me 🙁

Wolverine for the win 😱

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
Er theres more than two people but im not going to going to count them if you want to go back and count every single person thats up to you. Anyway ive already stated I can settle for 5/10 but no less.
redhotrash, iceman24567, Darth MArtin, OneDumbG0, Python99, Sado, Phantom Zone for Punisher

Creshosk, Jinzin, Battlezone, Ha-son, Master-Borg, Eternal Idol, Buster 1, Raoul, AJ, Soljer, Symmetric Chaos, Bouboumaster, Wolverine2006, starlock, Decimus, xmarksthespot, jgiant, carver9, Zeitgeist, Captainstoic, manx422, QBoy45
... etc. For Wolverine.

7 for punisher
22 for wolverine.

😐

How the hell is more than three times less the majority?

Originally posted by Creshosk
redhotrash, iceman24567, Darth MArtin, OneDumbG0, Python99, Sado, Phantom Zone for Punisher

Creshosk, Jinzin, Battlezone, Ha-son, Master-Borg, Eternal Idol, Buster 1, Raoul, AJ, Soljer, Symmetric Chaos, Bouboumaster, Wolverine2006, starlock, Decimus, xmarksthespot, jgiant, carver9, Zeitgeist, Captainstoic, manx422, QBoy45
... etc. For Wolverine.

7 for punisher
22 for wolverine.

😐

How the hell is more than three times less the majority?

Whoa im pretty sure you made som mistakes there for example master-borg.....anyway you're the ones who said that argumentam ad popluarem is a fallacy (however you spell it). Lol you actually went and counted it.

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
Whoa im pretty sure you made som mistakes there for example master-borg.....anyway you're the ones who said that argumentam ad popluarem is a fallacy (however you spell it). Lol you actually went and counted it.

A.)

Originally posted by Master-Borg
punisher loses majority, but it's not a spite thread imo. THere are a lot of threads where one side clearly wins majority, but spite thread means threadmaker feels one side has no chance and still made it.

B.) I'm not surprised that you missed the point again... You were trying to commit the fallacy, and poorly at that. I was merely correcting your blatent lie.

Originally posted by Creshosk
A.)

B.) I'm not surprised that you missed the point again... You were trying to commit the fallacy, and poorly at that. I was merely correcting your blatent lie.

Oh ok im lying? I didnt make a mistake? Ok. 👆

rickson by armbar!!!!

Originally posted by Eternal Idol
Well, you screwed yourself there-- the library's books don't belong to you, but so long as you're a member of that library, you can use the books for your own personal use. Sure, it's standard procedure to check out the books before you take them out of the library, but what if you just took them and brought it back later? No one would know until it was too late. Same applies here. You admitted just now Wolverine wouldn't ask for permission. I never said the Blackbird belonged to Wolverine. I said he had access, to all three Blackbirds, no less. I asked what's to stop him from taking one?

I'd like to point out at the moment that even Sabretooth commandeered a blackbird jet while staying at the X-mansion.

Common sense dictates Wolverine stomps the Punisher

common sense also dictates that superman would pwn wonderwoman 10/10 😬

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
. [B]but currently he gets dropped by bullets so what Jean Grey said doesnt mean a goddamn thing. [/B]

Why do you continue to ignore the circumstances of that "feat"?

Are you just ignoring it to be subjective or have you seriously missed out everytime it's been explained to you?

Wolverine got dropped by what's likely to be hundreds and hundreds of bullets. Not just a few or a couple. Beyond that he got put down in a desert environment which weakens his healing factor as was stated back in Wolverine vol.1.

Then we have him get up in one panel from a bullet in his brain? That's faster than even Sabretooth himself was able to recover from Wolverine puncturing his skull 3 years ago when he was fighting off Supermen and taking Sas punches to the face. 😬

Then this huge battle that he just had with Deadpool. Kinda shows that it's gonna take more than a few bullets to drop Logan if you ask me. 😐

Haven't read recent depowered Wolverine, how depowered is he compared to old him?

Originally posted by A.J 2008
Haven't read recent depowered Wolverine, how depowered is he compared to old him?
Originally posted by jinzin
Why do you continue to ignore the circumstances of that "feat"?

Are you just ignoring it to be subjective or have you seriously missed out everytime it's been explained to you?

Wolverine got dropped by what's likely to be hundreds and hundreds of bullets. Not just a few or a couple. Beyond that he got put down in a desert environment which weakens his healing factor as was stated back in Wolverine vol.1.

Then we have him get up in one panel from a bullet in his brain? That's faster than even Sabretooth himself was able to recover from Wolverine puncturing his skull 3 years ago when he was fighting off Supermen and taking Sas punches to the face. 😬

Then this huge battle that he just had with Deadpool. Kinda shows that it's gonna take more than a few bullets to drop Logan if you ask me. 😐

LOL AJ you so crazay!

✅ And proudly so.

So Jinzin since hes been powered down has the issues been any good?