Yoda versus Dumbledore (the Force versus Hogwarts magic)

Started by Ya Krunk'd Floo48 pages
Ya Krunk'd Floo Moving with the swell.

Apart from Bardock's beautiful drawing, this whole discussion is completely retrarded.

I like it.

Bardock42 Junior Member

Originally posted by Ya Krunk'd Floo
Apart from Bardock's beautiful drawing, this whole discussion is completely retrarded.

I like it.

I thought about you while painting it.

dadudemon Senior Member
Originally posted by Bardock42
Exactly.

*reads over the last several pages*

Makes sense now why you'd say that.

Strangelove Misunderstood Genius

Just coming back to this for a second:

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Translation: Yoda doesnt display his full powers in the movies, so this is how I am gonna win.
Dumbledore's full range of power been explored either. But in EU materials, Yoda's limits are much better tested and explored. Hell, forget the limits of Dumbledore's power, we don't even know the limits of magic. If you're going to base your argument that Yoda's full power hasn't been used, then that's an argument you're going to lose, amigo.

Ya Krunk'd Floo Moving with the swell.
Originally posted by Bardock42
I thought about you while painting it.

You are a beautiful person. Now, please tell me I was Dumbledore. He'd totally own Yoda's green, wrinkly, pleb-hanging ass-crack.

Bardock42 Junior Member

Originally posted by Ya Krunk'd Floo
You are a beautiful person. Now, please tell me I was Dumbledore. He'd totally own Yoda's green, wrinkly, pleb-hanging ass-crack.
No, friend...no.

You were the wand.

Ya Krunk'd Floo Moving with the swell.

Aha...You're saying I'm rock hard and stick-like. I like, I very like.

You seen that Mysterious Ticking Noise thing? Sweet as, my man. Sweet as.

dadudemon Senior Member

Originally posted by dadudemon
I feel that the magical world of JK Rawling has created is grossly underpowered. Considering all of the "stuff" that is covered in the magical world, a person similar to Orochimaru would have to exist and Voldemort doesn't really cut it for me.

If someone were TRULY able to become great at magic in Rawling's Harry Potter universe, then the possibilities are endless.

As I read her stories, I thought that Voldemort was very weak considering the reputation he was supposed to have.

I could go on for pages about things that could be done by a truly powerful wizard/witch...

Still, it is no contest.

Dumbledore by a ridiculous landslide.

Bardock42 Junior Member

Originally posted by Blax_Hydralisk
Now now now. Don't get out the celebratory cups just yet.

When I get home from school I will counter everything that's been said so far.

Not to be a dick, and you know I love your WetBlack ass, but you spend an awful long time in School.

Damn, I just checked the racial slur database, and it seems I was not the first to come up with that one 🙁

dadudemon Senior Member
Originally posted by Bardock42
Damn, I just checked the racial slur database, and it seems I was not the first to come up with that one 🙁

WTF? Is that German owned and operated?

Strangelove Misunderstood Genius

haha....racial slur database.

Rogue Jedi Restricted

fukking cracker.

Placidity Chief Executive Officer

Maybe you shouldn't have used Yoda to represent the Force. Darth Sidious, although inferior to Yoda, has all the more aggressive Dark Side Force powers at his disposal. A single Bolt of force Lightning is sure to smoke Dumbledore to a nice charcoal grill.

Also the most powerful Jedis/Sith were before the time of Yoda. Yoda only possesses a fraction of what the former Force users could do.

Rogue Jedi Restricted

Yoda has been known to be able to tap into the dark side without turning.

Strangelove Misunderstood Genius

Doesn't change the fact that Dumbledore bulldozes him.

Placidity Chief Executive Officer
Originally posted by Strangelove
Doesn't change MY OPINION that Dumbledore bulldozes him.

Fixed.

Rogue Jedi Restricted

What if Dumbles is disarmed? What type of defense/offense can he mount without a wand?

Strangelove Misunderstood Genius

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
What if Dumbles is disarmed? What type of defense/offense can he mount without a wand?
Without his wand, he can't really do anything, I'll admit. That said, there's no way you're getting the wand out of his hand.
Originally posted by Placidity
Fixed.
The fact that it's my opinion pretty much goes without saying, fckwit.

Rogue Jedi Restricted

Originally posted by Strangelove
Without his wand, he can't really do anything, I'll admit. That said, there's no way you're getting the wand out of his hand.
No way at all? How can you be so sure? And I have heard from a Harry Potter enthusiast that Dumbles can indeed do some magic without his wand, but that JK Rowling leaves it open for mystery as to what he can actually do.

Strangelove Misunderstood Genius

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
No way at all? How can you be so sure? And I have heard from a Harry Potter enthusiast that Dumbles can indeed do some magic without his wand, but that JK Rowling leaves it open for mystery as to what he can actually do.
I say "no way" because to a wizard, the wand is an extension of the self. And to a wizard as experienced and weathered as Dumbledore, I think it'd be mighty hard to get it away from him.

And maybe it is possible to do magic without a wand. The concept hasn't been explored extensively in the books or the films.