Doomsday HP vs Thanos

Originally posted by Kris Blaze
People claiming a destructible hammer is indestructible.

Well i have no idea which people u are talking about.

Also thor uses and indestructible planet busting hammer which makes some of his strikes alot more dangerous than regular punches.

Originally posted by Enyalus
I'm posting the WM Thor w/ PG vs. Thanos fight anyway - so everyone can see how it went for themselves and understand that once again, my position is backed up by on-panel evidence, not random BS:

1. http://i184.photobucket.com/albums/x287/Deywos/Thanos_WMThor1.jpg
2. http://i184.photobucket.com/albums/x287/Deywos/Thanos_WMThor2.jpg
3. http://i184.photobucket.com/albums/x287/Deywos/Thanos_WMThor3.jpg
4. http://i184.photobucket.com/albums/x287/Deywos/Thanos_WMThor4.jpg
5. http://i184.photobucket.com/albums/x287/Deywos/Thanos_WMThor5.jpg
6. http://i184.photobucket.com/albums/x287/Deywos/Thanos_WMThor6.jpg
7. http://i184.photobucket.com/albums/x287/Deywos/Thanos_WMThor7.jpg
8. http://i184.photobucket.com/albums/x287/Deywos/Thanos_WMThor8.jpg
9. http://i184.photobucket.com/albums/x287/Deywos/Thanos_WMThor9.jpg
10. http://i184.photobucket.com/albums/x287/Deywos/Thanos_WMThor10.jpg
11. http://i184.photobucket.com/albums/x287/Deywos/Thanos_WMThor11.jpg

Now, a few things to note: Thanos lands five blows (including energy blast) against Thor. Thor lands five blows of his own. Thanos knocks Thor off of his feet with his blows (including energy blast) four times (once, through the floor itself). Thor knocks Thanos off of his feet once (also lands a very solid blow just prior to Thanos knocking him through the floor.)

ANYONE should be able to look at that fight and tell Thanos held the edge. That he was winning where the entire Infinity Watch, Silver Surfer, and Dr. Strange got dropped like little children.

The fact that his blows did more damage (knocking Thor off of his feet) should prove that his striking power > WM Thor w/ PG's. And if any of you need any indication of how powerful Thor was, he was able to one-shot Drax even before he had the power gem. The same Drax who in turn one-shotted a Quantum Band wielding Champion.

Thank you, I rest my case.

Originally posted by fangirl101
Are you kidding me? Your case is sad. Thanos did not hold the edge.

On panel evidence doesn't lie. Yes, Thanos had the advantage.

Originally posted by fangirl101
for one. DD beat Skyfathers. Thor beat NONE.

Pre-DOTNG DS is not Skyfather level.

Originally posted by fangirl101
Thanos's shields cracked like tissue paper. He was using amped energy and still got punked into a wall.

Thanos was in no way amped. This was under his own power. He wasn't even expecting a battle. Pip teleported them into Thanos' location unexpectedly.

Originally posted by fangirl101
On top of that, Thor does not evolve on the fly and still felt pain. Something DD has over him.

I wasn't seeking to compare Thor to DD. Merely strength and brawling wise. And DD adapts on the fly as much as Hulk does (breathing in space, anyone). H/P DD did nothing, evolving wise, besides covering up his ear canals.

Originally posted by Enyalus

On panel evidence doesn't lie. Yes, Thanos had the advantage.

Pre-DOTNG DS is not Skyfather level.

Thanos was in no way amped. This was under his own power. He wasn't even expecting a battle. Pip teleported them into Thanos' location unexpectedly.

I wasn't seeking to compare Thor to DD. Merely strength and brawling wise. And DD adapts on the fly as much as Hulk does (breathing in space, anyone). H/P DD did nothing, evolving wise, besides covering up his ear canals. [/B]

DS created stayne who is so far above the top tier it isn't funny. Out of his own power. He's one shotted the uber trans tiered EASG. He Pwned Jimmy with the combined might of thousands of New Gods. He also Beat Cyborg Superman and then held him captive. Something not even the Source Wall could completely do. And DD resurrected from Pure Omega Beams and then Beat DS. Yes DD beat a skyfather. Thor did not.

Originally posted by fangirl101
. Orion, Was able to contain UNIVERSAL destroying energies. And he has been bitched so many times by DS. So how the hell is Pre-DOTNG DS not skyfather?

DS created stayne who is so far above the top tier it isn't funny. Out of his own power. He's one shotted the uber trans tiered EASG. He Pwned Jimmy with the combined might of thousands of New Gods. He also Beat Cyborg Superman and then held him captive. Something not even the Source Wall could completely do. And DD resurrected from Pure Omega Beams and then Beat DS. Yes DD beat a skyfather. Thor did not.

You're using PC feats now to make your case?

Originally posted by Enyalus
You're using PC feats now to make your case?

Originally posted by fangirl101
No. you obviously argue against a character you know nothing about. Everything I mentioned was Post crisis.

You're right. The Stayne feat threw me. But last I checked, I wasn't arguing against Darkseid.

That was an avatar of Darkseid that Doomsday pwned

A few hundred thousand years ago Darkseid met DD and could have killed him with the OE but wanted to fight him hand to hand instead

The fight never took place because the planet was about to blow

Originally posted by Xzpunisher
That was an avatar of Darkseid that Doomsday pwned

Right, I forgot about the retcon of his losses.

Originally posted by Enyalus
Right, I forgot about the retcon of his losses.

Just like Doom and his Doombots everytime he loses to the FF

Originally posted by Xzpunisher
Yeah they use to use it as a plot device

Just like Doom and his Doombots everytime he loses to the FF

Right. So bottom line is DD didn't beat a skyfather, regardless of whether DS is or is not.

😎

Originally posted by Enyalus
Right. So bottom line is DD didn't beat a skyfather, regardless of whether DS is or is not.

😎

Beside they can do that without killing his credibility

DS for most of the time has been physically superior to Supes ei strength and durability

How is it that Supes can tank DD hits while DS gets beaten to the point where he needs a mother box to save his life

Its simply an avatar

No one really has...well cept supes that one time. Anyhow Thor wasn't tapping anywhere near the energy he could have and Thanos being skyfather is to generous IMO.

Originally posted by The Great Galen
No one really has...well cept supes that one time. Anyhow Thor wasn't tapping anywhere near the energy he could have and Thanos being skyfather is to generous IMO.

Thor thought he could contend with Odin. And that assertion isn't totally without merit. When Odin attempts to battle Thor's insanity (Thor is still drawing on the gem subconsciously at this point), its depicted as a stalemate before Odin decides he can't do it without killing Thor and leaves.

And Thor still utterly stomps the entire Infinity Watch, Surfer, and Dr. Strange. A feat I don't believe Superman could accomplish (or would you like to set up that in a vs. match, Galen?)

No doubt he wasn't taping the gem's full potential - no one said he was. He's still an absolute physical beast who is more than ten times stronger than a normal Thor, wielding a skyfather enchanted weapon. And I hope you'll agree now, after seeing the entire battle, that Thanos did in fact have the edge.

This is why I believe that even if Thanos resorted to a physical match, that yes he would lose, but no it would not be a stomp.

As it is, Thanos is extremely intelligent and a very savvy fighter. He'd BFR for an easy victory.

Originally posted by The Great Galen
No one really has...well cept supes that one time. Anyhow Thor wasn't tapping anywhere near the energy he could have and Thanos being skyfather is to generous IMO.

Supes beating DS has always been pure PIS bullcrap
Like when he beat him and threw him into the source wall

Pure PIS

Originally posted by Xzpunisher
Supes beating DS has always been pure PIS bullcrap
Like when he beat him and threw him into the source wall

Pure PIS

Well, it wasn't a DS avatar. And DS was portrayed as being physically superior to Superman until Supes got a brief sunamp. Plus he was prepped and got help from Wonder Woman. I don't think that battle was PIS.

Apokolips Now = Huge PIS.

DS is one of my favorite DC characters.

Originally posted by Enyalus
Thor thought he could contend with Odin. And that assertion isn't totally without merit. When Odin attempts to battle Thor's insanity (Thor is still drawing on the gem subconsciously at this point), its depicted as a stalemate before Odin decides he can't do it without killing Thor and leaves.

And Thor still utterly stomps the entire Infinity Watch, Surfer, and Dr. Strange. A feat I don't believe Superman could accomplish (or would you like to set up that in a vs. match, Galen?)

No doubt he wasn't taping the gem's full potential - no one said he was. He's still an absolute physical beast who is more than ten times stronger than a normal Thor, wielding a skyfather enchanted weapon. And I hope you'll agree now, after seeing the entire battle, that Thanos did in fact have the edge.

This is why I believe that even if Thanos resorted to a physical match, that yes he would lose, but no it would not be a stomp.

As it is, Thanos is extremely intelligent and a very savvy fighter. He'd BFR for an easy victory.

You sure it was "10 times"his normal strength....oddly enough thor has knocked Thanos back under his normal strenght before, and Odin was not stalemated he just simply avoided the situation cause he didn't want to kill his own son. Supes probably couldn't solo the infinity watch without some amp like thor did....but the same could be said for a lot of peak heralds.

Originally posted by Enyalus
Thor thought he could contend with Odin. And that assertion isn't totally without merit. When Odin attempts to battle Thor's insanity (Thor is still drawing on the gem subconsciously at this point), its depicted as a stalemate before Odin decides he can't do it without killing Thor and leaves.

And Thor still utterly stomps the entire Infinity Watch, Surfer, and Dr. Strange. A feat I don't believe Superman could accomplish (or would you like to set up that in a vs. match, Galen?)

No doubt he wasn't taping the gem's full potential - no one said he was. He's still an absolute physical beast who is more than ten times stronger than a normal Thor, wielding a skyfather enchanted weapon. And I hope you'll agree now, after seeing the entire battle, that Thanos did in fact have the edge.

This is why I believe that even if Thanos resorted to a physical match, that yes he would lose, but no it would not be a stomp.

As it is, Thanos is extremely intelligent and a very savvy fighter. He'd BFR for an easy victory.

Although Classic Adam Warlock was a freakin beast
And Strange is a joke now