Silver Surfer and Superman throw down like men...

Who wins in a fight in space with no "cheap" tactics? That means no weakness exploitation for Surfer and no speed blitz or T-Vo for Supes.

Surfer imo.

Lets see...

If we say that....

1. Surfer doesnt exploit Superman's weaknesses to K-nite....such as by duplicating it for weapons or bombarding Superman with RedSun...or changing his own body into K-nite.

2. Surfer doesnt screw with Superman's DNA or matter.

3. Surfer doesnt utilize cosmic energy to amp beyond Superman levels.

4. Surfer doesnt cheat by utilizing cosmic energy to sustain his endurance or heal any damage recieved.

5. Surfer doesnt utilize cosmic energy to boost his body armor/durability....

6. Surfer doesnt utilize his cosmic awareness to locate and use Lois as a human shield...

Then Id definitely say that Superman should take this for a majority of 7/10.

Superman imo is the better fighter, he wins majority.

Originally posted by horrorwolf

3. Surfer doesnt utilize cosmic energy to amp beyond Superman levels.

4. Surfer doesnt cheat by utilizing cosmic energy to sustain his endurance or heal any damage recieved.

5. Surfer doesnt utilize cosmic energy to boost his body armor/durability....

Then Id definitely say that Superman should take this a minimum of 7/10.

Originally posted by horrorwolf
Lets see...

If we say that....

1. Surfer doesnt exploit Superman's weaknesses to K-nite....such as by duplicating it for weapons or bombarding Superman with RedSun...or changing his own body into K-nite.

2. Surfer doesnt screw with Superman's DNA or matter.

3. Surfer doesnt utilize cosmic energy to amp beyond Superman levels.

4. Surfer doesnt cheat by utilizing cosmic energy to sustain his endurance or heal any damage recieved.

5. Surfer doesnt utilize cosmic energy to boost his body armor/durability....

Then Id definitely say that Superman should take this for a majority of 7/10.

Originally posted by darthgoober
Surfer can still amp and stuff, he just can't use solar energy absorption, red sunlight, or k-nite...

Then..Surfer takes this.

On second thought, also remove the options of BFR and time manipulation....

surfer loses hes got like no strength feats that put him on supermans level 😄

norrin

God im getting tired of this,surfer has never ever EVER amped himself to superman levels physically out of the blue stop acting like he can.

Surfer FTW.
Superman isn't strong enough to harm him.
Surfer can also amp himself indefinitely, enough to beat Superman.

Warning! Dumb a$$ post above.

Originally posted by h1a8
Warning! Dumb a$$ post above.

So, what IS the Surfer allowed to do?

If all he's allowed to do is blast and punch, I'd say the majority swings to Superman.

6/10 Surfer

Surfer loses horribly

the whole reason he can beat supes is his cheap ass versitility

Originally posted by Soljer
So, what IS the Surfer allowed to do?

If all he's allowed to do is blast and punch, I'd say the majority swings to Superman.

Surfer wins this.

IMO, by removing these exploitations from Surfers arsenal, you're also removing his ability to win.

Superman wins.