Originally posted by jinzin
Don't think so.
There's different Hulk's just as there's different influences on Hulk by way of Banner...
And that was just my point. It ISN'T the same Hulk... The only thing they had in common was that Banner wasn't in control in any facet, way, shape, or form anymore. I'm sorry I should have clarified this earlier. This is why I think the example is skewed: We're using a version of Hulk who was suped up to a point of strength that hasn't been compared to since. We've already seen WM Thor take on and stupify SS, but we haven't seen "SSJ" Hulk fail to put Surfer down cause he never had the chance to try. Saying that (and I know it wasn't you but that's what got us here in the first place) WM Thor could put SS down, while ignoring that it was only OTHER versions of Hulk that have ever fought him and not "SSJ" doesn't make a convincing argument for Thor.Sorry, perhaps I need to clarify again. Other versions of Hulk, powerful versions, have had little care over their personal well being, but this manifestion was crying about how he was getting killed. it just reads off to me like he's a wimp compared to other manifestions.
Granted Hulk usually gets put down before he can hurt Surfer, I don't think Surfer's ever (EVER) had to deal with Hulk at the level of power that's being discussed here. And, both him, AND Thanos have made comments that they wouldn't want to either. To me, that says something.
I know, but the Surfer thing was already brought up, so I figured "Why not?".
And I really hate talking about RRHulk, as his strength is so ambiguous, it's ridiculous. What he can do, and what he can't do is never shown. All we know is that he can potentially break the world, he's more powerful than he's been, and he's got gamma flowing off of him. And Iron Man's laser is powerful enough to KO him (yes I know Hulk let himself be hit, but he never lowered his durability... did he?).
How much can we really draw from this? If you were Devilhulk, you'd put him above abstract level, and others put him above Odin level ( 😐 )... so... he's pointless in debating about.
Until we see someone punk Iron Man's laser... 😖hifty:
However, Hulk sort of knows attacks that merely melt his skin off or whatever won't put him down. And he also knows that he's f*cked without gamma (especially when he has no human host to revert to). Plus, it could also be that he's telling his pacifist 'friend' to stop.
It's not Surfer's fault Hulk can't hurt him before he gets KO'ed, or the fight stops.
Surfer always fights Hulk... 😕
And prior to the Thanos comment, Thanos was in a previously weaker body... so I can't see how either has relevance to Hulk.
Anyway, Surfer could easily beat this Hulk anyway... it starts with raising an arm, and sucking his gamma away.
As for Thor... he'd have a better chance in his normal mindset.