Thor vs Superman

Started by joesha28453 pages

hmmmm

Originally posted by Cosmic Cube
Can you show me a pic of him when he was invisible? 😖hifty:

j/k

Moving fast enough to become invisible to the human eye isn't very hard for someone with Superman's speed. Intangibility is another matter entirely.

Dude, it's fairly clear that it went through him. He IS intangible.
His cape didnt even catch fire. He's inside the blast, nothing is bouncing off supes. He has see through reflections..etc.

Intangible

http://www.answers.com/intangible&r=67

It's a bird, It's a plane, It's Intangible Superman!

"It gets silly because if elseworlds are admissable so is JLA Avengers"

Only problem is that Busiek at JLA made reference of that crosssover in the comic. By DC standarts its cannon.

Of course Marvel didnt do anything like that yet 😉

About how many times and if Marvel has hit Superman post crisis aside from KC, ill check it out. True to be told i dont recall it now either. Billy has done that trick even before KC came out but againt Supes im not sure.

"you said busiek stories, so i thought you were under the impression he'd made thor huarmed by bullets in one of his stories. and again, he showed thor taking the brunt of the heat vision sans hammer"

Thats exactly the beef i have. If theres one story or another that suggests he is not bullet proof, it cant go against tons of showings when he does. Majority always wins. What beefs me more after that is that he makes Thor handle the heat vision at close range so he cant have durability that low. About Priest i read it in a thread at SHC, that he made clear about asking his opinion to Busiek since he has the rep to know alot about Marvel characters history.

I think i saw it in this thread:

http://superherochat.net/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=88498

Check the last pages where Thors durability was discussed.

Originally posted by olympian
"It gets silly because if elseworlds are admissable so is JLA Avengers"

Only problem is that Busiek at JLA made reference of that crosssover in the comic. By DC standarts its cannon.

Of course Marvel didnt do anything like that yet 😉

About how many times and if Marvel has hit Superman post crisis aside from KC, ill check it out. True to be told i dont recall it now either. Billy has done that trick even before KC came out but againt Supes im not sure.

"you said busiek stories, so i thought you were under the impression he'd made thor huarmed by bullets in one of his stories. and again, he showed thor taking the brunt of the heat vision sans hammer"

Thats exactly the beef i have. If theres one story or another that suggests he is not bullet proof, it cant go against tons of showings when he does. Majority always wins. What beefs me more after that is that he makes Thor handle the heat vision at close range so he cant have durability that low. About Priest i read it in a thread at SHC, that he made clear about asking his opinion to Busiek since he has the rep to know alot about Marvel characters history.

I think i saw it in this thread:

http://superherochat.net/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=88498

Check the last pages where Thors durability was discussed.

yes we can all find stuff like that

Else worlds is elseworlds, the kingdom which is in Continuity, kind of, is not the same as Kingdom come, as kid flash died at the end of kingdom come, both are different timelines. 😄

The Elseworlds mission statement

"In Elseworlds, heroes are taken from their usual settings and put into strange times and places--some that have existed, and others that can't, couldn't, or shouldn't exist. The result is stories that make characters who are as familiar as yesterday seem as fresh as tomorrow."
© DC Comics

The major events of this timeline begin twenty years from now, when Captain Atom is killed by the Parasite, irradiating much of the American Midwest. The end result is the deaths of over 90% of the then-active superhumans.

The universe presented in The Kingdom and related titles is almost identical to this one, but there are clear differences. (E.g., Kid Flash died at the end of Kingdom Come.)

his not the same Superman.

This poll here has superman winning by a landslide😄

like your link it means nothing😄

It also has Supes beating the Surfer

http://www.misterpoll.com/results.mpl?id=2643948648

Keep the faith🙂

Stay Whirly🤘

http://forums.comicbookresources.com/archive/index.php/t-7332.html

This one is about as referenced as yours, i.e. not at all.😄

loads more out there.

Thor is vulnerable to bullets😄

"Else worlds is elseworlds, the kingdom which is in Continuity, kind of, is not the same as Kingdom come, as kid flash died at the end of kingdom come, both are different timelines"

Im aware Kingdom Come is an elsewords, thank you.

"like your link it means nothing"

My link has nothing to do with discussing Superman. It has to do with Discussing thor. And hes not vulnerable to bullets if only one writer out of many says he is.

The only porpuse my link serves here its to discuss where and how Busiek got that idea. Nothing more.

"Thor is vulnerable to bullets"

Give me more than one example thats cannon where Thor was hurt by bullets at full power.

Originally posted by olympian
"Else worlds is elseworlds, the kingdom which is in Continuity, kind of, is not the same as Kingdom come, as kid flash died at the end of kingdom come, both are different timelines"

Im aware Kingdom Come is an elsewords, thank you.

"like your link it means nothing"

My link has nothing to do with discussing Superman. It has to do with Discussing thor. And hes not vulnerable to bullets if only one writer out of many says he is.

The only porpuse my link serves here its to discuss where and how Busiek got that idea. Nothing more.

"Thor is vulnerable to bullets"

Give me more than one example thats cannon where Thor was hurt by bullets at full power.

The one where the F16 unloads on him with its cannon and bullets break his skin. Scarlet Spider gives the ref somewhere in the Thor bulletproof thread🙂

The one where daredevil and the FF are in it, I think its a very old FF I only have it in UK pocketbook reprint where a cop shoots Thor and for the rest of the comic his arm is in a sling.

Ill check it out. Now i only have to know if those happened during the 90`s where he was depowered or when he was at classic levels.

Originally posted by joesha28
Intangible

http://www.answers.com/intangible&r=67

Main Entry: in·tan·gi·ble
Pronunciation: in-'tan-j&-b&l
Function: adjective
: incapable of being touched : having no physical existence : not tangible or corporeal

Originally posted by olympian
Ill check it out. Now i only have to know if those happened during the 90`s where he was depowered or when he was at classic levels.

The F16 nineties, the other was 60's, 70's, it also happened with the Space Phantom.

Originally posted by Avalonofthewind
When he was eclipso? Wasnt supes 😄

Kingdom Come..it hurt him but he still won.

Take your pick.


He didn't won.Cap Marvel sacrificed himself

Originally posted by K3VIL
He didn't won.Cap Marvel sacrificed himself

After Supes had released Billy 😄

Seems the Thors bullet proof thing its like Wonder Woman. He has examples of both.

Examples of Thor being bullet proof:

Thor takes machine gun fire and a bazooka from close range:

http://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y226/jjschm20/Thor210-04.jpg
http://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y226/jjschm20/Thor210-05.jpg

Iron man stating his armour is almost as tough as Thors skin:

http://www.comicboards.com/thor/view.php?rpl=040410002521&q=Scans

Thor # 480 where he takes bullets:

http://www.comicboards.com/thor/view.php?trd=040409215828&q=Scans

Appearantly there are examples of both. With Thor being BP as the majority over those two examples you meantioned Whirly. Wich im still trying to track down.

Btw that one from the 60`s..was it with Firelord?

Originally posted by olympian
Seems the Thors bullet proof thing its like Wonder Woman. He has examples of both.

Examples of Thor being bullet proof:

Thor takes machine gun fire and a bazooka from close range:

http://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y226/jjschm20/Thor210-04.jpg
http://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y226/jjschm20/Thor210-05.jpg

Iron man stating his armour is almost as tough as Thors skin:

http://www.comicboards.com/thor/view.php?rpl=040410002521&q=Scans

Thor # 480 where he takes bullets:

http://www.comicboards.com/thor/view.php?trd=040409215828&q=Scans

Appearantly there are examples of both. With Thor being BP as the majority over those two examples you meantioned Whirly. Wich im still trying to track down.

Btw that one from the 60`s..was it with Firelord?

The 60's one didn't have Firelord the Bullet one shows welts appearing on his skin which he calls troublesome (thats) vulnerable 480

The others also show his vulnerable

Case closed we agree 😄

No one said theyed kill him individually he likens them to bee stings, enough will kill him, like enough bee stings will kill you, the welts are as much damage proportionally as a single lightning bolt from Shazam would do to supes probably more damage.

His vulnerable discussion closed😄

"The 60's one didn't have Firelord the Bullet one shows welts appearing on his skin which he calls troublesome (thats) vulnerable 480"

Thor # 480? Thats during the 90`s when he wasent at full power.

And i do agree that Supes is above him in durability, but Thor how was - usually - portraited, with taking bullets and going to the sun etc, isent that far behind.

Durability case closed, moving on 😉

Originally posted by olympian
"The 60's one didn't have Firelord the Bullet one shows welts appearing on his skin which he calls troublesome (thats) vulnerable 480"

Thor # 480? Thats during the 90`s when he wasent at full power.

And i do agree that Supes is above him in durability, but Thor how was - usually - portraited, with taking bullets and going to the sun etc, isent that far behind.

Durability case closed, moving on 😉

So he can be hurt by bullets which cause him at least as much damage as magical lightning causes supes.

case indeed closed😄

"So he can be hurt by bullets which cause him at least as much damage as magical lightning causes supes"

No. Supes always got more wasted after a ligthing bolt than Thor with a bullet 😛

this message board will never end regardless of facts from either side!!?!? My question to those who love Thor is that how come the times i have seen him in battle is just throwing his hammer around nothing tactical at all what is this masterful training that i am reading about i have not seen any real skill of fighting from him at all. if anyone has scans of comics which depicts him more of a skill fighter than being reminiscent to the barbarian in the beginning of Gladiator(Russell crowe) then please put them up, i think supes has shown throughout the years that he can withstand and overcome magical attacks, because it comes down to fighting ability and i think supes has shown more skill in fighting than Thor-my opinion