Thor vs Superman

Started by quanchi112453 pages

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
So your an ignorant Thor fan?

It would be ****ing epic.

We need a serious beat down, and not jokes like Venom manhandling Clark, although I could believe that, with Clark being such a massive puss.

The boards would overflow with people rubbing it in and hate from the supercamp.

Originally posted by cdtm
I'm actually basing my opinion off of Thor respect threads.

He DOES have impressive examples of speed, but none of them really point at high level speedster stuff. The feats that are there are either of the lower level speedster variety, or fighting with other speedsters which in and of itself doesn't prove Thor is a speedster, as than you'd have to claim Deathstroke the Terminator is one for all the times he's punked Flash.

Identity Crisis was probably the worst example of all, with him actually tagging Flash with a reverse thrust of his sword..

yeah well the thing here is that Thor have actually moved faster than light before while Deathstroke just anticipated Flash's movement using his enhanced brain capacity.
Again Thor is slower but not slower enough that it makes it spite or anything. And if Supes has the speed and a slight strength advantage Thor has magic, energy drain, bfr option that can give him the win if he plays smart

Originally posted by Warlord
yeah well the thing here is that Thor have actually moved faster than light before while Deathstroke just anticipated Flash's movement using his enhanced brain capacity.
Again Thor is slower but not slower enough that it makes it spite or anything. And if Supes has the speed and a slight strength advantage Thor has magic, energy drain, bfr option that can give him the win if he plays smart

Not to mention the ability to omniblast, creating force fields, the ability to throw Mjolnir so that the hammer will home in eventually on its target, etc. Thor's versatility enables him to more than match what Superman brings to the table in terms of sheer physical attributes.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Neither do I. The best we can hope for is a stalemate. Wasn't one of the main reasons the first crossover fell through a result of Marvel not letting Thor being sacrificed on the altar of Superman? He was intended to stalemate Pre-Crisis Superman as I recall.

He does.

PC superman would take down ever incarnation of Thor ever.

Originally posted by amnesia
PC superman would take down ever incarnation of Thor ever.
😱 King THor and RKT would own him PC SUperman physiclly own current/ classic but ever incarnation come on man. PC supers imo would take Classic Thor 8/10 Thor would gets some wins but PC superman had a real bad rep with magic

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
I'm not happy that Clark won and I'd have liked a fight that was so anticipated to have lasted longer than 3 freaking pages, but the way he wrote Thor's defeat had class. He made it clear that Thor and Superman are physical peers, and that a Superman using his other powers such as heat vision, along with his speed and flight could beat a Thor who was in brick mode and did nothing but spin his hammer and toss blows around.

Heck, he even had Thor win the hand to hand confrontation they had (Not that much different than Thor looking superior to Captain Marvel in hand to hand in that brief skirmish.). With Mjolnir, I'd think the edge would lean to Thor.

I don't have much problems with that fight besides the briefness. I would have liked it if Superman fainted on his own after the defeat instead of being beaten down but whatever.

However, I do believe Busiek favors Superman.

all right.

Originally posted by Warlord
maybe he means PIS when Supes is beating opponents he "should" not be able to deal with.

IMO Darkseid is one of them. PIS instances like heat vision bloking the omega beams etc tend to happen with supes

that's not PIS. that's bad writing. there is a difference.

Originally posted by DarkOdin
😱 King THor and RKT would own him PC SUperman physiclly own current/ classic but ever incarnation come on man. PC supers imo would take Classic Thor 8/10 Thor would gets some wins but PC superman had a real bad rep with magic

PC supes would defeat every incarnation of Thor even if they teamed up.

Originally posted by Warlord
wicha re the most powerful versions?

cosmic armor superman is the strongest version of superman.

Originally posted by amnesia
PC supes would defeat every incarnation of Thor even if they teamed up.
Rk Thor would defeat him by looking in his direction.

Originally posted by amnesia
PC supes would defeat every incarnation of Thor even if they teamed up.

Nope. That much Odinforce out on the field would mess PC Superman up pretty badly.

Originally posted by amnesia
PC supes would defeat every incarnation of Thor even if they teamed up.
Not every likely he was extremely venerable to magic. He was also very inconsistent written.

And his power level was not that much higher than mainstream Superman sure he had insane feat but also had ridiculous lower end feats and massive weakness to K-nite , Magic etc.

Originally posted by quanchi112
The boards would overflow with people rubbing it in and hate from the supercamp.

Lol, yea.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Nope. That much Odinforce out on the field would mess PC Superman up pretty badly.

Yeah, PC Supes had the real magic weakess. Current versions actually taken his fair share of magic attacks, but PC Supes folded at even a hint of it...

Orco or David Copperfield could beat him.

Originally posted by quanchi112
The backlash from supercamp would tear the internet in half.

I'm more of a Superman fan than a Thor fan, and honestly..

..that wouldn't bother me at all. Thor's an awesome character.

In an arena fight, I'll argue towards speed advantages nearly every time, even if it's against characters I'm a fan of, but comic fights never really play out like board rules...

Superman wins
thor is class 40 now

Originally posted by Joker793
Superman wins
thor is class 40 now

lol

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
lol
he was knocked out by iron patriot

Originally posted by Joker793
he was knocked out by iron patriot

and Taskmaster... 😱

Originally posted by Joker793
he was knocked out by iron patriot

He also took blows from Sentry in the same arc and wasn't KOed. Unless you want to argue that Iron Patriot's aura >>> Sentry's.

Originally posted by -Pr-

that's not PIS. that's bad writing. there is a difference.

I know...I was just guessing what he was trying to say since PIS off would only benefit Supes