Spider-Man vs. Captain America h2h only

Started by Acrosurge90 pages

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
My good God. Clones are usually not as good as there counterparts but this one is the exception to the rule. Did you understand that the fact that the clone was stalemating Spiderman is evidence that they were similar in abilty do you know that the robot was using the exact same techinques that Spiderman was using ie turning his webbing into wings? Basically the point has gone completely and utterly over your head otherwise you would not have posted that response.

I dont have to the fact that the Skrull was many times stronger than Spiderman compensates for the speed difference and furthermore if is a replica of Collsus it probably has enhanced speed to an extent. Dont you dare try to accuse my of trying to do anything you've brought absolutely nothing to this debate. Im taking lip from the guy who says that Beast can beat Captain America in H2H despite the fact he got his ass handed to him.

Yes its still irrevelant because Cap and street levelers have shown many times that they can hurt and KO Spiderman, but just because you got an example of Spiderman rolling with Hulks punch dont mean a goddman thing.

The Colossus Skrull (in the FF4 encounter with Cap) was using concussive technology to make it seem as if it had superhuman strength. It should not be used in this debate as it does not share similarities with the actual Colossus or with Spider-Man.

Spider-Man has repeatedly housed superheroes and villains way above his class level. Why should he be constrained exclusively to low showings while Cap gets only his best?

Originally posted by Badabing
spidur-man beats capameridur. duryes

Get him! angrymob

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
Get him! angrymob

Originally posted by Badabing
spidur-man beats capameridur. duryes
Behold, the irrepressible Truth of Dur!

Originally posted by Acrosurge
The Colossus Skrull (in the FF4 encounter with Cap) was using concussive technology to make it seem as if it had superhuman strength. It should not be used in this debate as it does not share similarities with the actual Colossus or with Spider-Man.

Anyway....cap has shown that he can take class 10 punches.

Originally posted by Acrosurge

Spider-Man has repeatedly housed superheroes and villains way above his class level. Why should he be constrained exclusively to low showings while Cap gets only his best?

I think you had better give the details of how he beat these supervillains, for example some people maybe more durable and stronger but may lack in the speed, skill and strategic departments.

Originally posted by Metalmanx
Alright then. Let's just do it here and now.

(I actually forgot your decision on this match, whether it was in Cap's favor or that he gets a few wins) Give your "valid" argument for why Cap either wins, ties, or gets at least 4/10. Provide evidence and prove your point.

Then once you've done that, I'll do my best to give you my valid argument as to why Spider-Man wins/gets a healthy majority. I, too, will do my best to provide evidence and prove my point.

Go for it. 🥷


lol. I have not been nor wish to debate in this arguement. I believe spiderman wins. I think people like H1 and marvel knight arguements have been terriable and more or less have been to simply deny and ignore evidences.

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
Anyway....cap has shown that he can take class 10 punches.

I think you had better give the details of how he beat these supervillains, for example some people maybe more durable and stronger but may lack in the speed, skill and strategic departments.

Flipped on its head, that argument works just as well for Spider-Man.

When has Cap taken class 10 punches from a guy as fast and agile as Spider-Man and directed by limited pre-cog? Clones and robots aren't going to cut it here.

Originally posted by Battlehammer
lol. I have not been nor wish to debate in this arguement. I believe spiderman wins.
Works for me.

Originally posted by Acrosurge
Flipped on its head, that argument works just as well for Spider-Man.

Not really no because to be quite frank Caps punches can be more effective than some of the people that Spiderman has fought. Hell if Cap can stun Proffesor Hulk and Namor underwater he can damn well one-shot Spiderman. Hell I dont think Venom can KO Namor underwater.

Originally posted by Acrosurge

When has Cap taken class 10 punches from a guy as fast and agile as Spider-Man and directed by limited pre-cog?

He took class 20 punches from sombody who was slower than Spiderman and he was drugged at the time. It doesnt really matter wether the guy was slower than Spiderman because if you look at there last fight Spiderman didnt hit him once. Spiderman most likely will ot get many hits on Cap.

Originally posted by Acrosurge

Clones and robots aren't going to cut it here.

What part of the clone was stalemating Spiderman dont you understand?

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
and Namor underwater he can damn well one-shot Spiderman. Hell I dont think Venom can KO Namor underwater.


...............is this seorusly your arguement?

come on you were doing better then this. This is a dumb arguement and you know it. venom attack power>>>>capt.

Capt should not be KOing namor under water or even hurting him for that matter

Originally posted by Battlehammer
...............is this seorusly your arguement?

come on you were doing better then this. This is a dumb arguement and you know it. venom attack power>>>>capt.

In general yes but the fact of the matter Caps attacks on ocassion have been shown to be just as effective or more effectivbe than people much stronger than him. Wether you like or not Caps pressure point attack seemed to have stunned Professor Hulk more than Venoms punches did.

Originally posted by Battlehammer

Capt should not be KOing namor under water or even hurting him for that matter

Namor was mindcontrolled but his durability was not reduced.

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
In general yes but the fact of the matter Caps attacks have been shown to be just as effective or more effectivbe than people much stronger than him.

Yes due to skill. But no amount of skill will make your attack power as much as a guy who 5 times stronger then you.

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
Namor was mindcontrolled but his durability was not reduced.

You mean when capt hit the mind control devices? which caused namor to be KOed?

Originally posted by Battlehammer
Yes due to skill.

Thats the bloody point im trying to make. Im not saying its as powerful as Venoms punches but wether you like it or not Cap actually managed to stun Professor Hulk and Venom didnt.

Originally posted by Battlehammer

You mean when capt hit the mind control devices? which caused namor to be KOed?

No that happened afterwards. 😐

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
Wether you like or not Caps pressure point attack seemed to have stunned Professor Hulk more than Venoms punches did.


so no your trying to tell me capt packs more power behind his attacks then venom?

also venom punches have done a hell of a lot more vs spiderman then capts have.

Originally posted by Battlehammer
so no your trying to tell me capt packs more power behind his attacks then venom?

No of course not but wether you like it or not Caps punches via skill have sometimes been shown to be more effective than people much stronger than him.

Originally posted by Battlehammer

also venom punches have done a hell of a lot more vs spiderman then capts have.

That still doesnt change the fact that Cap has the skill to KO Spiderman. Im pretty sure Galactus's punches would be more effective than Cap dont change nothing does it.

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
Thats the bloody point im trying to make. Im not saying its as powerful as Venoms punches but wether you like it or not Cap actually managed to stun Professor Hulk and Venom didnt.

No that happened afterwards. 😐


when did venom fight professor hulk?

and when did capt stunn professor hulk again? I hope your not refferring to when he tripped him out the door..............

you think it fine for capt to KO namor well under water.................
come on....................now that is a bs feat.

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
No of course not but wether you like it or not Caps punches via skill have sometimes been shown to be more effective than people much stronger than him.

and sometimes have not as well.

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
That still doesnt change the fact that Cap has the skill to KO Spiderman. Im pretty sure Galactus's punches would be more effective than Cap dont change nothing does it.

argeed capt can deffiently KO spiderman

Originally posted by Battlehammer
when did venom fight professor hulk?

They have look in the respect thread.

Originally posted by Battlehammer

and when did capt stunn professor hulk again? I hope your not refferring to when he tripped him out the door..............

No im not.

Originally posted by Battlehammer

you think it fine for capt to KO namor well under water.................
come on....................now that is a bs feat.

Fine it doesnt suit you so lets just scream PIS eventhough hes hurt a being even tougher than Namor. Its a high showing hes shown he has the capability to do it.

Originally posted by Phantom Zone

Fine it doesnt suit you so lets just scream PIS eventhough hes hurt a being even tougher than Namor. Its a high showing hes shown he has the capability to do it.

it not the hurting namor I have the problem with.

it the fact it was under water were not only is namor amped up..............but there also water risistences greatly weakening any attack capt could throw...........

thats a lot more then a high showing

Originally posted by Battlehammer
it not the hurting namor I have the problem with.

I dont care. Korvac durability >>>> Namor underwater. If he can hurt Korvac hes Koing somebody with less durabiltiy

Originally posted by Battlehammer

it the fact it was under water were not only is namor amped up..............but there also water risistences greatly weakening any attack capt could throw...........thats a lot more then a high showing

Bruv water resistance is most likely not going to make that much difference because Cap has beaten Atlantaens in H2H underwater. Hell if he can stun Professor Hulk who was more poweful than Namor he can KO Namor.....no it was not underwater but Professor Hulk is more powerful than Namor underwater.

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
My good God. Clones are usually not as good as there counterparts but this one is the exception to the rule. Did you understand that the fact that the clone was stalemating Spiderman is evidence that they were similar in abilty do you know that the robot was using the exact same techinques that Spiderman was using ie turning his webbing into wings? Basically the point has gone completely and utterly over your head otherwise you would not have posted that response.

I dont have to the fact that the Skrull was many times stronger than Spiderman compensates for the speed difference and furthermore if is a replica of Collsus it probably has enhanced speed to an extent. Dont you dare try to accuse my of trying to do anything you've brought absolutely nothing to thsi debate.

Yes its still irrevelant because Cap and street levelers have shown many times that they can hurt and KO Spiderman, but just because you got an example of Spiderman rolling with Hulks punch dont mean a goddman thing.

.....and I already told you that a robot clone of Spiderman was not holding back and could not take Cap in H2H. Spidermans punches are faster? Caps punches are more effective.

Of course he can hurt him but Cap is capable of taking full force class 10 punches

To tell the truth I dont think hes faster and what?

Sigh. doh

Alright. I know what instance you're talking about--the robot Spidey clone that fought Spidey. I've seen it. I saw where it was fighting just like him. And I also saw how it was defeated. All Spidey had to do was do something unexpected, different from his usual norm. The robot could not react in time, giving Spidey the chance to defeat it. Now you're going to continue to tell me that this clone was just as good. If it was, it would still be fighting Spider-Man to this day. But because it had a major flaw--lack of instinct/inginuity--it was defeated.

http://img293.imageshack.us/img293/8666/feat26fight2uk5.jpg

The original defeated the robot clone just like they usually do. By outsmarting it. Thus, taking away the credibility of a robot clone's statement. And oh yea--the robot clone didn't have a spider-sense. It would fare far worse against Cap because of that.

Not bringing anything to this debate? All I've done is what you're doing. Providing evidence and countering yours. Why is mine irrelevant? Because you say so?

This is getting ridiculous. Spidey has rolled with Hulk's punches more than once. That, coupled with the fact that Hulk is much faster than he appears, is a plus in Spidey's book. Spidey's taken Rhino's punches dozens and dozens of times over the years, and he's been fine. Say what you will about Rhino, he's still class 75-80.

Cap's punches are more effective POUND-FOR-POUND. Hulk's/Juggernaut's/other class 100s (without martial arts training) are more effective because of their sheer power. Or do you argue that Cap's punches are more effective than the Hulk's? Spidey might as well be the Hulk to Cap in this situation. Cap's 1-2 ton power vs. class 20 power? It makes all the difference in the world. Add that to Spidey's superior speed/reflexes? Well damn.

http://img379.imageshack.us/my.php?image=spidermanjuggy7ec.jpg
-Even with Juggy pounding on him, Spidey still manages to hold on.

Can Cap hurt Spider-Man? Sure. Can he do it as easily as you seem to believe? Hell no.

Do you NOT know about the Scorpion? He's stronger, faster, and more durable than Spider-Man (thus, superior to Cap in all of these aspects). And yet, even when he punches Spidey hard enough to put him down with his superior strength, Scorpion still ends up nearly busting all of his fingers because of Spidey's superhuman durability.

http://img380.imageshack.us/img380/4223/feat3durabilityjy6.jpg

So, if you haven't figured it out yet, wouldn't it stand to say that, unless Cap is able to utilize pressure points (very doubtful), that Cap's much weaker punches prove ineffective to Spidey? Possibly even hurting himself more than Spidey?

Goddamn. Why do I always get the debators that either can't write to save their lives, constantly claim I don't know the character, claim that I bring nothing to do the debate (when all I'm doing is the same thing they're doing), or sometimes all three? Come on, kids. They're called "punctuation" and "spelling".

Originally posted by Metalmanx
Sigh. doh

Alright. I know what instance you're talking about--the robot Spidey clone that fought Spidey. I've seen it. I saw where it was fighting just like him. And I also saw how it was defeated. All Spidey had to do was do something unexpected, different from his usual norm. The robot could not react in time, giving Spidey the chance to defeat it. Now you're going to continue to tell me that this clone was just as good. If it was, it would still be fighting Spider-Man to this day. But because it had a major flaw--lack of instinct/inginuity--it was defeated.

http://img293.imageshack.us/img293/8666/feat26fight2uk5.jpg

The original defeated the robot clone just like they usually do. By outsmarting it. Thus, taking away the credibility of a robot clone's statement.

Have you read the comic? Thats not how he was beaten he lost because he found the off switch. Hell did you even read the bit where its says Spiderman underestimated his mechanical foe?