Originally posted by Cavalier
The atom by atom bit took a considerable amount of time. Clearly not within the designated 5 minutes.
Clearly. But I'm talking about dispersing him over a considerable area, but him still reforming almost instantly. The uber feat you're referring to had him expanding far beyond the size of most of the battlefields. So it might be literally impossible for us to disperse him to the extent where he can't just reform instantly.
Originally posted by DigiMark007
Clearly. But I'm talking about dispersing him over a considerable are, but him still reforming almost instantly. The uber feat you're referring to had him expanding far beyond the size of most of the battlefields. So it might be literally impossible for us to disperse him to the extent where he can't just reform instantly.
Eh, my two cents-
After seeing this scan-
http://img139.imageshack.us/my.php?image=atombyatomfl1.jpg
I'd be willing to say his HF > Deadpools
And DP took more than 5 minutes to heal from liquid, yet his level of HF is still banned.
And Sand is a lot more spread out than DP. For one, his atom's are all over the place. DP was just a liquid, and he's still banned.
Originally posted by Charlotte DeBel
As for me, 30 points Sand is almost as BS (low herald at full potential) as [b]25 points Shift, who is\was Metamorpho 2.0 and high meta at the lowest (I think both him and Metamorpho should go to low herald tier, OK, high meta, 25 point is steal and a horrible one). [/B]
Originally posted by Charlotte DeBelseriously, sand "low herald" ?
As for me, 30 points Sand is almost as BS (low herald at full potential) as [b]25 points Shift, who is\was Metamorpho 2.0 and high meta at the lowest (I think both him and Metamorpho should go to low herald tier, OK, high meta, 25 point is steal and a horrible one). [/B]
he's strictly terrestrial and can still be fused into glass like sandman was. he's be hard pressed to beat shadowcat.
Originally posted by psycho gundam
seriously, sand "low herald" ?he's strictly terrestrial and can still be fused into glass like sandman was. he's be hard pressed to beat shadowcat.
In my match SMurph/BW argued that he couldn't be fused into glass as he's made of silicon not just sand.
And he has been in control of his body as molten rock before, so heating him doesn't seem to do that much.
And strictly terrestrial means nothing. Hulk's mid herald and he's terrestrial.
Originally posted by AlmightyKfish
Eh, my two cents-After seeing this scan-
http://img139.imageshack.us/my.php?image=atombyatomfl1.jpg
I'd be willing to say his HF > Deadpools
And DP took more than 5 minutes to heal from liquid, yet his level of HF is still banned.
And Sand is a lot more spread out than DP. For one, his atom's are all over the place. DP was just a liquid, and he's still banned.
DP healed instantly from that once his HF started working again. DP is banned because he both has a healing factor and cannot die no matter what happens.
Based on what I remember from the few JSA comics I've seen him in Sand is probably too powerful for the tournament once CIS is removed, basically for the reasons that DP is banned, he seemingly cannot die and can reform his body from even the most devastating injuries.
Damn, this ruling is gonna suck...
Based on the evidence presented (a scan which Smurph and B-dub actually provided themselves in the battle, surprisingly), I'm going to have to rule that Sand's regen/healing is beyond tournament caps as stated in Combat Rule #16, established per majority vote in the discussion period. The ability to reform from atomization exceeds the established tournament limits.
By rule all arguments based on the use of Sand's powers will have to be disregarded in the battle, and Sand is officially removed from their teams roster and banned from use by all participants (for Season 1).
Smurph/BDub, please submit a replacement character for use in Week 5. Sorry.
Judges, please disregard any Sand related arguments/offenses in the Kfish Vs. Bdub/Smurph battle.
Originally posted by AlmightyKfishsandman was fused into a solid piece of glass like a statue, unless shattered he would have stayed like that.
In my match SMurph/BW argued that he couldn't be fused into glass as he's made of silicon not just sand.And he has been in control of his body as molten rock before, so heating him doesn't seem to do that much.
And strictly terrestrial means nothing. Hulk's mid herald and he's terrestrial.
