PC Superman runs a Gauntlet

Started by darthgoober18 pages

Originally posted by The Great Galen
I wasn't suggesting his travel speed=blitz speed, I was referring directly about his bullrushing speed. Aside from that, while it's true that PC Supes was a lesson in comedy, it still doesnt subtract his feats which are perfectly valid in a forum battle.

They're only valid if they're "in character". Destroying the universe just to pull off a bullrush = not in character for Supes.

Originally posted by darthgoober
They're only valid if they're "in character". Destroying the universe just to pull off a bullrush = not in character for Supes.

Right, but aren't the characters bloodlusted as forum rules stipulate. Isn't that the reason forum SS is vastly different from his comic counterpart.

Originally posted by The Great Galen
Right, but aren't the characters bloodlusted as forum rules stipulate. Isn't that the reason forum SS is vastly different from his comic counterpart.

Yes they're bloodlusted, but they still fight in character. And if Supes has never willfully done anything similar, it's not "in character" for him.

Originally posted by darthgoober
Yes they're bloodlusted, but they still fight in character.

That doesn't make sense though, forum SS hardly fights like comic SS by a long shot yet there are debates that give him the clean win even in spite of his battle tendencies in comics suggesting otherwise. However, if we are going to go by by"in character"fights then Supes blast him with"anti-PC"vision.

Originally posted by The Great Galen
That doesn't make sense though, forum SS hardly fights like comic SS by a long shot yet there are debates that give him the clean win even in spite of his battle tendencies in comics suggesting otherwise. However, if we are going to go by by"in character"fights then Supes blast him with"anti-PC"vision.

Low showing don't determine "in character". Things like weakness exploitation are things that Surfer often uses when his opponent has them(Hulk, Wonderman, Vision, ect.), thus it's "in character" for him to use them in a forum fight. But Surfer doesn't create a thousand K-nite spears to impale Supes on because regardless of his ability to do so it's not "in character" for him to behave that way.

WM Thor w/ Gem would break PC Superman.

Originally posted by The Great Galen
Well how often does this occur, Spidey beat firelord and doged blast from Adam and other top tiers....or how about SS not realizing that Thanos power comes from his ship even after numerous encounters.
Are you serious?

Do you think all of Thanos' power comes from his ship in every story?

Because bran made some kind of comment is that what you are basing this off of?

Originally posted by Knowsbleed33
WM Thor w/ Gem would break PC Superman.
Yep. Supes doesnt get one single win against him imo.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Yep. Supes doesnt get one single win against him imo.

LMAO, time shattering punch for the win..srry quan.

Superman, very easy

Originally posted by The Great Galen
LMAO, time shattering punch for the win..srry quan.

WM Thor struggled with a force cage. PC Supes operates at higher power levels.

Originally posted by darthgoober
They're only valid if they're "in character". Destroying the universe just to pull off a bullrush = not in character for Supes.

It's within his power set. Such a Bullrush would obliterate SS.

Originally posted by Allankles
It's within his power set. Such a Bullrush would obliterate SS.

We don't debate solely off of power sets, we debate off power sets as they're applied by the character. If it's not "in character" for him, he's not doing it.

Originally posted by darthgoober
We don't debate solely off of power sets, we debate off power sets as they're applied by the character. If it's not "in character" for him, he's not doing it.

The destroying the galaxies thing was an after effect of the speed he was traveling in through those myriad dimensions.

Here he isn't passing any dimensions, there's a set distance between the combatants as stipulated in the forum rules. It's a neutral setting, no innocents for Supes to threaten. This is a weak defense from you.

Originally posted by Allankles
The destroying the galaxies thing was an after effect of the speed he was traveling in through those myriad dimensions.

Here he isn't passing any dimensions, there's a set distance between the combatants as stipulated in the forum rules. It's a neutral setting, no innocents for Supes to threaten. This is a weak defense from you.

PC Supes doesnt blitz like current supes does, but bullrushing only really requires travel speed since its simply"crashing agaisnt the other character as fast you can".

Originally posted by Allankles
The destroying the galaxies thing was an after effect of the speed he was traveling in through those myriad dimensions.

Here he isn't passing any dimensions, there's a set distance between the combatants as stipulated in the forum rules. It's a neutral setting, no innocents for Supes to threaten. This is a weak defense from you.


It's not a weak defense to say that if Supes stopped going that fast when he found out the universe was going to be destroyed because of it and he never went that fast again afterwards that it's out of character for him to do so now.

Again, we don't debate of powersets alone here, it's KMC not CBR.

Originally posted by darthgoober
It's not a weak defense to say that if Supes stopped going that fast when he found out the universe was going to be destroyed because of it and he never went that fast again afterwards that it's out of character for him to do so.

Again, we don't debate of powersets alone here, it's KMC not CBR.

Were not debating powersets, we've seen Supes already move that fast so why not assume he could apply it to his bullrush speed...besides you tried to equate SS travel speed with his bullrush speed to.

Originally posted by The Great Galen
Were not debating powersets, we've seen Supes already move that fast so why not assume he could apply it to his bullrush speed...besides you tried to equate SS travel speed with his bullrush speed to.

It is equatable, but there's a difference between something being possible and something being "in character". Surfer can travel millions of times the speed of light and going by logic all he'd have to do is aim his board at his opponents neck to decapitate him at that speed, but you'll never see me seriously argue for him to do that kind of thing because it's out of character for him.

Isn't bloodlust on by default?

Originally posted by Endless Mike
Isn't bloodlust on by default?

Yes, but they still fight in character.