3 Jedis vs 3 Siths

Yoda, Mace, Obiwan vs Sidious, Dooku, Vader(pre-suit). All are ROTS version.

1. Saber only
2. Force only
3. All out

Ick. I think the Sith take things pretty easily. In sabers, they've got a chance if Mace can deal with Dooku quickly. But in the Force and by consequence, all out, the Sith should dominate.

1. Sabers, Sith - 6/10.
2. Force, Sith - 8/10.
3. All Out, Sith - 7/10.

jedis??
siths?!?!?!?!
with an S????
blasphemy!!

but on topic the sith win 😛

Question: Why doesn't he like cats?

Scratch that.

Mace with Vaapad and Shatterpoint defeats Sidious. But take away the Force, does he still have those? Or are they considered (well, Vaapad at least) Saber techniques?

Oh and the pluralization pissed me off too.

Originally posted by Kenobiwan
Yoda, Mace, Obiwan vs Sidious, Dooku, Vader(pre-suit). All are ROTS version.

1. Saber only
2. Force only
3. All out

all these were ALREADY done witht the jedi triumphing each time. and worst case scenario obi wan is in trouble but mace and yoda could finish off thier opponents in time to help

Jedi take sabers, but the Sith take Force and all-out.

I'd give it to the Sith.

The Jedi definitely take the lightsaber round. Windu's Vaapad and shatterpoint charism will be enough to defeat either Sidious or Dooku (and Yoda could defeat Dooku there as well), and if Vader fights like the moron he is against Obi-Wan, he'll lose there to. Though, given that Yoda and Mace will win either of their battles, I'm tempted to say that it won't matter either way.

So, um, at best (for the Sith), Obi-Wan dies. And that's the only casualty I see the Jedi taking.

The Sith take the Force contest for obvious reasons. Anakin or Obi-Wan are cannon fodder here and both can (and would) be taken out rather easily. Dooku could take Windu, Sidious could manhandle him, and Dooku + Sidious vs Yoda = one crispy-fied Grandmaster.

All out? Um... actually, I don't know.

The movies did all these match ups and the jedi won evrytime. Anakin vs Obi wan Obi Wan won. Mace vs Sid Mace woulda of won if anakin wasnt there. And Yoda vs Dooku Yoda wins

Pre Suited Vader was curling massive temple statues like missiles and Force Crushing durasteel blast doors. He definitely takes out Obi-Wan in a Force contest and is at least the equal of Mace there.

But Obi Wan did defeat Pre suit Vader

Originally posted by Enyalus
Pre Suited Vader was curling massive temple statues like missiles and Force Crushing durasteel blast doors. He definitely takes out Obi-Wan in a Force contest and is at least the equal of Mace there.

You did see the RotS movie, didn't you?

Holy shiznizzle. I forgot all about that. Enyalus, Anakin can't overcome Obi-Wan in a Force push contest.

I find it interesting that people consider Obi-Wan to be weak with the force, yet he was able to stalemate Anakin "I shatter ceilings with my voice" Skywalker in a force duel, especially considering he was amped with the dark side at the time.

Originally posted by Gideon
Holy shiznizzle. I forgot all about that. Enyalus, Anakin can't overcome Obi-Wan in a Force push contest.

Correct, Sir. Vader can't do that...

Originally posted by Gideon
[...]if Vader fights like the moron he is against Obi-Wan, he'll lose there to.

Originally posted by Gideon
Holy shiznizzle. I forgot all about that. Enyalus, Anakin can't overcome Obi-Wan in a Force push contest.

I didn't realize we were using a mentally crippled Vader as the standard.

WTF.

How else is he going to fight against Obi-Wan? He goes nuts fighting against the man whom he loved like a brother/father, his mentor, his teacher. He identifies Obi-Wan as the source of the Jedi's problems and Padme's betrayal and he fights like a moron.

Originally posted by Gideon
WTF.

How else is he going to fight against Obi-Wan? He goes nuts fighting against the man whom he loved like a brother/father, his mentor, his teacher. He identifies Obi-Wan as the source of the Jedi's problems and Padme's betrayal and he fights like a moron.

I thought psychology wasn't a factor in vs. fights? 😛 Make up your mind. It's either Pre Suited Vader at his peak, or a repeat of Mustafar.

Jedi win all three

Well i dont think pre suit vader was ever that mentally stable so.....