Superman vs Magneto: Who can lift more weight?

Started by Starscream M8 pages

Superman vs Magneto: Who can lift more weight?

Assume the material of the weight they have to lift is metal.

Who can lift more?

magneto by far. I honestly dont think that anyone can lift up more then magneto can lift if its regarding metal. You know that pyramid that superman strained to lift, magneto would have done it with ease.

Originally posted by carver9
magneto by far. I honestly dont think that anyone can lift up more then magneto can lift if its regarding metal. You know that pyramid that superman strained to lift, magneto would have done it with ease.

He didn't strain. He made one noise as he picked up, a grunt or something, then carried the whole thing to Mars (about 35 million miles away)

Originally posted by The Pict
He didn't strain. He made one noise as he picked up, a grunt or something, then carried the whole thing to Mars (about 35 million miles away)

You do know that the lanterns assisted him with that pyramid right.

Originally posted by carver9
You do know that the lanterns assisted him with that pyramid right.

They assisted him when he was in space. I assume they covered it so it wouldn't break apart or whatever but he was still shown carrying it and he did uproot it himself.
They covered it in energy but they were busy transporting everyone else, Supes was left carrying the Pyramid, it's not shown that it helped him with the weight.

Originally posted by The Pict
He didn't strain. He made one noise as he picked up, a grunt or something, then carried the whole thing to Mars (about 35 million miles away)
but we do know his limit was near there* Maybe doulbe the weight next time!

Anyways Magneto for the win. 1pimpslap

Originally posted by The Pict
They assisted him when he was in space. I assume they covered it so it wouldn't break apart or whatever but he was still shown carrying it and he did uproot it himself.
They covered it in energy but they were busy transporting everyone else, Supes was left carrying the Pyramid, it's not shown that it helped him with the weight.

Its a high end feat for superman to even think about lifting a pyramid since it weighs millions of tons BUT he did strain in the beginning and he slowly took it out of space AND the gl assisted him. It didnt show how long they assisted him but they did. The pyramid was also leaning on his back as leverage, if anything it was a flight strength feat.

Magneto lifted a city size asteroid above the earth without to much of a problem.

Superman strains when he lifts a car, a bus, a building, a moon sized ship, or a planet. He does that all of the time. how can some one think that is a high end strength feat for him is beyond me. Wonder Woman is shown stopping a meteor mid fall, as in having inertia on top of it's weight, with ease. Which was much larger than the pyramid. By Far. Nearly as big as a city. As Terra, who can play with mountains like pebbles, couldn't even stop it. Superman is stronger than Wonder Woman. So I fail to see how the pyramid could be a high end feat for him when wondy stops a meteor far bigger and heaver and actually moving, with ease.

Probably superman

Originally posted by carver9
Its a high end feat for superman to even think about lifting a pyramid since it weighs millions of tons BUT he did strain in the beginning and he slowly took it out of space AND the gl assisted him. It didnt show how long they assisted him but they did. The pyramid was also leaning on his back as leverage, if anything it was a flight strength feat.

Magneto lifted a city size asteroid above the earth without to much of a problem.

how much stronger do you think Superman Allstar is than regular Superman?

He did lift like 40 quadrillion tons with one arm behind his back 🙁

Originally posted by fangirl101
Superman strains when he lifts a car, a bus, a building, a moon sized ship, or a planet. He does that all of the time. how can some one think that is a high end strength feat for him is beyond me. Wonder Woman is shown stopping a meteor mid fall, as in having inertia on top of it's weight, with ease. Which was much larger than the pyramid. By Far. Nearly as big as a city. As Terra, who can play with mountains like pebbles, couldn't even stop it. Superman is stronger than Wonder Woman. So I fail to see how the pyramid could be a high end feat for him when wondy stops a meteor far bigger and heaver and actually moving, with ease.

what does any of this have to do with the thread? my vote is for mags

Originally posted by Nestical
what does any of this have to do with the thread? my vote is for mags
The point that someone was using a pyramid as a high end to superman's strength, when wondy has been shown to stop something far bigger, and heavier, with no effort. Superman>Diana in strength.

Originally posted by Starscream M
how much stronger do you think Superman Allstar is than regular Superman?
what makes all-star superman's strength feats seem more incredible than normal superman's, is:

a.) the extreme ease in which he preforms said feats.
b.) we are given actual weights to go with some of the things he has lifted (which seems to be quite rare.)

hell, the simple act of him lifting his key to the fortress (which weighs 500,000 tons) is a greater strength feat than we've seen from most other post-crisis characters. and that's just his friggin' everyday front door key. lol.

Originally posted by Mr Marvel
He did lift like 40 quadrillion tons with one arm behind his back 🙁
it was 200 quintillion tons, actually. 🙂

Yeah, that's it! 😄

Magneto really shouldnt have a limit on this.

Originally posted by Galan007

b.) we are given actual weights to go with some of the things he has lifted (which seems to be quite rare.)
good point...it is quite rare.

Supes moved a device that was dwarfed the solar system in size...he wins and quite handily.

Originally posted by Galan007
what makes all-star superman's strength feats seem more incredible than normal superman's, is:

My opinion is that current Superman is stronger than AS Superman...I have reasons if anyone would like to hear them sometime.

As for the thread, since what they're lifting is metal - Magneto wins. Omega level mutants are supposed to have no limit to their abilities, and he does lift Asteroid M, a very large asteroid, 250 miles into the air with relative ease.

Omega-level is a marvel scale. What does that make Superman?