Batman vs. Punisher (with a twist)

Originally posted by Wei Phoenix
Seeing as he has taken blows from people far stronger than Batman. His damage soak is phenomenal. I don't have enough info on both of their pure strenght to gauge who is actually physically stronger.

Batman has also taken blows from people far stronger than Punisher. Actually, he has probably taken blows from people far more powerfull than anything Punisher has ever faced and taken blows from combined into one.

His damage soak is phenomenal, yes. Now, give me some examples of his best damage-soak feats.

Strength, I won't even bother to compare.

Originally posted by Philosophía
Batman has also taken blows from people far stronger than Punisher. Actually, he has probably taken blows from people far more powerfull than anything Punisher has ever faced and taken blows from combined into one.

His damage soak is phenomenal, yes. Now, give me some examples of his best damage-soak feats.

Strength, I won't even bother to compare.

Bullet wounds and The Russian.

Scans.

I'm really in a debating mood.

Originally posted by Wei Phoenix
Seeing as he has taken blows from people far stronger than Batman. His damage soak is phenomenal. I don't have enough info on both of their pure strenght to gauge who is actually physically stronger.

crylaugh

Originally posted by batdude123
crylaugh

It's more entertaining to beat them down with their own 'debating tactics' instead of pointing out the flaw in their argument. 😂

Originally posted by Philosophía
It's more entertaining to beat them down with their own 'debating tactics' instead of pointing out the flaw in their argument. 😂

The most fun is just sitting back and laughing.

Batman.

As a Die Hard Punisher fan it hurts me to do this, but Ive gotta go with Batman. Simply put, Batman is faster, smarter, a better fighter, and probably a tad stronger and tougher (which are Franks too biggest physical points). In virtually all ways, Batman can do anything Punisher can, but a bit better. Punisher has fought the likes of Cap, DD, Wolverine, Tombstone, SpiderMan, The Russian, even Ulik (with weapons), but his strength comes from weaponry, cunning and adaptation, none of which he would be able to use in this type of fight. In normal settings, with both of them knowing about the other, I still give it to Batman, but at more of a 7 / 10 record (here Bruce takes Frank virtually every time, but hes be Sore and Beaten every single time).

batman is peak human strength, batman wins this one

Originally posted by DTM
As a Die Hard Punisher fan it hurts me to do this, but Ive gotta go with Batman. Simply put, Batman is faster, smarter, a better fighter, and probably a tad stronger and tougher (which are Franks too biggest physical points). In virtually all ways, Batman can do anything Punisher can, but a bit better. Punisher has fought the likes of Cap, DD, Wolverine, Tombstone, SpiderMan, The Russian, even Ulik (with weapons), but his strength comes from weaponry, cunning and adaptation, none of which he would be able to use in this type of fight. In normal settings, with both of them knowing about the other, I still give it to Batman, but at more of a 7 / 10 record (here Bruce takes Frank virtually every time, but hes be Sore and Beaten every single time).

Batman was fighting him for 20 minutes in JLA/Avengers that sounds like one of the longest fights hes ever had.

Batman wins this prick dodged superman's speed blitz lol

for someone who does not have powers, has to be the most overpowered character ever!

Karate Kid

Captain America.

Punisher

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
Batman was fighting him for 20 minutes in JLA/Avengers that sounds like one of the longest fights hes ever had.

Oh I think Frank would give Bruce a good run, but hes simply not in Batmans overall class. If anything hes more a Batman-lite (which is saying quite a bit really). Now if this were Nightwing vs. Punisher, youd have a much closer match up, I say.

Originally posted by DTM
As a Die Hard Punisher fan it hurts me to do this, but Ive gotta go with Batman. Simply put, Batman is faster, smarter, a better fighter, and probably a tad stronger and tougher (which are Franks too biggest physical points). In virtually all ways, Batman can do anything Punisher can, but a bit better. Punisher has fought the likes of Cap, DD, Wolverine, Tombstone, SpiderMan, The Russian, even Ulik (with weapons), but his strength comes from weaponry, cunning and adaptation, none of which he would be able to use in this type of fight. In normal settings, with both of them knowing about the other, I still give it to Batman, but at more of a 7 / 10 record (here Bruce takes Frank virtually every time, but hes be Sore and Beaten every single time).

hahah a tad bit tougher. Thats a joke right there. 😆

Batman definitely takes this.

Not a joke at all, as toughness is probably Punishers greatest physical asset, and if there is any physical ability that Punisher is a near match with Batman, its toughness and the overall ability to take damage.

Seriously though, Batman would simply overpower him.

Originally posted by DTM
Oh I think Frank would give Bruce a good run, but hes simply not in Batmans overall class. If anything hes more a Batman-lite (which is saying quite a bit really). Now if this were Nightwing vs. Punisher, youd have a much closer match up, I say.

Depends on whos writing him.

Originally posted by Warrior18
Seriously though, Batman would simply overpower him.

Yeah you're right thats why it took him simply 20 minutes when they actually fought and we dont even know for sure if Punisher was beaten at the end.

Originally posted by Phantom Zone

Yeah you're right thats why it took him simply 20 minutes when they actually fought and we dont even know for sure if Punisher was beaten at the end.

Crossovers..............

Based on their respective strength feats he would.