Star Trek Vs. Star Wars

Started by Morgromir26 pages
Morgromir Senior Member

Originally posted by jaden101
They're not really "much more powerful" at all. Leia took a direct hit in the arm and it caused no damage at all.

If she were to get hit there by a fully powered phaser she would have disintegrated completely.


that wasnt a hit just a glancing blow 1 shot to an armored stormtrooper and theyre dead , plus disrupters disintergrate tissue and leave only blackened skeletons in a single low power shot

Doctor-Alvis Post-Crisis Balki

Originally posted by Morgromir
that wasnt a hit just a glancing blow 1 shot to an armored stormtrooper and theyre dead , plus disrupters disintergrate tissue and leave only blackened skeletons in a single low power shot

Sooo... blasters have as much power as a little stick with a sharp rock fastened to the end of it?

Red Nemesis The Blind Critic

If you watch the Battle of Endor again you might notice stormtroopers getting knocked down, but how many do you think died? The ones that went down usually had several ewoks hitting them on the head with large rocks over and over again. I don't know that I saw any die from arrows.

snoopdogg Big Pimpin

Didn't the Ewoks have the element of surprise against the Stormtroopers?

Acrosurge Lumine Infinitus

Originally posted by snoopdogg
Didn't the Ewoks have the element of surprise against the Stormtroopers?
Yes they did. This, however, does not change the fact that a hand held phaser at full power is vastly more destructive than a hand held blaster at full power. There's really no way around it.

And disruptors are hardly illegal in the Trek-verse. Klingons carry them. Romulans carry them. The Breen carry them.

snoopdogg Big Pimpin

Have we ever seen a hand held blaster at full power?

Shakyamunison Nam Myoho Renge Kyo
Originally posted by snoopdogg
Have we ever seen a hand held blaster at full power?

I didn't know they had an adjustment.

snoopdogg Big Pimpin

Originally posted by Shakyamunison
I didn't know they had an adjustment.
I don't know if they can but they can set them to stun. So I am going to assume they can adjust them.

Shakyamunison Nam Myoho Renge Kyo
Originally posted by snoopdogg
I don't know if they can but they can set them to stun. So I am going to assume they can adjust them.

That's true. 😄

Robtard Senor Member
Originally posted by snoopdogg
Have we ever seen a hand held blaster at full power?

It kills, if it hits a vital area. Greedo can attest to this.

Doctor-Alvis Post-Crisis Balki

Originally posted by Red Nemesis
If you watch the Battle of Endor again you might notice stormtroopers getting knocked down, but how many do you think died? The ones that went down usually had several ewoks hitting them on the head with large rocks over and over again. I don't know that I saw any die from arrows.

All of them. From the Death Star exploding a mile above their heads.

Haha, I kid. That Endor battle is really fun to bring up around Star Wars fans. It's like George Lucas' "if you have the spirit you will always prevail" is the fans' "****".

Red Nemesis The Blind Critic

I H8 U SO MUCH 😛

But really, if we stick to the story that no troopers died from ewoks then it isn't as bad... right? right!

Morgromir Senior Member

oksy remember you ppl forced me to bring this up one word ,Mandalorians

Symmetric Chaos Fractal King

Borg 😐

Morgromir Senior Member

The Mandalorians have kick@$$ soldiers,tanks and ships
Their best tank the Canderous Assault tank can hold its own vs an AT AT and its around the size of an abrams , for fleet strength they ave Kedeble class battleships which are around the strength of a star destroyer
As for troops think of an army equipped with disrupters and have the orignal fighting style of jango fett (they are waaay tougher than clones aswell so dont say clone troopers are as good as them)
another side troopr ar noighri assassins theyre elite assassins with disrupters and treat vader like a god
And one type of star destroyer no ones counting is the Destroyer class, it has 2 HUGE cannons that are literally the size of the ship (such as the Merciless and im not sure if its called the destroyer class)

Doctor-Alvis Post-Crisis Balki

You know, AT-ATs don't seem like the best vehicle by themselves. Don't get me wrong, they're impressive and intimidating but Luke himself shows how easily one person can take one out when it's not guarded properly.

Morgromir Senior Member

im talking about head on, full out attack ,defend

and luke had a lightsaber aswell as a chosen target that was entirely ungaurded from behind and unnexpecting

snoopdogg Big Pimpin

Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos
Borg 😐
The Borg were a total failure in every episode I saw.

Doctor-Alvis Post-Crisis Balki

Originally posted by Morgromir
im talking about head on, full out attack ,defend

With one AT-AT?

and luke had a lightsaber aswell as a chosen target that was entirely ungaurded from behind and unnexpecting

A cutting implement is nice, yes, but if you can just climb up it like that all you need is the right amount of explosives at the right point. It's just tactically a bad design in my opinion. Weapons only on the head? No thank you.

jaden101 Restricted
Originally posted by snoopdogg
The Borg were a total failure in every episode I saw.

Clearly never saw "best of both worlds" then.

A single Borg ship annihilated the entire federation fleet.