Originally posted by No End N Site
It does not matter what Dhalsim's path is, to me. He exudes the aura of a an enlightened monk. He is always the 1st to sense evil and always operates above and away from the rest of the cast. This leads me to believe that he is on a level above the average SF.Well I see things differently. Being enlightened and a great fighter are not all that different in the world of SF, since Ryu, who is a great fighter, aspires to have a demeanor like that of Dhalsim, who is also like that of his own master, Gouken.
Being an elighten Monk doesn't put him on a level that pushes him above Ryu. Just because he's spiritually on a higher place then Ryu per say, does not mean that he's a more formidable fighter, otherwise why wasn't Dictator looking for Sim's body to take over, or that the only one to give Gouki his dream match is basically Ryu.
Dhalsim is a fighter, however he isn't a fighter looking to become more powerful in the same mannerism that we are seeing Ryu taking a step towards.
Just simply being enlightened and having the capability to be able to sense evil prior to others does not put him on a fighter level that all of a sudden pushes him above someone like Ryu.
Originally posted by No End N Site
~pertaining to Ryu vs Gouki in the Alpha Series and Alpha Bison
SnH Ryu is basically a Ryu who has given into SnH completely. Their is little to no restrictions here. Within SnH Ryu's ending for a "what if" he would've been powerful enough have killed and beaten Gouki, which is shown in his what if ending had he'd gone Satsui-No-Hadou Ryu. Watch that ending again, it's not regular Gouki, but Shin Gouki who confronts Satsui-No-Hadou Ryu and loses. Again, Gouki is only holding back against norm. Ryu in Alpha is because Gouki wants him to unleash his full potential (Meaning SnH) then only then will he have the true fight that he wants in which he can display his full capability.
SnH Ryu during Alpha would've been very capable of fighting Shin Gouki at this time, because he would've been rivaled him. The A3 What if Storyline showcases this, and displays how powerful SnH Ryu would've been at that time period.
Here is the direct "What If" Ending
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wjzdk_LG1E0
SFIII Ryu is indeed powerful enough at this point to be equal to his SnH version who would've been capable of defeating an Alpha Gouki at that point and time. Obviously of course, Gouki during SFIII has now surpassed this level.
So the idea and though of a SFIII Ryu being capable of defeating Alpha Dictator prior to his Super Elite Mode Alpha 3 version is very possible if his what if storyline shows him even overthrowing a Shin Gouki.
Again, its not like the tier placements that Vasili made for putting Ryu above the characters you mentioned doesn't make sense, when he and a few others have basically done the most homework and the most Capcom Japanese Translations of the Canon Guide/interviews/Game Dialogues to English.
I'm not saying they are right all the time (The Gouken was clone idea was absurd imo by Vasili), however Ryu being above Rose, Gen, and Dhalsim, I can very easily agree with that.
Originally posted by No End N Site
~Pertaining to Oni~
He is not the strongest form of Gouki. Again that translations isn't correct at all, and pertains to his strength within the game mechanics "as the strongest".
Here is the true official Oni Profile...
http://www.capcom.co.jp/sf4/oni.html#character_btn
Here is the Complete Translation from a japanese translator (remember, not perfect english, but you'll get the idea)...
Kyouoshiki Oni; (Mentally Possessed) Oni
Onigami to Pierce the Heavens
The having continued consequence of being exposed to "satsui no hadou", Gouki's appearance transfigured to one completely not of a person. Already now for the flesh and sentiment as a human being almost unremaining, with just a consciousness toward pure-like combat is retaining his shape. For the one who stood before that, to fight entirely the limit of desperate effort maybe, only the option of giving up to die perhaps is not being granted.
Name: Kyouoshiki Oni
Represented nation: unknown
Birthday: unknown
Height: unknown
Weight: unknown
BWH sizes: unknown
Blood type: unknown
Likes: unknown
Dislikes: unknown
Special skill: unknown
Fighting style: none
Ultras include the tenchi soukaigen and the meido gou hadou which has two alternate forms: the messatsu gou zankuu and the messatsu goutenha, and new sure-kill techniques include the gourai hadouken (the only "gou" matching with Goutetsu's name, all others are the same as in Gouki's), the zankuu hadoushou, the akaboshi jiraiken, and the rakan dantoujin. And because it was previously asked and now answerable, his uppercut which looks like a shin shoryuken is named the gou shoryuken.
Even within another interview in which Seth Killian describes Oni as a Gouki within his final "demon" form (notice how he clearly states Demon Form which makes sense considering his name literally means Mentally Possessed).
This again, goes back to what is being noted. Gouki speaks of Oni as is because its Gouki losing his entire will or close to it, and thus Onigami is able to almost completely take over and consume him. Hence why you see Oni speaking in the way that he does. Remember that every time Gouki unleashes SGS he has a chance to fall into the gap of what would turn him into Oni, however when SFIII rolls around, we know for a fact this is not the case.
All of what Oni is what would only happen if Gouki fails at his true purpose of what he's pursuing, much in the same case for a situation to what Ryu would've if he completely succumbed to Satsui-No-Hadou.
That's why Oni is specifically shown again displaying and dispersing his energy with complete and utter instability. Where as Shin Gouki would be capable of all of those abilities without losing control of his energy or abilities is because he is a perfect blend without lack of true thought.
The other reason why Oni is considered weaker then his Z2 version is not just simply because of instability, but also his feat. It's not even as impressive as what holding back Gouki did to his island. Making an already unstable volcano explode while using a significant amount of force in order to do so isn't as impressive as an already weakened Gouki but yet still holding back sinking an island with a strike to the ground.
Oni's ending again reflects what I've mentioned.
Put the two together and it makes perfect sense. Oni-Gouki in his form is nearly consumed by Onigami and can no longer focus his powers while just violently throwing them out because his human will is nearly gone at this point. Where as Shin Gouki at 100% is fully capable of his powers but then has the ability to fully channel his abilities at will.