Spider-man and The Jedi Order

OK, lets say that Yoda and the council were adamant in their stance of not training Anakin. Would Obi Wan really have defied them by training him? Would Obi Wan, as a result, have been expelled from the order?

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
OK, lets say that Yoda and the council were adamant in their stance of not training Anakin. Would Obi Wan really have defied them by training him? Would Obi Wan, as a result, have been expelled from the order?

I don't think the latter. He would have been more Qui Gon Jinn-y, but not been expelled I'd assume.

Pretty much what I was thinking.

Didn't Jin basically tell the council to eat shit and that he was going to train Anakin when they forbid training?

So I don't think the council is all controlling over a Jedi's actions.

Well, I took it as Jinn saying Obi Wan was ready for the trials, and that he would train Annie. But then Jinn told Annie "I'm not allowed to train you, so just watch me."

Oh, I thought Jinn just gave them the finger.

Originally posted by Robtard
Didn't Jin basically tell the council to eat shit and that he was going to train Anakin when they forbid training?

So I don't think the council is all controlling over a Jedi's actions.

Well, I don't think we've seen that much about it in the movies...but I think Jedi do their stuff voluntarily, really. It's not a big corporation that controls all of their "employees". They might be assigned missions, but it's really their choice to take them.

As "Keepers of the peace", wouldn't they be obligated to accept whatever mission assigned to them? I can't see Yoda sitting back and being all accepting if a Jedi says "**** that, I don't feel like going to Hoth."

Do they receive wages for their Jediry?

Originally posted by Robtard
Do they receive wages for their Jediry?

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
As "Keepers of the peace", wouldn't they be obligated to accept whatever mission assigned to them? I can't see Yoda sitting back and being all accepting if a Jedi says "**** that, I don't feel like going to Hoth."

Really? I can picture Yoda doing that very well.

Jedi dont get paid. At least I dont think. Wouldnt that go against the whole "No material possessions" thing?

****, I wouldn't go to Hoth either then.

sissy.

This country IS Hoth right now. 😛

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
As "Keepers of the peace", wouldn't they be obligated to accept whatever mission assigned to them? I can't see Yoda sitting back and being all accepting if a Jedi says "**** that, I don't feel like going to Hoth."

Originally posted by Bardock42
No.

Really? I can picture Yoda doing that very well.

Me too, or Yoda asking someone else.

Hell, I'd do any mission for a damn liter of cola.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Hell, I'd do any mission for a damn liter of cola.

Liter uh Cola, huh?

Well....I'd do anything for a Liter uh Mr. Pibb.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Hell, I'd do any mission for a damn liter of cola.

And you spelling-nazied me for not using a spellchecker...?

Heh. It seems to have let ya down a bit there again.... 😛
See...? Nothings perfect.

No, I am saying I ****ING LOVE COLA.