Silver Surfer vs Thor (Pure Physical Slugfest)

Started by Starscream M5 pages

Silver Surfer vs Thor (Pure Physical Slugfest)

No Mjolnir

No Amping

No Active Powers

Fight inside adamantium stadium.

Who wins?

i am inclined to say the surfer takes the slight majority since thor doesnt have the hammer but thor does have the experience and skill so im not sure!

Without Mjolnir, I'm taking Surfer.

I'm taking Thor.

Thor

Surfer can keep up with or speedblitz Superman.

So he speedblitzes Thor.

Or so I've frequently heard on this board.

Originally posted by Philosophía
Surfer can keep up with or speedblitz Superman.

So he speedblitzes Thor.

Or so I've frequently heard on this board.

I'd say, more technically put, 'bullrush.' Don't think I've ever seen Surfer H2H speedblitz anyone, ever.

Does surfer get his board in this match? If so he wins .If not id give it to thor because of his fighting skills

Originally posted by Enyalus
I'd say, more technically put, 'bullrush.' Don't think I've ever seen Surfer H2H speedblitz anyone, ever.
No, they specifically said that Surfer has the reaction and movement feats off the board to keep up with Superman. They even posted him dodging Hulk (which is an insane feat) and the obviously-not-hyperbole scan with 'I've only got a nanosecond left which shall not pass!!'.

Surfer obviously speedblitzes Thor.

Originally posted by Naija boy
Does surfer get his board in this match? If so he wins .If not id give it to thor because of his fighting skills
no surfboard...sorry for not making the stipulation in my OP

Originally posted by Philosophía
Surfer obviously speedblitzes Thor.

Haha, well if you put it that way, obviously...

Originally posted by Naija boy
Does surfer get his board in this match? If so he wins .If not id give it to thor because of his fighting skills

I don't see Thor being able to physically overpower an angry Hulk as easily as Surfer was able to, or physically stalemating Champion w/ bands. And hell, Surfer also briefly physically held his ground against WM Thor in one of those grappling-type matches Marvel is so fond of depicting before being hurled backwards.

And without Mjolnir, I don't see Thor's blows doing Thanos-like damage sufficient to KO him. Plus as Philosophia's already mentioned, he's got the speed advantage. 😉

Originally posted by Enyalus
Haha, well if you put it that way, obviously...

I don't see Thor being able to physically overpower an angry Hulk as easily as Surfer was able to, or physically stalemating Champion w/ bands. And hell, Surfer also briefly physically held his ground against WM Thor in one of those grappling-type matches Marvel is so fond of depicting before being hurled backwards.

And without Mjolnir, I don't see Thor's blows doing Thanos-like damage sufficient to KO him. Plus as Philosophia's already mentioned, he's got the speed advantage. 😉

Heh. Your determined to make supporting thor difficult arent you? 😛

Ok, i agree that surfer is more durable but i believe that thor has the speed to keep up with him here. Strength wise they are pretty comparable ( maybe edge to surfer if were referring to classic thor). Thor however has the advantage in fighting skills and i think that will be the key to his victory. He has also been a warrior for numerous milleniums and so would be more comfortable in these type of matches than surfer.

Surfer wins this. Surfer owned Abomination pretty easily, took Lunatik too and basically is far too tough for Thor to hurt.

Originally posted by Philosophía
No, they specifically said that Surfer has the reaction and movement feats off the board to keep up with Superman. They even posted him dodging Hulk (which is an insane feat) and the obviously-not-hyperbole scan with 'I've only got a nanosecond left which shall not pass!!'.

Surfer obviously speedblitzes Thor.


What does being on or off his board have to do with his reaction speed?

Usually all of Surfers speed feats are seen on his board. You don't often see him fight one on one, on his own two shiny foot cuffs.

Originally posted by D-Block
I'm taking Thor.

👆

Originally posted by KingD19
Usually all of Surfers speed feats are seen on his board. You don't often see him fight one on one, on his own two shiny foot cuffs.

I know, but how would being off his board dull his reactions? That's like saying that Cyclops isn't as physically strong if his visor's off since you never see feats from him that way...

I never said it would, I was just guessing that someone would think that without his board, Surfer is a little less, Surfer.

Originally posted by KingD19
I never said it would, I was just guessing that someone would think that without his board, Surfer is a little less, Surfer.

Ah ok, I thought you were one of those who liked to claim that mental speed/reaction feats from Surfer were only valid when he was on his board. Forgive me if I was mistaken.

Not a good matchup for the Surfer.