Silver Surfer vs Thor (Pure Physical Slugfest)

Originally posted by darthgoober
Ah ok, I thought you were one of those who liked to claim that mental speed/reaction feats from Surfer were only valid when he was on his board. Forgive me if I was mistaken.

No amping? Surfer is screwed Thor is a way better fighter and he's way stronger at base level Thor stomps I am not a fanboy you guys are insane.

Well of course, since his super speed only pertains to flight, but he can fly just as fast off of his board as on it, it's just that flying without it uses his own energy. And it's not a problem dude.

Originally posted by Starscream M
surfer can't move as fast on foot as he can on his board

Originally posted by Philosophía
Surfer obviously speedblitzes Thor.

Originally posted by Kris Blaze
Not a good matchup for the Surfer.

Originally posted by darthgoober
I agree. Surfer's strength feats are rare enough when amping's included, they're virtually non-existent otherwise.

Yeah.

Fights with odd stipulations that put a character in a position where they have virtually no feats, be it for or against, is just plain pointless.

Thor IMO.

Though not as durable and fast, IMO their strength is at the least comparable, with Thor also having more consistent showings of strength than Surfer, and undeniably being the more skilled physical combatant.

Indeed, the thunder god is right, you see Thor dishing out punishment left and right, but Surfer usually utilizes the Power Cosmic, his own base strength is very rarely seen. Plus, Thor has spent countless years training and fighting hand to hand, while Norrin Radd was a philosopher/scientist before becoming the Surfer, and has stayed much the same.

Originally posted by Kris Blaze
Yeah.

Fights with odd stipulations that put a character in a position where they have virtually no feats, be it for or against, is just plain pointless.

Originally posted by darthgoober
Pretty much. Hey who do you think would win in a chess match between Jonny Storm and Jubilee...

That's a poor example.

Both of them are too stupid to even set up the board.... 😎

Originally posted by KingD19
Indeed, the thunder god is right, you see Thor dishing out punishment left and right, but Surfer usually utilizes the Power Cosmic, his own base strength is very rarely seen. Plus, Thor has spent countless years training and fighting hand to hand, while Norrin Radd was a philosopher/scientist before becoming the Surfer, and has stayed much the same.

Originally posted by Kris Blaze
That's a poor example.

Both of them are too stupid to even set up the board.... 😎

this is funny how people giving Surfer the win
No Amping , No Active Powers which means SS dies bad

heck even with amping i don't see him beating THor h2h

I don't think the Surfer can speedblitz without amping first.

Now it is clear that SS's reactions are better than Thor's and that Thor's fighting skills are better than SS's. Let's assume their strength and physical durability is comparable enough that it won't make any difference in the fight.

While in comics Thor would win, I give this fight to Silver Surfer simply because I believe that superior senses and reactions trumps superior fighting skills most of the time.

The only way Thor can possibly win is if his attack speed is sufficiently in the vicinity of SS's reactions. If so, Thor can distract, feint, and other skillful ploys to offset SS's reaction advantage. After all, SS has done some dumb Sugar Honey Ice Tea like walk into the fists of Thanos.

Now CA beating Spidey is unacceptable to me. Spidey's reflexes at their best are infinitely better (future sense) than CA's and he is also much stronger.

Thus I see this fight similar to that one except that the skill and strength gap is smaller.

Originally posted by h1a8
After all, SS has done some dumb [B]Sugar Honey Ice Tea like walk into the fists of Thanos.
[/B]

Shit are you full of made up shit. The shit you say sometimes, I mean shit. Shitty shit.

Shit.

Originally posted by iceman24567
No amping? Surfer is screwed Thor is a way better fighter and he's way stronger at base level Thor stomps I am not a fanboy you guys are insane.

Surfer doesn't even need to amp to be physically above Hulk and Skaar w/ Old Power and other top tier bricks. Guys Thor usually has difficulty matching up to strengthwise.

Originally posted by Mekrob
Never happened.

Shit are you full of made up shit. The shit you say sometimes, I mean shit. Shitty shit.

Shit.

^ that was beautiful.

Originally posted by Enyalus
Surfer doesn't even need to amp to be physically above Hulk and Skaar w/ Old Power and other top tier bricks. Guys Thor usually has difficulty matching up to strengthwise.