Silver Surfer vs Thor (Pure Physical Slugfest)

His point was that Surfer is stronger dude. 😬

How is Surfer stronger?

I did not say he was, I was merely commenting your response was not an adequate refute to his claim that Surfer is stronger.

I personally believe that they are at least comparable, with Thor having the edge due to more consistent showings of physical might.

wasn't surfer beating hulk in wwh saga?

He sure was little buddy

Originally posted by Starscream M
wasn't surfer beating hulk in wwh saga?

Originally posted by kgkg
nope
he only fought hulk when he<SS> was depowered

Originally posted by Mindset
What?

surfer did give hulk and the warbound a beating while he was depowered..

Originally posted by Slaanesh
surfer did give hulk and the warbound a beating while he was depowered..

Originally posted by Slaanesh
surfer did give hulk and the warbound a beating while he was depowered..

if he did it while depowered, then he would be even more formidable in this scenario

Originally posted by kgkg
he gave hulk a beating you sure? IIRC it was brief and SS was on the ground once hulk was mad and started pounding him.

Originally posted by iceman24567
How is Surfer stronger?

I just said how. It takes everything Thor has to go mono-a-mono physically with the Hulk, for instance. Surfer's easily overpowered him on two occasions (one of which while he was cut off from the PC), beat down Skaar w/ Old Power physically, put Ravenous on his knees, physically stalemated Champion w/ Quantum Bands (who claimed to be stronger than when he possessed the PG), etc.

IMO Current SS is stronger than Classic Thor. Current Thor doesn't really have any strength feats, so...

Originally posted by Starscream M
ok, so then why the hell is everyone selling surfer short in the h2h department

if he did it while depowered, then he would be even more formidable in this scenario

Originally posted by kgkg
he gave hulk a beating you sure? IIRC it was brief and SS was on the ground once hulk was mad and started pounding him.

Well he was beating Hulk and multiple other warbound members phulk olanet hulk. Frankly hulk only got the upper hand when SS stopped fighting.

Originally posted by kgkg
that's the point he didn't

Depowered and cut off from the PC Surfer physically grappled with Gladiator Hulk, then easily overpowered him and tossed him into a wall. This was after kicking the asses of the rest of the Warbound. Then Surfer got ganked by Hulk and Hirom (sp?), got hit once...gave up defending himself, and got smashed again...

While he was trying, Surfer was clearly superior.

Originally posted by kgkg
he gave hulk a beating you sure? IIRC it was brief and SS was on the ground once hulk was mad and started pounding him.

Hulk broke the obedience disc, then he proceeded to beat SS who was no longer fighting back.

Originally posted by Kris Blaze
Yeah.

Fights with odd stipulations that put a character in a position where they have virtually no feats, be it for or against, is just plain pointless.

Originally posted by Naija boy
Well he was beating Hulk and multiple other warbound members phulk olanet hulk. Frankly hulk only got the upper hand when SS stopped fighting.

Your would call that one punch a beating?

Hulk even said Surfer would have killed them all 😬