Take Down Routh Superman

Started by ThunderGodEneru6 pages

Originally posted by Placidity
I think others will be able to tell.

You didn't address any points I've made reagarding Phoenix.

How did you come to the conclusion that Surfer can be knocked off his board by anything other than a tachylon pulse with a very specific frequency?

Did you know Surfer can merge completely with his board?

Did you know Surfer can become intangible?

Indeed they will jerk.

What points? That TK would slow him? She has no TK feats of her being able to slow down as powerful a force as Superman.

Mindrape is too slow for Superman. Not to mention...Phoenix never showed that power in the movies anyway.

Dunno, can't remember too much about FF2, since you know, it sucked, like really bad. But I acknowledge him as the biggest threat.

Originally posted by ThunderGodEneru
Indeed they will jerk.

🙄

Originally posted by ThunderGodEneru

What points? That TK would slow him? She has no TK feats of her being able to slow down as powerful a force as Superman.

Thats pretty much comes down to opinion. I don't think I saw a limit to her telekinesis. Could go either way. But instead of acknowledging that, I see you will go on calling anyone who doesn't see it your way "not very good at comprehending logic" (Jerk).

Originally posted by ThunderGodEneru

Mindrape is too slow for Superman. Not to mention...Phoenix never showed that power in the movies anyway.

I don't think you know the characters well that you are arguing against. In X2 when her Phoenix powers were surfacing she both mind controlled Xavier, prevented Nightcrawler from teleporting, while lifting a jet and stopping a tidal wave at the same time.

In X3, Xavier wasn't able to best her in a telepathic battle.

Originally posted by ThunderGodEneru

Dunno, can't remember too much about FF2, since you know, it sucked, like really bad. But I acknowledge him as the biggest threat.

Well, again you're arguing against a character you are unsure of.

Originally posted by Placidity
🙄

Thats pretty much comes down to opinion. I don't think I saw a limit to her telekinesis. Could go either way. But instead of acknowledging that, I see you will go on calling anyone who doesn't see it your way "not very good at comprehending logic" (Jerk).

I don't think you know the characters well that you are arguing against. In X2 when her Phoenix powers were surfacing she both mind controlled [b]Xavier, prevented Nightcrawler from teleporting, while lifting a jet and stopping a tidal wave at the same time.

In X3, Xavier wasn't able to best her in a telepathic battle.

Well, again you're arguing against a character you are unsure of. [/B]

1. Indeed.

2. We have never seen a limit to Superman's physical abilities, only what he does with them are on a far grander scale than what Phoenix does, so Superman will not be slowed.

3. Got ya fvcker. X2 doesn't matter since the thread starter specified X3. 🙂

As for Xavier being unable to best her, he was unable to mindrape her, she never mindraped anyone in 3. 🙂

4. Not really, I can recall a bit, but not much, hence why I asked you to bring it up

Originally posted by ThunderGodEneru

3. Got ya fvcker. X2 doesn't matter since the thread starter specified X3. 🙂

Yes, Dark Phoenix was only in X3. I'm sure topic starter will allow Jean Grey feats if I ask for clarification 🙂

Why? Considering the canon feats of Reeve's Superman are not allowed for him?

Originally posted by ThunderGodEneru
Why? Considering the canon feats of Reeve's Superman are not allowed for him?

While its canon, its quite obvious its a Superman of a new era. Also, Superman being able to turn back time and all wouldn't be a good idea for any debate topic.

Dark Phoenix couldn't kill Logan. The same Logan that was knocked down by a by a bullet in x2.

Routh, as much as i hate him, lifted a kryptonite continent, caught a plane, and moved faster than many speeding bullets.

If Phoenix can take him down, she didn't show it in the three movies, imo...

Originally posted by Placidity
I've been over this in another topic.

If you click on that post I've explained my take on that.

Edit: @ Raoul

Originally posted by ThunderGodEneru
1. Indeed.

2. We have never seen a limit to Superman's physical abilities, only what he does with them are on a far grander scale than what Phoenix does, so Superman will not be slowed.

3. Got ya fvcker. X2 doesn't matter since the thread starter specified X3. 🙂

As for Xavier being unable to best her, he was unable to mindrape her, she never mindraped anyone in 3. 🙂

4. Not really, I can recall a bit, but not much, hence why I asked you to bring it up

Could we chill on the F*cker name calling, please?

Originally posted by Placidity
How is she weak?

The Surfer is not cannon fodder.

The problem here is that you only see power in terms of strength. Like any other abilities don't matter. Now I would find it easier to accept if your opinion was while those two could be a threat to Superman, his overwhelming feats would be too much for them.

But the idea I'm getting from you is that anyone without superhuman strength is "weak" and Superman wins because he is strong.

If my argument was solely based around strength i wouldn't have mentioned feats that aren't based around strength.

Flying to the bottom of the ocean and into the earth's mantle is about durability. Withstanding water pressures of hundreds of pounds per square inch. Then there's the incredible temperatures of the mantle and lava that had to be overcome.

The surfer, from the movie, is canon fodder. He didn't really show anything capable of defeating Routh Superman.

His strength is obviously important though and from the movies, it's far more than either hulk or the thing. Magneto is irrelevant as all he could do is throw metal objects at superman. Given that a bullet direct to the eye didn't even make Superman blink then i'd say his durability to anything metallic that Magneto could throw at him isn't in question.

Ghost rider is irrelevant because of Supes inherent good. Although i like the idea that they are diametrically opposed...Supes' strength from the sun and GR's being taken by the sun.

Again, DP's powers are limited in the movie. You hear much about her being hugely powerful but see almost nothing.

Originally posted by Placidity
If you click on that post I've explained my take on that.

Edit: @ Raoul

which one?

Originally posted by Raoul
which one?

The quote in the one you quoted lol.

It just explains why I don't think Dark Phoenix was trying to kill Wolverine in that final fight.

Originally posted by Placidity
The quote in the one you quoted lol.

It just explains why I don't think Dark Phoenix was trying to kill Wolverine in that final fight.

i didn't quote any post... 😛

Originally posted by Placidity
Thats pretty much comes down to opinion. I don't think I saw a limit to her telekinesis.

This is a no-limit logical fallacy.

Well it was clearly enough to lift everything but the houses in that street outside where Magneto and Xavier were talking with Grey as a child. Where do you see the limit in such a power...?

...

Lifting an entire continent, can't compare to a man who flew through a black hole.

So. No.

Originally posted by Final Blaxican
...

Lifting an entire continent, can't compare to a man who flew through a black hole.

So. No.

Who's the man who flew through a black hole?

Originally posted by jaden101
Who's the man who flew through a black hole?

Superman in the opening credits flew through a black hole... It was in first person showing his flight from the destroyed Krypton back to Earth.YouTube video

Let's flip this around since it's always "how is Superman going to win".

How are any of them going ot take him down, putting aside that his super-speed would allow him to kill or nullify all of them except for the Surfer quicker than they could think of an attack?

Originally posted by Final Blaxican
Superman in the opening credits flew through a black hole... It was in first person showing his flight from the destroyed Krypton back to Earth.

Not that I don't doubt this Superman couldn't fly through a black-hole and be alright, as even his one weakness isn't that much of a weakness, that is a bit of a stretch.

He was in his spaceship; we don't know what kind of protection that Kryptonian technology provides.